A Letter to the Reverend Mr. Benjamin Lord
EEBO-TCP N07511 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 9587
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.
A LETTER to Mr. BENJAMIN LORD, of NORWICH.
Reverend and Honoured SIR,
TO do to others as we would have them do to us, must be allowed to be the universal rule of equity; yet, alas! how far is it from being universally practised? and I have thought that it is often as little regarded in the management of disputes about religion, as in almost any affair at all: a view of which has caused in my mind, these many years, a great cautiousness of engaging in any warm debates: tho' where the cause of truth really calls for it, no doubt there is warrant still to appear in it's defence. Such a call seems now to present itself to my view; for as you, Sir, have lately exerted yourself considerably, to support the cause of the churches and ministry that are established by law in our land, so you have not failed to represent the characters and sentiments of those who have lately dissented therefrom, in very odious, and I believe, in very unjust colours. In your sermon at Mr. Hart's ordination at Preston, 1762, you assert, that
no just cause of withdrawment from your assemblies can be produced,
and ask,
what meaneth this conduct?
which seems to require an answer; p. 4tho' you immediately say,
I only put the question, and leave it to CHRIST and conscience for a decision.
Page 28.—But if it was left there then, yet you, Sir, and six of your neighbouring brethren, have so far taken the case into your own hands since, as that, in a preface which you have added to a new edition of Mr. Dickinson's dialogue about infant baptism, just published, after mentioning the direction to ministers, to blow the trumpet in Zion, and sound the alarm in the holy mountain, and then just touching upon some other evils, which now expose us to GOD'S judgments, you go on to say,
very especially, the error and iniquity of going in the way of Cain, and following the example of the gainsaying of Core, in departing from GOD'S institutions, and without any scriptural warrant, setting up separately themselves.
Page 4. And in page 7, you proceed in sounding the alarm, thus, p. 4Do not the late separations, and one separation from another, already discover their nature by their fruits? in that some have by this time apostatised even from all religion: while some others are renouncing infant baptism, and going fast to the like dreadful apostacy.—It is hid from them, that evil men and seducers wax worse and worse: it is hid from them, or rather, they will not see that they have fell into the way of Cain, and are in danger of perishing in the gainsaying of Core.
Thus Sir, you and your brethren have decided the case with a witness, and if there was no appeal from your judgment, in your own cause, our case would be sad indeed. I say in your own cause; for the whole procedure evidently goes upon this supposition, that your ministers are as certainly right, as those were that Core appeared against, and that your churches in their present order, are as certainly right as those which evil men and seducers departed from in Paul's p. 5time: and if so, then pray who is it that are
in their own esteem, holier and better than others.
NOW as I happen to be one against whom this dreadful indictment is laid, for leaving your church, and since that infant baptism, the law of self-defence will warrant a criminal to speak, before he is condemned; but the nobler principle of regard to the honor of GOD and good of souls, even demand a reply, when truth and reformation are represented by men of note, as error and apostacy, which I believe in my heart is the case here. Therefore, without any further apology, I shall make a few remarks upon some passages in your late writings, and then give some of the scripture grounds and reasons of my sentiments and conduct, in the points which you condemn me for; and so leave it to every conscience to judge, whether that is justly called the way of apostacy or no.
THE first remark that I shall make, is upon page 18 of Mr. Hart's ordination sermon, where you say of CHRIST,
He was sent as well as furnished, (see Luke iv. 18, 19) and so must we be; else the disciple covets to be above his master; which is the case with those that imagine the fullness of the spirit (or singular gifts) which they think they possess, doth warrant their assuming the character, and entering on the work of ministers of CHRIST.
p. 5In this, I suppose, you have some reference to what I have said on that point in my discourse on an internal call to preach the gospel; but I am sorry you had not stated it more fairly. We don't argue that persons have a warrant to enter into the ministry, merely from their having singular gifts; but we are of opinion, that those to whom GOD has given grace and singular gifts, he commands to improve them: p. 6his command is very express, As every man hath received the gift, even so minister the same one to another, as good stewards of the manifold grace of God, &c. 1 Pet. iv. 10, 11. Rom. xii. 6—8. And we believe that the spirit of GOD, by light and truth, must make that clear to the soul, in order for their going forth; and that his teachings and call, gives warrant sufficient to go upon and improve the gifts which he has given, and that will open the way for their being introduced and ordained in the church of CHRIST. You go on to say,
And what great confusion doth this tend unto? would it not tend to throw the STATE into confusion if any man that would, might set up for a civil magistrate, who thought himself fit, and could find a party to encourage and follow him? and why should it not tend to make the same mischief in the church?
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadOther works by Isaac Backus
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.