The Reconcileableness of God's Prescience of the Sins of Men
EEBO-TCP A44687 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 11742372; STC/Wing Wing H3036; ESTC R18027
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.
THE RECONCILEABLENESS OF God's Prescience, &c.
Sir,
THe veneration I have long had for your Name, could not permit me to apprehend less obligation than that of a Law, in your recommending to me this subject. For within the whole compass of intellectual employment and affairs, non but who are so unhappy as not at all to know you, would dispute your right to prescribe, and give Law.
And taking a nearer view of the Province you have assigned me, I must esteem it alike both disingenuous and undutiful, wholly to have refus'd it. For the less you could think it possible to me to perform in it, the more I might perceiv of kindness allaying the Authority of the imposition; And have the apprehension the more obvious to me that you rather design'd in it mine own advantage, than that you reckon'd the cause could receiv any, by my undertaking it.
The doubt, I well know, was mention'd by you as other Mens, and not your own; whose clear mind, and diligent enqiry leave you little liable to be encumb'red with greater difficulties.
Wherefore that I so soon divert from you, and no more allow these papers to express any regard unto you, till the p. 1shutting of the discourse, is only a seeming disrespect or indecorum, put in the stead of a real one. For after you have given them the countenance, as to let it be understood, you gave the first rise and occasion to the business and design of them; I had little reason to slur that stamp put upon them, by adding to their (enough other) faults, that of making them guilty of so great a misdemeanour, and impertinency, as to continue a discourse of this length, to one that hath so little leasure or occasion to attend to any thing can be said by them.
WHat there is of difficulty in this matter I cannot pretend to set down in those most apt expressions wherein it was represented p. 2to me, and must therefore endeavour to supply a bad memory out of a worse invention.
So much appears very obvious, That, ascribing to the ever blessed God, among the other Attributes which we take to belong to an every way Perfect Being, a knowledg so perfect as shall admit of no possible accession or increase; and conseqently the Prescience of all future events (as whereof we doubt him not to have the distinct knowledg when they shall have actually come to pass.) Since many of those events are the sinful actions or omissions of men, which he earnestly counsels and warns them against; This matter of doubt cannot but arise hereupon, viz.
p. 2How it can stand with the wisdom & p. 3rity which our own thoughts do by the earliest anticipation challenge to that ever happy Being, to use these (or any other means) with a visible design to prevent that, which, in the mean time appears to that all-seeing eye, sure to come to pass.
So that, by this representation of the Case, there seem to be committed together. Either 1st. Gods wisdom with this part of his knowledg. For we judg it not to consist with the wisdom of a man, to design and pursue an end, which he foreknows he shall never attain: Or 2ly. the same foreknowledg with his sincerity and uprightness, that he seems intent upon an end, which indeed he intends not.
The matter then comes shortly to this summe. Either the holy God seriously intends the prevention of such foreseen sinful actions p. 4and omissions or he doth not intend it. If he do, His wisdom seems liable to be impleaded, as above. If he do not, his uprightness and Truth.
My purpose is not, in treating of this affair, to move a dispute concerning the fitnes of the words [prescience] or [foreknowledg] Or to trouble this discourse with notions I understand not, of the indivisibility, and unsuccessivenes of eternal duration, Whence it would be collected there can be no such thing as first or second fore-or afterknowledg in that duration. But be contented to speak as I can understand, and be understood. That is, to call that foreknowledg which is the knowledg of somewhat that as yet is not, but that shall sometime come to pass. For p. 5it were a meer piece of legerdem◊in only to amuse enqirers whom one would pretend to satisfie. Or to fly to a cloud for refuge from the force of an argument, and avoid an occurring difficulty by the present reliefless shift of involving one-self in greater.
Nor shall I design to my self so large a field as a Tractate concerning the divine Prescience. So as to be obliged to discourse particularly whatsoever may be thought to belong to that Theological Topick. But confine the discourse to my enjoyned subject. And offer only such considerations as may some way tend to expedite or alleviate the present difficulty.
II. It were one of the greatest injuries to Religion, a subversion indeed of its very foundations. p. 6And then by doing which, we could not more highly gratifie atheistical minds, instead, and under pretence of ascribing perfections to the nature of God, to ascribe to it inconsistencies, or to give a self-repugnant notion of that adorable Being, The parts whereof should justle and not accord with one another. And yet eqal care is to be taken, lest while we endeavour to frame a consistent notion of God, we reject from it any thing that is truly a perfection, and so give a maimed one. Whereby we should undo our own design, and by our over much caution to make our conception of him agree with it self, make it disagree to him. For to an absolutely perfect Being, no other can agree than that, which not only is not made up of contradictions, but which also comprehends p. 7in it all real perfections either explicitely, or which leaves room for all, by not positively excluding any of them. Which to do, and afterward, to assign that as the proper notion of God, were, it self, the greatest contradiction. We need therefore to be very warie, lest we pronounce too hastily concerning any thing, which to our most sedate thoughts, appeares simply a perfection in it self, that it carries with it a repugnancie to somewhat else, necessary to be ascribed to him.
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadContents
- THE RECONCILEABLENESS OF God's Prescience, &c.p. 2
- §. II.p. 5
- §. III.p. 11
- §. IV.p. 16
- §. V.p. 24
- §. VI.p. 31
- §. VII.p. 34
- §. VIII.p. 50
- §. IX.p. 54
- §. X.p. 57
- §. XII.p. 64
- §. XIII.p. 67
- §. XIV.p. 74
- XV.p. 78
- §. XVI.p. 81
- §. XVII.p. 87
- §. XVIII.p. 90
- §. XIX.p. 99
- §. XXI.p. 108
- §. XXII.p. 112
- §. XXIII.p. 121
- §. XXIV.p. 123
- §. XXV.p. 128
- §. XXVI.p. 132
- §. XXVII.p. 138
- §. XXVIII.p. 141
- §. XXIX.p. 147
Other works by John Howe
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.