Primary Source

The Doctrine of Sovereign Grace Opened and Vindicated

Isaac Backus 1771
Backus reconciles divine sovereignty with human moral responsibility, arguing that declaring God's sovereignty and human inability need not diminish Gospel urgency.

EEBO-TCP N09388 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 11971

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

THE chief occasion of the ensuing discourse is this: About four years ago, on a view of the prevailing disposition in multitudes, either to pry into futurities, to the neglect of present duty, or to contend about religion, instead of regarding the life and practice of it, while the vanities of time carried the world before them, I was moved to publish a discourse from James ii. 22. with this title, True Faith will produce good Works. And through the whole endeavoured to handle the glorious truths of the gospel in a practical way; and had as little expectation of being publicly attacked therefor as for any thing I ever wrote: And I was not alone in this thought, for a worthy minister in Great-Britain says, in a letter,

Your sermon on the Fruits of Faith is well adapted to silence gainsayers.

Yet how often are we disappointed in this evil world!

p. 6Mr. Daniel Martin, Elder of a Baptist Church in Rehoboth, published a piece last fall, intituled, Some Meditations on the plain Testimony of the holy Scriptures, relating to the elect or chosen of God, &c. wherein, after inserting as a motto our Saviour's caution to take heed how and who we hear, he begins thus:

Having received the foregoing caution and instruction from the most wonderful Counsellor that ever spoke on earth. I have made the following observations on several points of doctrine delivered by Mr. Isaac B—s, in his book intituled, True Faith will produce good Works, wherein he hath made many worthy observations, and given divers good instructions; but to my sorrow he hath advanced several points of doctrine, which appear to me to be in opposition to the sense and pure meaning of the holy scriptures.

And he goes on to bend all his force through his whole performance against the peculiar doctrines of sovereign grace.

Several reasons were suggested, in my own mind and by others, against making any reply to this piece at all: As that it is so plainly erroneous, that it was not likely to do much hurt; that there is no end of controversy; and it is peculiarly disagreeable for one Baptist to contend with another, who have so many others against them on every side. But in answer to this, it appears, that as plain as these errors are, yet many are carried away with them; and though contention is disagreeable, yet if we can see the faith once delivered to the saints betrayed, and hold our peace, how shall we answer it to him who has required us to contend p. 7earnestly therefor? And will not a just view of the last objection turn its weight the other way? For an engine which has been much used, both in the past and present age, to prejudice people against the Baptists, has been to represent them as unsound in gospel doctrine; and now when an aged Elder of that denomination has represented to the world, that to hold, "That faith is not of man," carries in it that p. 7He that is justified by faith, is justified because God hath given it to him; and he that believeth not is damned, because God hath not given him faith;

p. 15. if we let such reproaches against sovereign grace pass unanswered, because in our denomination, what a handle would others make of it, to represent us all either as corrupt in principle, or else more after party than truth? Nay, if those who met their enemies ox or ass going astray, and did not bring it back again, broke a command of God [Exod. xxiii. 4.] ; how can we answer it to him, if we see our friends and fellow mortals going in a way that we are fully convinced leads to destruction, and not attempt, as we have opportunity, to shew them their danger? Paul's earnest desire for the salvation of his brethren and kinsfolk, moved him to take pains to convince them, that, though they followed after the law of righteousness, yet that they did quite miss their way, because they sought it not by faith, but as it were by the deeds of the law. Rom. ix. 22. And as it appears to me that Mr. M—n has missed the right way in the same respect, I think it a duty to attempt in a brief and plain manner to shew him wherein he has done so.

p. 8The grand point which he objects against in my book, is the manner of my holding election: He professeth to hold it; but thinks I hold it in a wrong way. I had observed from Eph. i. 3—7. that Paul says, He hath chosen us, that we should be holy; but the modern notions are, that he chooseth us because we are holy, making that to be the cause, which Paul viewed to be the effect: All the controversy turns upon this point, whether the good pleasure of God's will, or our free will, be the cause of our holiness and happiness. Mr. M—n mentions this, and answers, that both are the cause thereof, p. 6. To prove which, he cites many declarations of God's good will, and then says;

Since it is the good will of God that all men should be saved and come to the knowledge of the truth, what doth hinder, or indeed what can hinder or prevent, but the want of man's good will?

p. 8p. 7. Ay sure enough, what else can hinder? But since that is wanting, how can it be any cause of our salvation? Solomon fays, That which is wanting cannot be numbered: Yet behold! here is one wiser than Solomon! For he can reckon that which is wanting for a principal part of the capital sum! Perhaps it will be said, if it is wanting in one, it may not in another. This I suppose is the thing aimed at, for he says,

By free will I understand good will; when a man's will is to do the will of God.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. PART I.p. 7
  2. PART II. Wherein is opened the Consistency and Duty of holding forth…p. 44
  3. APPENDIX, Containing a brief Account of the Sentiments of the first Baptist Churches in…

Other works by Isaac Backus

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.