Primary Source

The Doctrine of Final Universal Salvation Examined

William Gordon 1783
Gordon examines and refutes the doctrine of universal salvation, arguing against scriptural support for the claim that all humanity will ultimately achieve redemption.

EEBO-TCP N14182 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 17959

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.

p. 1THE Doctrine of Final Universal Salvation EXAMINED, And shewn to be unscriptural.

INDIFFERENCE to religious sentiments, thought to be of divine revelation, however hastily pronounced a proof of candour, catholicism and good sense, must, upon mature deliberation, appear little other than an affront to the wisdom of that Being, who is supposed to have revealed them.

That the writer of the following sheets pretends not to such indifference, cannot be complained of by those who are endeavouring to spread their own particular tenets, which, though not really novel, are new to the generality of the present generation.

When persons reject doctrines upon the sole plea of their being new, it is warrantable to convince them of their mistake: but it is not the antiquity or novelty of doctrines, that should incline us to receive or reject them—no—but their being, or not being, contained directly or indirectly in the sacred writings. The appeal is to be made to Moses and the Prophets, to the Evangelists and Apostles, for it is the Bible that contains the religion of consistent Protestants, and not the writings of Origen or Clement of Alexandria, or any other uninspired divine.

p. 2Should it be asserted, that our Lord's words in Matthew, when he says, "there be eunuchs who have made themselves eunuchs for the kingdom of heaven's sake," are to be understood literally; and should it be brought in proof, that the pious and learned Origen castrated himself, the argument would produce a sneer rather than conviction.

Whoever consults the first volume of the celebrated Mosheim's Ecclesiastical History, will learn from thence, that Origen and Clement were notorious, for introducing into the church, that "pagan philosophy and vain deceit, (alluded to by Dr. Hartley, but with a different view) and for mingling them with christianity, and so corrupting it." [Salvation for all Men illustrated and vindicated, p. 21.]

Clement of Alexandria, who was the praeceptor of Origen, flourished about the year 206, and lived till towards 220. "His excessive attachment to the reigning philosophy led him into a variety of pernicious errors." [Mosheim, Vol. I. p. 148.] Origen, who died in the year 254, aged 69, enchanted by the charms of the Platonic philosophy, set it up as the test of all religion, and imagined that the reasons of each doctrine were to be found in that favourite philosophy, and their nature and extent to be determined by it." [Mosheim, Vol. I. p. 221.]

p. 2But to dismiss Clement and Origen, and attend to Jeremiah White, chaplain to Oliver Cromwell, who is honoured with the epithets of pious, ingenious and excellent. If these epithets are designed to bias the mind and prejudice the reader, in favour of the chaplain's reasoning, it must be imputed to weakness or craft; but whether lay-craft or priest-craft is immaterial to the case in hand. That the chaplain was ingenious will appear from the following anecdote, which will p. 3also prove at the same instant, that Oliver Cromwell was still more ingenious. Jerry while in a state of celibacy was ambitious of matrimonial connexions with his master's daughter, and laboured privately to gain her affections. Oliver obtained information of it, and, watching the opportunity, enters abruptly into the room where Jerry was upon his knees before his Dulcinia. The sight of him in such a posture led Cromwell to ask the reason of it. Jerry ingeniously answered, that he was beseeching her ladyship to intercede on his behalf, that he might obtain one of her maids of honour (mentioning the name) in marriage. O! crys the more ingenious master, is that all! Well! I will help you out of your difficulty; and immediately summoned the unsuspecting innocent maid into his presence, enjoined her compliance with the wish of the chaplain, and then saw to it, that it was so and the parties married.

But if Oliver's Chaplain was ever so pious, ingenious and excellent, what is that to the purpose? No man is to receive the doctrine of Universal Salvation upon that account; any more than that monster of monsters the doctrine of transubstantiation, because embraced taught and defended by many Papists far more pious, ingenious and excellent than ever was Jeremiah White.

We are told (p. 4) that Mr. White's introduction "breathes a spirit of piety and benevolence," it is not pretended however that this is an argument in favour of a Universal Restoration of the human race; and yet it may serve to captivate silly women, whether in petticoats or breeches, who are ever learning and never able to come to the knowledge of the truth; and to make them believe that he has the true knack of interpreting scripture.

p. 3The only answer, that Mr. White's benevolent rant and rhapsody upon the divine goodness is entitled to, are the following lines of Dr. Young.

p. 4"Not, thus, our infidels th' Eternal draw,

A God all-o'er, consummate, absolute,

Full orb'd, in his whole round of rays complete:

They set at odds heav'n's jarring attributes;

And, with one excellence, another wound;

Maim heav'n's perfection, break its equal beams,

Bid mercy triumph over—God himself,

Undeify'd by their opprobrious praise:

A God all mercy, is a God unjust." [The Complaint, Night iv.]

Having done with Mr. White's introduction we should now proceed to his scripture arguments, which we must suppose have not suffered by being printed in the present form; but it may be proper to lay down beforehand certain principles and rules, to be regarded, while we are interpreting the scriptures, and profess to venerate them as divine oracles.

The writers being inspired by one and the same Spirit, no real contradiction of doctrine can be admitted; and each must be understood in a sense that accords with the whole.

The meaning of particular passages is not to be determined by the sound of words; but the sound of words is to be determined by the meaning of such passages, which must be fixed by the connexion, circumstances, and agreement with other passages.

We must not use a violence in forcing particular senses upon scripture expressions, when we should blush to practise the same with human compositions.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Other works by William Gordon

→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.