Primary Source

That There Is But One Covenant

Joseph Bellamy 1769
Bellamy's theological treatise defending the single covenant of grace against emerging doctrines of external graceless covenants.

EEBO-TCP N08741 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 11174

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

A DIALOGUE between a MINISTER and his PARISHIONER, concerning the HALF-WAY-COVENANT.

Parishioner.

SIR, this third visit I am come to make you, for I have lately read a piece, printed at New-London, entituled, "A dialogue between a minister and his parishioner, concerning the half-way-covenant continued;" said to be written by one of the most learned and ingenious ministers in the colony. I hope, therefore, now, if ever, by the assistance of such a patron, to be able to carry my point,—Instructed by him, I give up the half-way-covenant; I grant there is but one covenant. I give up the half-way-practice too, as founded only in ignorance, and the mistaken notions of the vulgar. I am convinced, that he that is qualified to have his children baptized, is equally qualified to come to the Lord's-table.—I come, therefore, to claim baptism for my child, and a place at the Lord's-table for myself, as my proper right. p. 6.—However, I am not well pleased at the publication of our discourse in my first visit, altho' I must confess you have given a fair representation of what passed, because being very dull at that time, I make but a very indifferent figure in the eyes of the public. p. 2.

Minister.

Be comforted, my friend, no blame is laid on you by the public. I bear it all; and I am willing to bear it for your good: and methinks you have only cause of joy and thankfulness; for, to be convinced, so soon, of your mistake, is no small favour. No doubt the voice of the clergy, who practice the half-way, declaring as one man, that he, who is qualified to offer his child, to baptism, is equally qualified to come to the Lord's-table, has wrought your conviction; for your former faith and practice were p. 4grounded merely on the custom of the country: this led you to think, that the Lord's-supper was more holy than baptism. But while you hear all the ministers, with whom you converse, declare, they mean no such thing; they practise the half-way only in condescention to the ignorance and groundless, unscriptural scruples of the common people, you are convinced; you give up the point: you own the command of Christ, do this in remembrance of me, is binding on all his disciples.—But, pray, upon what grounds, do you now so boldly claim baptism for your child?

Altho' I was "uncommonly dull and muddy," in my first visit; yet

you know, sir, what I wanted was to have my child baptized. As you told me there was but one covenant, so we were agreed, that I had entered into that covenant, the very same covenant that you entered into three and thirty years ago, when you was admitted into the church. And, sir, why may I not have the seal of it set upon my child? p. 4.

Did not I expressly tell you, that

If the covenant owned is the covenant of grace, and if the parent acts understandingly & honestly in the affair, he is a good man, he has a right before God to baptism for his children, and an equal right to the Lord's-supper? But that if the covenant owned is not the covenant of grace, those who have owned it, have in the sight of God no right to either of those ordinances which are seals of that covenant, and of no other: no more right than if they had given their assent to any chapter in the aprocrypha?

True, you did so—and there is but one covenant, says my patron.

This covenant then is the covenant of grace, which, we are all agreed, requires repentance toward God, and faith toward our Lord Jesus Christ: or else there is no covenant of grace at all—for he says there is but one.—But lay your hand upon your heart, and tell me the truth honestly, did you mean to profess repentance toward God & faith toward our Lord Jesus Christ, when you owned the covenant? or in other words, did you mean to profess a compliance with p. 5the covenant of grace? Pray, sir, recollect and repeat the very words you spake to me in your first visit.

You make me blush—for I told you the truth in my first visit, from the bottom of my heart; and this is what I said,

I knew myself to be unconverted.—I meant to own the covenant, as the phrase is, and have my children baptised; but I had no design to profess godliness, or to pretend a real compliance with the covenant of grace. This godly people may do; but it had been great hypocrisy in me to do it. To lie to men is bad, but to lie to God is worse. I supposed that owning the covenant was what the unconverted might do.

p. 5These were my very words: and on these principles I acted, as do all others, that I am acquainted with, who own the covenant, have their children baptised, and do not come to the Lord's table; and I verily tho't this was right before my first visit.

How is it possible a man, so honest as you then appeared to be, should now act such a dishonest part, as you have done? It is my duty as a minister of Christ, to rebuke you sharply; for then you told me, as you now own, that you did not mean to profess a compliance with the covenant of grace, upon which I denied baptism to your child; and yet just now you pretended you did mean to do it.—You have need to blush—This deliberate dissimulation in such an affair, is no small crime. Did your learned patron advise you to this step, to get your child baptised? Is this the way to obtain God's blessing?

Be this as it may, I am willing now to make a profession, and publickly to enter into covenant with God, and I have no objection against the form used in your church. I can make that covenant, and speak truly in the sight of God, notwithstanding I know I have no grace. p. 6, 7.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. A DIALOGUE between a MINISTER and his PARISHIONER, concerning the HALF-WAY-COVENANT.p. 4
  2. The PREFACE.
  3. SECT. I. The nature of Mr. M's external, graceless covenant it's difference from the…p. 6
  4. SECT. II. The Covenant with Abraham was a holy covenant, and could not be really complied…p. 9
  5. SECT. III. The covenant with the Israelites in the wilderness was a holy covenant, and…p. 19
  6. SECT. IV. The Gospel of Christ essentially different from Mr. Mather's external…p. 34
  7. SECT. V. Baptism and the Lord's Supper, are seals of the covenant of grace, and of no…p. 41
  8. SECT. VI. It cannot be determined what Mr. M's external covenant requires, and wherein a…p. 48
  9. SECT. VII. Various distinctions stated, to render the subjct more easy to be understood…p. 54
  10. SECT. VIII. Mr. Mather's scheme inconsistent with itself.p. 66
  11. THE CONCLUSION.p. 79

Other works by Joseph Bellamy

→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.