Open Communion Examined
EEBO-TCP N16830 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 21665
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, from p. 5, in the spelling of this edition.
p. 5SECTION I. Remarks on the unfriendly aspersions cast upon the Baptists, for refusing communion with other denominations—The gospel doctrine of a church, and qualification of the members—With strictures on Baptism.
THE Baptist churches in general, have long been blamed for holding and practising what is commonly called close communion, as if wholly inconsistent with christian charity, or that mutual forbearance which the gospel requires: and by some it is considered as incompatible with the existence of grace; and for which we have been loaded with many reproachful names.
WE are charged of making the want of a little water only, a bar to communion; and that we are so superstitiously fond of the watery element, that we place the whole of our religion in what they call a mere circumstance of the ordinance of baptism: and some even assert, that we hold that none can be saved without being immersed. And that thereby we put baptism in the place of redeeming blood.
BUT why such unfriendly charges? Surely they greatly impeach our doctrinal principles, and are perfectly inconsistent with our avowed sentiments and constant practice.
FOR it is too notorious to admit a plea of ignorance, in any of our opponents, that we consider no p. 6one as a proper subject of baptism, who does not profess repentance towards God, and faith in our Lord Jesus Christ; who does not, in other words, appear to be in a state of salvation.
NAY, so far from making baptism a saving ordinance, we do not, we cannot, consider any one as a proper subject of it, who looks upon it in that light.
BUT however, we desire to pay a proper deference to that, as well as any other of Christ's institutions; and not to treat it as though it was left to our choice, either to practise or omit it: although we do not consider it as essential to salvation, yet it is essential to the visibility of a gospel church; and to consequently to communion at the Lord's ◊able; for that is a church ordinance, and ought never to be administered but to members that are in special covenant.
p. 6I AM persuaded that the Baptists are not the only people who believe baptism to be a pre-requisite to the Lord's supper.
WAS a Turk to be brought from Mecca to America, and here should be convinced o◊ Mahomet's imposture, and become a true convert to christianity, immediately after should attend at a Paedo-Baptist church, it being one of their stated seasons to celebrate the sacred supper; the solemnity attracts his mind, he sees the beauty of the ordinance, and desires to partake in it. Will they permit him? I am persuaded they will not. But what are their reasons? Is it because they do not look upon him as a Christian? No, for they really do. But do they not believe God has received him? Yes, they do. But do they not believe Christ communes with p. 7him spiritually? They do. How can they then shut him off? Doubtless, because they view him to be no baptized, and not a member of any church. Their conduct in refusing him, would be consistent with the tenderest feelings of christianity. Therefore we do not commune merely as Christians, but as such in a regular, visible, standing.
BUT to illustrate the point further, suppose a minister of Christ was providentially in one of our new towns where were a number of inhabitants, respectable on other accounts, but had never been baptized in their infancy, nor had any church been gathered in the place—he is invited to preach—his labours are so far succeeded, that in a few days considerable numbers are hopefully brought to the knowledge of the truth—the next Lord's day they desire him to break bread to them. What will he do? Why, it free communion is to be established, here is a good opportunity for it to operate in its full latitude; for if it be lawful and right to break bread to one that is unbaptized, it may be to a whole society. But however, if he be a Paedobaptist minister, I presume he will not be guilty of such an irregularity: nor would a consistent Baptist. And I feel safe to conclude, that our Paedobaptist brethren would not blame us for refusing communion with such a society, who did not submit to baptism in some mode or other, however amiable their christian characters might appear in other respects.
p. 7IF they would acquit us from blame in the foregoing instance, why should they fault us for refusing communion with those that we verily belive have p. 8never been baptized according to Christ's institution: for, agreeable to an ancient writer, "They who are not rightly baptized, are, doubtless, not baptized at all [Baptismum quumt 〈…〉 dubio non habent. Turtil. de baptismo, cap. xi. page • 30.] ." Wherefore we conclude, that communion does not belong to christians merely as such, but to them as baptized members of some gospel church.
NEITHER yet should we be quite safe to open our doors for communion, to all who are in a church state, and profess to be baptized.
Therefore, it will be necessary in the next place, to attend to the scripture account of the Faith and Order of a Gospel Church.
A GOSPEL church must be built upon a gospel plan. Therefore, if we look into the scriptures, we shall easily perceive, that the church is a society of saints, and faithful men and women in Christ Jesus, that are joined together in holy fellowship, that are incorporated into a visible church-state, and by agreement meet together to carry on the worship of God, to glorify him, and edify one another.
THE church does not appear to be national, provincial, or parochial; but truly congregational. It is not built of dead materials, but of lively stones [1 Pet. ii. 5.] ; each of them fitted before they are laid in the building, "so that there is neither hammer nor axe heard in all the house while it is in building [1 Kings, vi. 7.] ." how wonderful! how superb! and yet how exact the model, so that there needed no alteration to bring them altogether with that exactness, that bone comes to its bone.
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadContents
- PREFACE.
- SECTION I. Remarks on the unfriendly aspersions cast upon the Baptists, for refusing…p. 5
- SECTION II. The impropriety of the Baptist Churches communing with those of other…p. 22
- SECTION III. The arguments for free comraunion considered—others offered in vindication…p. 32
Other works by Thomas Baldwin
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.