Primary Source

An Answer to the Observations upon the Conduct and Behaviour of the Methodists

George Whitefield 1744
Whitefield's detailed defense of Methodist practices against ecclesiastical criticism, presented as letters to English bishops and constituting an important primary source for understanding early Methodist theology and church relations.

EEBO-TCP N04452 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 5515

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 3, in the spelling of this edition.

p. 3OBSERVATIONS Upon the Conduct and Behaviour of a certain Sect, usually distinguished by the Name of METHODISTS.

IT does not appear, that any of the Preachers among the Methodists have qualified themselves and the Places of their Assembling, according to the Act of Toleration; which Act warrants separate Assemblies for the Worship of God, that before were unlawful.

The unbounded Licentiousness in holding Assemblies for Divine Worship, both as to Persons and Places, which had prevailed for some Years before the Restoration, and of which our Histories are full; was a sufficient Warning to the Legislature, to have a watchful Eye over that Spirit, which had caused so much Confusion in the Kingdom; and particularly in the publick Worship of God. And the Methods taken from Time to Time to keep-under that Spirit, and to prevent and suppress all such irregular Assemblies, are a plain Evidence, that the Government, in those Days, saw the mischievous Consequences of them, and the Necessity of putting early and effectual Restraints upon them. And though, at the Revolution, the Wisdom of the Nation, for some Ease to scrupulous Consciences in the Exercise of Religion (as the Words of the Act are) granted an Exemption from the Penalties of former Laws, both to Preachers and People; yet it is plain, that they saw the mischievous Consequences of granting that Indulgence, without such Conditions and Limitations, as would be a Security to the Established Government and Religion, against the Advantages it might otherwise give to the Enemies of both.

And therefore the Act of Toleration provides, as to the People, that none shall have the Benefit of it, but such as will take the Oaths to the Government, and subscribe the Declaration against Popery (30 Car. II, c. 1;) and as to the Preachers, it obliges them, not only to take the said Oaths and subscribe the Declaration, but also to subscribe the Thirty-nine Articles of Religion; those excepted, which relate to Ceremonies, Homilies, the C◊nsecra◊◊◊◊ of Bishops, and Infant Baptism.

p. 4II. But now, this new Sect of Methodists have broken-thro' all these Provisions and Restraints; neither regarding the Penalties of the Laws which stand in full Force against them, nor embracing the Protection which the Act of Toleration might give them in Case they comply'd with the Conditions of it. And if this be not an open Defiance of Government, it is hard to say what is.

They began with Evening-Meetings at private Houses; but they have been going on, for some Time, to open and appoint publick Places of Religious Worship, with the same Freedom, as if they were warranted by the Act of Toleration. And, not content with that, they have had the Boldness to preach in the Fields and other open Places, and by publick Advertisements to invite the Rabble to be their Hearers; notwithstanding an express Declaration in a Statute (22 Car. II. c. 1.) against assembling in a FIELD, by Name. And how big with Mischief that Practice in particular is, may be abundantly seen in the past and present Accounts of it in a neighbouring Nation; and may be sensibly felt in our own, when it will be too late to remedy it, if not attended to in Time.

III. It must be confessed, that in most other Steps which the Methodists take, the Act of Toleration would be a Security against the Penalties of former Laws, if they would but qualify themselves according to the Direction of it; but in the Case of Field-preaching, it is conceived that it would not secure them. For that Act not only requires the Qualifications of Oaths and Subscriptions as above, but also provides, That no Congregation or Assembly for Religious Worship shall be there◊y permitted ◊r allowed, until the PLACE of such Meeting shall be certified to the Bishop of the Diocese, or to the Archdeacon of the Archdeaconry, or to the Justices of the Peace at their General or Quarter Sessions.

And it would be a strange Construction to give any other Meaning to the Word PLACE in that Clause of the Act, than a particular House opened for Religious Worship, and a fix'd Place to be repaired-to by a Congregation of Dissenters; in which Sense it has been universally understood. And indeed the Act of Toleration itself plainly leads to this Meaning, when it forbids any Assembly of Persons, dissenting from the Church of England, to be had p. 4in any PLACE for Religious Worship, with the Doors lock'd, barr'd, or bolted.

Nor has it been known, that a Dissenting Teacher of any Denomination whatever, has thought himself warranted, under the Act of Toleration, to preach in Fie◊◊s, or Streets.

IV. But notwithstanding such open Inroads upon the National Constitution; these Teachers and their Followe◊ affect to be thought Members of the National Church, and do accordingly join in Communion with it; though in a Manner that is very irregular▪ and contrary to the Directions laid down in p. 5the Rubrick before the Communion-Service; which is established by the Act of Uniformity. This Rubrick directs, as follows:

So many as intend to be Partakers of the Holy Communion, shall signify their Names to the Curate, at least some Time the Day before.

And if any of those be an open and notorious evil Liver, or have done any Wrong to his Neighbours by Word o◊ Deed, so that the Congregation is thereby offended; the Curate, having Knowledge thereof, shall call him and advertise him, that in any wise he presume not to come to the Lord's Table, until he hath openly declared himself to have truly repented, and amended his former naughty Life, that the Congregation may thereby be satisfied, which before were offended: and that he hath recompensed the Parties to whom he hath done Wrong, or at least declare himself to be in full Purpose so to do, as soon as he conveniently may.

The same Order shall the Curate use with those betwixt whom he perceiveth Malice and Hatred to reign; not suffering them to be Partakers of the Lord's Table, until he know them to be reconciled.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. PREFACE TO THE READER.
  2. OBSERVATIONS Upon the Conduct and Behaviour of a certain Sect, usually distinguished by…p. 3
  3. To conclude this first Part.p. 8
  4. PART II.p. 9
  5. A LETTER To the RIGHT REVEREND The Bishop of London, &c.p. 3

Other works by George Whitefield

→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.