Born, Not Sworn: A Reply to Toby Sumpter on What Makes a Nation

In "What is a Nation?" Toby Sumpter defines a nation as "a covenanted people." Blood, he grants, is part of what a nation is, but it is not what makes a nation a nation. The covenant does that.

The Reformed writers he cites used "covenant" for two particular acts. In the first, a people bound itself to God, promising to worship him as he commanded. That act made the people a church. In the second, a people and its rulers bound themselves to one another under God. That act set up a government and fixed the limits of its power. In both cases the people already existed before anyone swore. It was a party to the covenant, not a product of it. What made it a people in the first place was something else: descent from common fathers, a shared tongue and customs, and lands God had assigned. Sumpter has taken the covenant that founds a church and the covenant that founds a government and treated them as the thing that founds a nation. The sources he names do not support that move, and his own examples show the nation coming first.

Begin with the table of nations, because that is where the older Reformed writers began. Samuel Bochart, whose Geographia Sacra was the standard Protestant work on the subject, said that pagan peoples told fables about springing from oaks or stones. For a true account of the nations he turned to Scripture, which "not only teaches in general that all men were brought forth from one seed ... but also enumerates the grandsons of Noah and the peoples who drew their origin from each one."1 Francis Turretin relied on Bochart for the same conclusion: "from the three sons of Noah descended from Adam, all nations throughout the whole world have been derived."2 John Gill names the marks by which God divided them in Deuteronomy 32:8. God "separated the sons of Adam; one from another; distinguished by the persons from whom they descended, by the tribes and nations to which they belonged, and by the countries they inhabited."3 Descent, tribe and land are the marks. An oath is not among them. That is the sense the Latin carried: natio comes from nasci, to be born.

Israel fits the pattern. Sumpter treats Israel as the model of a covenanted nation, and in one sense it was. But Israel was a nation before Sinai. The very name of the nation was the name of its forefather. Andrew Willet, on Jacob's blessing in Genesis 48, notes that "Israel is taken not for the proper name of Iacob, but for the name of the whole nation that came of him."4 Calvin, opening his commentary on Exodus, reads the multiplying in Egypt as the fulfillment of what God "had promised to his servant as to the increase of his descendants."5 Seventy souls went down, and a nation came out. God's covenant with Abraham was a promise to make a nation out of his seed. The covenant at Sinai then bound that nation to God. It did not create it. Sumpter concedes the point without noticing it. When Jehoiada renewed the covenant, he writes, Judah "was already a nation." A body that existed before the covenant, and went on existing while the covenant lay broken, was not constituted by the covenant.

The best witness against Sumpter is Johannes Althusius, whom he names as an authority. Althusius does describe political life as association by consent. But when he defines who belongs to a people, he puts birth first. "A full Hebrew citizen was one who was born of the seed of Jacob according to lawful descent and was circumcised," he writes, citing Deuteronomy 23. Then he draws the distinction Sumpter's essay lacks. "Full citizenship is either by birth or by adoption." The citizen by birth "is therefore called a necessary and natural citizen." The adopted citizen, received "by the consent and vote of the other citizens," is "therefore called a voluntary citizen."6 Consent, the thing Sumpter calls covenant, is how a stranger is adopted into a people. It is not how the people itself exists. For Althusius the natural citizen is the rule and the voluntary citizen is the exception.

Sumpter's own sources say the same about what the covenant with God produced. He quotes the Vindiciae contra tyrannos on the "double covenant," but the Vindiciae says plainly what the first covenant was for: "The intention of this was, that the people should be the people of God, (which is as much as to say) that the people should be the church of God." The same passage assumes the people already existed as a party able to swear: "if the people had not authority to promise, and to keep promise, it were vainly lost time to contract or Covenant with them."7 So the covenant with God made an existing nation into a church, and the covenant with the king put a government over it. Neither covenant made the nation. Samuel Rutherford's Lex, Rex, which Sumpter also invokes, states the order outright: "the constituent cause is of more power and dignity then the effect, and so the people is above the King."8 The people came first and set up the throne. In Rutherford, covenant is how a people constitutes its rulers, not how a people comes to be.

The New England divines, whose covenant theology is as Reformed as anyone's, made the distinction sharper still. Thomas Shepard describes "a sociall or common covenanting between God and a people," and he says exactly what it produces: "in this covenanting of God with a people, whereby they become a Church."9 The Congregationalists spent a century insisting that being born into a nation does not make anyone a member of a church. Sumpter makes the mirror-image mistake. He takes the covenant that makes a church and says it makes a nation.

Bartholomaeus Keckermann, the Danzig professor whose ethics was taught across Reformed Europe, puts the oath where it belongs. To the magistrate and the fatherland, he says, "we are obligated by a threefold bond, namely: 1. of humanity, 2. of kinship, since the commonwealth contains the welfare of our relatives; and finally, by the special covenant and oath which we have rendered to the magistrate and fatherland as good citizens."10 The covenant is real, and it binds. But it comes third. It is laid on top of a kinship that was already there, and Keckermann says why that kinship matters: the commonwealth holds our relatives.

That leaves Sumpter's strongest evidence, that the covenant was "permeable." He points to the circumcised stranger who was "as one that is born in the land," to the mixed multitude, and to Ruth. Althusius answers the first directly. Proselytes "were citizens of the Hebrew people, insofar as they were able to participate in the synagogues and eat the Passover of the Lord together with the true Hebrews. ... In other respects they were by no means equal to the remaining Hebrews."11 Exodus 12:48 is a law about who may eat the Passover. The proselyte was admitted to the altar. He was not thereby made a son of Jacob. Calvin answers the second. The mixed multitude that left Egypt "were either the offspring of Egypt, or had migrated from the neighboring countries," and when the same phrase recurs in Nehemiah 13:3, they were "separated from the true Israelites, lest all should promiscuously arrogate to themselves the same dignity."12 As for Ruth, she did not enter by oath alone. She entered by marriage into a house of Judah, and Gill notes that Jewish law permitted "females of those nations" to marry Israelites, "provided they were proselytesses, as Ruth was."13 Moabite men were barred for generations under Deuteronomy 23, the same law Althusius cites. Grafting into a nation happened through families, and it took generations. A covenant definition cannot explain that delay. If the oath made the Israelite, the oath would have been enough. A definition by descent explains the delay at once.

Sumpter is right about a great deal, and the tradition backs him. Covenant theology is not social-contract theory, and nations are not propositions. Every nation owes obedience to God and to his Christ, and a people that renews its covenant with God does well. He is right that ancestry is a gift, and right that masses who arrive with no intention of belonging are not joining a nation. On that last point Althusius goes further than he does. He warns that foreigners placed in authority "cannot readily conform to the customs of those over whom they are placed, nor can they easily understand the language of the subjects, or be understood by them," and that a ruler "from the same people" is held "far more dear than a foreigner, as one of their own body."14 Calvin, on Acts 17:26, says God placed men on the earth "that every people may be content with their bounds."15 A nation formed by God through birth, with customs, language and bounds that God set, gives a stronger case for national loyalty and for limits on immigration than an oath that any newcomer can swear.

Sumpter wants a definition that keeps out both the race-hustlers and the globalists, and a covenant definition cannot do it. If a nation is whoever has sworn the oath, then a nation whose covenant is "strained to the point of breaking," as he says America's is, is coming apart, and anyone willing to swear can found it again. The Reformed tradition gave him something sturdier. A nation is a people God makes by birth and settles within bounds. Covenant is the solemn duty that people owes to God and to its rulers. Josiah did not make Judah a nation. He called a nation that already existed back to its God.

Notes

  1. Samuel Bochart, Geographia Sacra (1646), passage 277894. Read ↩
  2. Francis Turretin, Institutes of Elenctic Theology, passage 210355. Read ↩
  3. John Gill, Exposition of Deuteronomy, on 32:8. Read ↩
  4. Andrew Willet, Hexapla in Genesin (1633), on Gen. 48:20, p. 381. Read ↩
  5. John Calvin, Commentary on the Harmony of the Law, vol. 1, on Ex. 1:1–5. Read ↩
  6. Johannes Althusius, Politica methodice digesta (1610), passage 242887. Read ↩
  7. Stephen Junius Brutus, Vindiciae contra tyrannos (English 1648), p. 21. Read ↩
  8. Samuel Rutherford, Lex, Rex (1644), p. 147. Read ↩
  9. Thomas Shepard, A Treatise of Liturgies, Power of the Keys (1653), p. 120. Read ↩
  10. Bartholomaeus Keckermann, Systema Ethicae (1607), passage 506353. Read ↩
  11. Johannes Althusius, Politica, passage 242888. Read ↩
  12. John Calvin, Commentary on the Harmony of the Law, vol. 1, on Ex. 12:38. Read ↩
  13. John Gill, Exposition of Deuteronomy, on 23:3. Read ↩
  14. Johannes Althusius, Politica, passage 242906. Read ↩
  15. John Calvin, Commentary on Acts, vol. 2, on 17:26. Read ↩

Commonplace is a library of 1,277 Reformed and Puritan primary sources, searchable with AI and cited to the page.

Create a Free Account

More from the blog