Primary Source

The Reasons of Doctor Hill Unmasked

George Abbot 1604
Abbot refutes Catholic theological arguments, demonstrating their weakness and insufficiency in defending papal religion.

EEBO-TCP A16795 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 99836353; STC/Wing STC 37; ESTC S100516

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.

p. 1To D. Hill, as a briefe answere to his two letters prefixed before his booke.

AS he is not to be commended for skill at his weapon, who frameth vnto himselfe a man of straw, and then at his pleasure doth pricke or strike him: so you are not in too high a degree to be thought well of, for your knowledge in Divinity, who in the entrance of your petty worke, do forge vnto your selfe an Epistle put out in the name of other, where-vnto you may say, or not say, what best fitteth your owne humour. You, who can be Fitz-Williams in steede of Hill, are capeable of such a quality; & in composing of your former letter you cannot much dissemble it; when you pretende, your friends, the two Citizens that write vnto you, to be first so learned, as out of [Bud. ex Cicer.] Budaeus, or Tully to call you Opinator vehemens, and secondly so zealous as to seeke to reclaime you from your course: and yet you bring them in, making no mention of Christian perswasion drawn from Divinity, or the word of God; but only multiplying vpō you worldly reasons of Countrey and Parents, and friends, & preferment, and other such like matters. Such of our people as are grounded in Religion, can readily yeeld some account [1. Pet. 3. 15] of the hope that is in them: but such as withall do make show of learning, may be presumed in a matter of this nature would intersert somwhat, which might savour of spirituall contemplation, especially their letter being sent to one of that minde, wherof throughout this treatise you shew your selfe to be. But this devise of your owne seemed vnto you the most cleanly shifte, that by such a [Fighting with a shaddow.] 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 you might haue some colour to divulge your rottē Reasōs; yet taking p. 2heed too, that you vrge not your selfe over-hard, least you might bee deemed more vnwise, then some of your Popish 〈…〉 ◊selues a voluntary pennance, vvill not lash themselues sorer then agreeth vvith their ovvne fancy.

In your Answere to this imaginary Letter, you woulde haue your Reader conceiue in you a most firme resolutiō to persevere in Papistry, since no Parents are so deare vnto you as the father of all fathers. Which iudgment of yours were to be prized at a high rate, if it were certaine and vn-questionable, that you did walke aright. For there is nothing in the world like the pleasing of that e◊e, which [Psa 121. 4. Chrys •… m 23 〈◊〉 G •… n.] neither slumbereth nor sleepeth: and as S. Hierome could say, [•… pist. 8. Tom. 9.] It is better to blush before sinners vpon earth, then before the holy Angels in heaven. But if you mistake your walke, and runne in the way of falshood, in steede of the path of truth; & so depriue your selfe first of the company of your earthly Parents, and then of the comfortable presence of that father which fitteth in heaven; you resolue amisse, and the issues of your race are the issues of death, so that the fruit of your persistance, or pertinacy rather, is no lesse then truly miserable. [Mat. 15. 2.] When the Pharisies stood stifly for the Tradition of the Elders, & S. [Act 22. 4.] Paule was so vehement for his old opinions, that hee persecuted the way of Christ vnto the death: When S. [August de m •… us Eccl Cath 1. 18.] Austen for nine yeares space could not be reclaimed from Manicheisme, they thought they had done well, and verily beleeved, that those their courses were acceptable to the Almighty: and yet indeede they were most displeasing in his sight, most exorbitant from the rule of his commaundements. God iudgeth not by the imaginations and conceipts of men: but according to those prescriptions which he hath laide downe in his word, so is his determination. And whether your opinions doe agree with that his sacred Scripture, vvee shall sift in time and place.

p. 2In one Periode you tell your friends, that they loue you amore concupiscenti◊, rather then amore amicitia, seeking their owne good thereby: yet you adde in the very next sentence, that whatsoever they write or say, you knowe it proceedeth from loue and affection, and fro◊ true am◊, but yet savouring meerely of flesh and blood. Here p. 3wee woulde gladly knowe, howe true amity should be in any, and not amor amicitia. You had neede explane this Paradoxe.

If you were borne and baptised in Popery, it may seeme that your birth was in Q. Maries daies: but how you should receiue confirmation in the same errors, vnlesse it were after your flying beyond the seas, we cannot tell. It is one thing to be generated, another to be regenerated; one thing to haue a birth, another a new birth. And as touching your Baptisme, you should remember that you were baptised into the faith of Christ, not into the beleefe of the Bishop of Rome; who for his owne part shall stand or fall to God, but shall not so answere as to cleere the soules of other. [Epiphanius in Ancorato.] Origen shall not stand by vs in the day of iudgement; neither shall any other so assist vs, as by his protection to savegard vs. Neither is it sufficient to say, that after this or this sort I was baptised, and therefore I will continue in the same; in as much as the Iewe may say so farre, touching his Circūcision in Iudaisme, and the Mahumetane concerning his Circumcision in Mahumetisme: yea the Arrians were baptised in Arrianisme, and other Heretikes receaved that Sacrament after the obliquities of their Heresies. It is ill to begin amisse: but it is worse to persevere in the by-waies of vncertaine errour. Tullie could recount it for a faulte, that [Academicar. Qu •… st. 4.] men in the weakest time of their age, either listning to some friend, or being inveigled by one oration of some body which they have first heard, they iudge of thinges vvhich they knovve not, and looke vnto whatsoever discipline they bee caried as vvith a tempest. vnto it they doe cleave as to a rocke, and never examine vvhether it be right or vvronge. Yet such as these, in their elder yeeres might have saide for themselves; In this have vvee beene conversant even from our youth: therein have vvee had our education; and therefore novve vvee are not to varie from it: This determination had not beene good in Philosophie, neither is the like to it commendable in Divinitie.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. TO THE RIGHT HONORABLE Thomas Baron of Buckhurst Knight of the Honorable Order of the…
  2. To D. Hill, as a briefe answere to his two letters prefixed before his booke.p. 1
  3. AN ANSWERE TO THE FIRST REASON.p. 9
  4. THE SECOND REASON. The name of Catholikes.p. 71
  5. THE THIRD REASON. Vnitie and Consent.p. 87
  6. THE FOVRTH REASON. Conversion of Countreyes.p. 127
  7. THE FIFTH REASON. Largenesse of Dominion, through the multitude of Beleevers.p. 177
  8. THE SIXTE REASON. Miracles.p. 244
  9. THE SEVENTH REASON. Visions, and the gift of Prophecie.p. 282
  10. THE EIGHTH REASON. Scriptures.p. 302
  11. THE NINTH REASON. Councels.p. 331
  12. THE TENTH REASON. Fathers.p. 364
  13. To the Christian Reader.

Other works by George Abbot

→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.