A Calm and Sober Enquiry Concerning the Possibility of a Trinity in the Godhead
EEBO-TCP A44670 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 12198941; STC/Wing Wing H3018; ESTC R10702
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.
p. 1A CALM DISCOURSE OF THE Trinity in the Godhead, &c.
SIR,
I Intend not this Discourse shall be concern'd in what this Author hath said of the several Explications given by the Persons named on his Title-page. The only thing it is design'd for, is the Discoursing with him that single Point which he refers to in his 29th. and 30th. pages, and which in this Controversie, is on all hands confessed to be the Cardinal one, viz. Whether a Trinity in the Godhead be possible or no?
I put not the Question about three Persons; both because I will not, in so short a Discourse as I intend to make this, be engaged in discussing the unagreed Notion of a Person; and because the Scripture lays not that Necessity p. 2upon me, (tho' I do not think the use of that term, in this affair, either blameable or indefensible.)
But I shall enquire whether the Father, the Son (or Word) and the Holy Ghost cannot possibly admit of sufficient distinction from one another to answer the parts and purposes severally assigned them by the Scripture, in the Christian Oeconomy, and yet be each of them God, consistently with this most inviolable and indubitable truth [that there can be but one God.]
This Author concludes it to be impossible in the mentioned Pages of his Discourse, and thereupon seems to judg it Necessary that two of them be excluded the Godhead, as many others (some going the Arian, some the Photinian, more lately called the Socinian way) have done before him. He acknowledges pag. 30. col. 1. there may be
[some Secret revealed by God, because it was above Humane Capacicity to discover it; and sometimes p. 3also to comprehend how it can be]
But adds
[there is a vast difference between my not being able to conceive how a thing should be, and a clear apprehension, and sight that it cannot be.]
What he says thus far is unexceptionable, and I heartily concur with him in it.
But for what he subjoyns, (wherein he might have spoken his Mind of the Matter in Controversie with as much Advantage to his Cause, without reflecting upon his Adversaries, as if they considered these things either with no intention, or with no sincerity, not allowing them even the never so little of the one or the other) that p. 3[three distinct almighty and alknowing Persons, should be but one Almighty, or but One Allknowing, or but one God, a Man (who considers with never so little intention and sincerity) clearly sees that it cannot be. In short, that it is not a Mystery, but (as Dr. South speaks) an absurdity and a contradiction.]
p. 4This is that I would consider with him, if he will affix these words of his [a Man who considers, &c.) clearly sees it cannot be; and it is an absurdity and a contradiction] to the Question as I have set it down above. In the mean time he cannot be ignorant that as he hath represented the matter, he hath here either not truly, (or at least not fairly) given the sense of any of them whom he pretended to oppose.
For when by those words,
But that three Divine Persons, or that three distinct almighty and allknowing Persons should be but one Almighty, but one Allknowing, or but One God,
he would slily insinuate to his unwary and less attentive Reader that the same Men held three Almighties, and but One; He well knows, and elsewhere confesses (tho' he might suppose that some Readers would not be at leisure to compare one place of his Writings with another, but hastily p. 5run away with the apprehension, that such as were not of his mind spake nothing but Nonsense and Contradictions) that not only his later Opposers since P. Lumbard, as he speaks, but divers much more ancient, as Athanasius, and the rest of the Nicene Fathers, &c. deny'd three Almighties, tho' they affirmed each of the Persons to be Almighty, understanding Omnipotency (as they do Omnisciency) to be an attribute not of the person, as such, but of the essence, as such, which they affirm to be but One, i. e. that they are each of them almighty, by communication in one and the same almighty essence. And if their Sentiment be so very absurd, he needed the less to fear representing it as it is.
And the other who seems to grant three Almighties, doth never say there is but one Almighty; tho' such say too there is but One God, placing the Unity of the Godhead in somewhat else, as he hath himself taken Notice; which is remote p. 6from express Self-contradiction also.
p. 6But I shall concern my self no further about the one or the other of these ways of explaining the Doctrine of the three Persons. Only shall enquire concerning the possibility of such a Trinity in the Godhead as was above expressed, requiting the uncharitableness of this Author, in imputing carelesness or insincerity to all, that think it possible, with so much Charity, as to believe he would not (against the plain tenour of Scripture) have rejected the Doctrine of the Trinity (as he professes to do that of the Incarnation) if he had not thought it every way impossible.
And here I premise
1. That the present Undertaking is not to shew that the Father, Son and Holy Ghost are three, and but One, in the same respect, which I would adventure (in this Authors words) to say, no Man that considers with never so little Intention and Sincerity, would offer at. p. 7But when they are supposed to be but One, in respect of Deity, they are thought to be three in some other respect.
2. That what I now design is only to represent this matter as possible to be some way, and in the way here proposed for ought we know, not as definitely certain, to be this way or that. The former is enough to our present purpose, i. e. if any way it can be conceived, without absurdity or contradiction, that these may be three with sufficient distinction to found the distinct Attributes which the Scriptures do severally give them, so as some things may be affirmed of some one, and not be affirmed of the other of them, and yet their Unity in Godhead be conserved, our Point is gained; and the clamour of this (and every other) Opposer ought to cease, for our asserting what every one that considers clearly sees cannot be.
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadContents
- A CALM DISCOURSE OF THE Trinity in the Godhead, &c.p. 1
- Postscript,p. 83
- LETTER I.p. 95
- LETTER II.p. 128
- LETTER III.p. 131
- Summary Propositions, collected out of the foregoing Discourses, more briefly offering to…p. 135
Other works by John Howe
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.