Primary Source

An Impartial Account of a Late Debate at Lyme in Connecticut

John Bulkley 1729
Bulkley provides a balanced account of baptismal debates at Lyme, summarizing arguments on baptismal subjects, modes, and ministerial support while defending traditional Reformed positions.

EEBO-TCP N02650 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 3142

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 9, in the spelling of this edition.

p. 9CHAP. I. QUEST. I. Whether it be the Will of GOD that some Infants, viz The Infants of Visible Bellevers should be Baptized?

p. 10With respect to 〈…〉 which We Affirmed. They Denyed◊ ◊o that you already see the first thing lying before me for Proof, was the following Position, Viz.

1 P. That it is the Will of GOD that some Infants be Baptized. By some Infants here, was said to be intended the Infants of Visible Believers: And for proof of this, Two Arguments only were offe◊◊d, the former of which you have in the following Syllogisms, Viz.

1. Argument. If there be a Divine Command for Baptizing some Infants, viz. The Infants of Visible Believers, then its the Will of GOD they should be Baptized.

But there is a Divine Command for Baptizing Some Infants, viz The Infants of Visible Believers:

Therefore its the Will of GOD they should be Baptized.

The Consequence of the first Proposition you see admits not of Denial. If there be a Divine Command for Baptizing the Infants of Visible Believers, and Divine Commands are Evidences or Expressions of the Divine Will in any case, then it necessarily follows its the Will of GOD they should be Baptized. Accordingly the Minor or Second Proposition was what Mr Wightman denied, which you see was this, Viz. That there is p. 11a Divine Command for Baptizing some Infants, Viz. The Infants of Visible Believers.

And for proof of this I offer'd,

2. Arg. If there be a Divine Command for Baptizing Disciples of CHRIST, then there is a Divine Command for Baptizing the Infants of Visible Believers.

But there is a Divine Command for Baptizing Disciples of CHRIST:

Therefore there is a Divine Command for Baptizing the Infants of Visible Believers.

For proof of the Minor or Second Proposition, Viz.

That there is a Divine Command for Baptizing Disciples of Christ, I alledged Mat. 28. 19. Go ye therefore and Teach all Nations, Baptizing them, &c. Or as it is in the Original, Go ye therefore & Disciple all Nations, or make them Disciples, &c. This Mr. Wightman owned to be a full proof of that Proposition, and accordingly denied it not; but the Consequence of th◊ Major or First Proposition was what he here denied; saying that tho' there be a Divine Command for Baptizing Disciples of CHRIST, it doth not thence follow there is such a Command for Baptizing the Infants of Visible Believers. For proof thereof the Consequence I said, p. 123. Arg That it availed or was good in case the Infants of Visible Believers are Disciples of CHRIST.

But the Infants of Visible Believers are Disciples of CHRIST.

For proof of which I said,

That if by the Holy Spirit in the Scriptures they are called Disciples, then they are so:

And that they are so called or ◊◊iled in the Scriptures, I Instanced in those words of Peter in the Council at Jerusalem, Acts 15.10. Now therefore why Tempt ye GOD to put a Yoke upon the Ne◊k of the Disciples, which neither our Father◊ nor we were able to bear? Where by the word [Disciples] I said is intended, in part at least, the Infants of Visible Believers, as is manifest from the Yoke there spoken of, as what those false Teachers endeavoured to impose which was the Observation of Circumcision after the manner of Moses, together with the whole Law: This Mr. Wightman denyed, and said it intended only Adult Persons, or such Gentiles as being of Years of Discretion had came over to Christianity, saying that such only of the Gentiles were Circumcised, to prove it quoted Joh. 7.22 — And ye on the Sabbath Day Circumcise a Man. To which Mr. Adams replyed, that by the word (Man) in the Text is intended a p. 13Man or Male Child, & that CHRIST in those words has reference to the custom of the Jews in observing the Law of Circumcision, which was to Circumcise a Child on the Sabbath, when that happened as it often did, to be the eighth day from the Child's Birth which gave rise to that saying among them, Circumcisio pefli◊ Sabbatum.

Reader, Thou see◊◊ ◊he Debate now was about the meaning of this word [Disciples] Acts 15.10.— whether it intend only such Gentile Believers as were Adult, or of Years, or their Seed together with them; and that the whole matter in Controversy was determined by the Resolution of this. Mr Wightman own'd there was a Divine Command for Baptizing Disciples of Christ; and consequently that if the Seed of Visible Believers are Disciples, its the will of GOD they should be Baptized: But this he denied and said that Acts 15 10. did not prove they are Disciples, but by that word intended only Adult Gentile Believers. I affirmed the contrary and said it included their Seed also with them. Here Mr Moderator Hitchcock perceiving matters were like to bear hard on Mr Wightman, came in to his Assistance in this Exigence, & roundly asserted with him that the word (Disciples) in the Text could intend no more than p. 14such Adult Gentiles as had embrac'd Christianity, and to prove it read the preceding Context; in doing which he particularly and with much Emphasis observed to us the Terms [Brethren, Ye, and Them,] in ver. 15 confidently asserting that as those Terms all signified or intended the same Persons, viz. Adult Gentile Believers, so they were the only Persons called [Disciples] ver. 10 To which I replyed it was true that the Brethren spoken of ver. 1. were the only Persons to whom those Judaizing Teachers then taught that Doctrine, and would have perswaded of the necessity of observing Circumcision and other works of the Law in order to Life, but that they were not the only Persons on whom they would have imposed that Yoke was evident from the same ver. with ver. 5. whom they tell us that the taught and would have perswaded them of the necessity of observing Circumcision after the Manner or according to the Law of Moses, and of keeping the whole Law, in order to Salvation. And to set this matter in a clearer light told him the case was this, viz. That as in that day there were both of Jews and Gentiles who by the Preaching of the Gospel were brought over to an Embracement of Christianity, So of the former, viz.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,243 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Start Free Trial to Read

Contents

  1. To the readerp. 1
  2. CHAP. I. QUEST. I. Whether it be the Will of GOD that some Infants, viz The Infants of…p. 9
  3. CHAP. II. QUEST. II. Whether Baptism by Sprinkling of Water on the Subject of it, be Law…p. 55
  4. CHAP. III. QUEST. III Whether the Present way of the Country in Maintaining Ministers by…p. 126
  5. CHAP. IV. The Conclusion.p. 133
  6. The Relation of one, lately Converted from Dreadful ERRORS: As it was given to a Minister…p. 187

Other works by John Bulkley

→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,243 primary sources.