Primary Source

Gospel Order Revived

Benjamin Colman 1700
A defense of congregational church order by New England ministers responding to Increase Mather's ecclesiastical proposals and polity arguments.

EEBO-TCP A34020 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 12715731; STC/Wing Wing C5399; ESTC W13238

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.

p. 1Quest. 1. Whether particular Churches ought to consist of Saints and true Believers in Christ?

It is granted that the matter of a particular Church (for the Question is not stated with reference to the Catholick) is visible Saints. And tho' the Answer is not given in the words, yet we would charitably hope his sense is the same, with the united Ministers in London.

That none shall be admitted as members in order to Communion, in all the special Ordinances of the Gospel, but such as are knowing and sound in the fundamental Doctrines of the Christian Religion, without scandal in their Lives, and to a judgment regulated by the word of God, are Persons of visible Godliness and honesty, credibly professing cordial subjection to Jesus Christ.

Had our Reverend Author only said thus much (and indeed more is needless) he had saved us the labour of any Reflections on this part of his Essay. But there is one passage in p. 15 which we cannot but except against.

A Scripture, saith he, which has respect in the times of the Gospel, severely rebukes those Ministers, which shall bring men that are uncircumcised in bear◊ (unregenerate persons) into the sanctuary, into the Church of God, to eat the Bread and drink the Blood, which 〈…〉y that are there, partake o◊, Ezek. 44. 7, 9.

A hard saying, and w◊o can ◊ear it. The Text is here mangled, and the principal things left out. What God has joyned, our Reverend Author has seperated, to drive on his design. The Text saith Uncircumcised in heart, and uncircumcised in flesh: but here we have it only uncircumcise in hea◊t, interpreted unregenerate persons. What a rebuke is this to the best of Ministers because (forsooth) they are not heart searchers, and dare not invade the prerogative of God. Did the Reverend Author or the Church with him, never admit any un〈…〉 ◊erate p. 2Person to communion with them? He will not dare to pretend to it, and therefore the rebuke is to himself. We know our Lord Jesus Christ admitted Judas uncircumcised in heart, an unregenerate Person to holy things; and in the purest Ages of the Church there were Hypocrites crept in, many of whom turned Apostates. Nay, our Author is so sensible of this, that p. 19. he quotes the opinion of the Reverend M. Co◊ton, That its better to admit diverse Hypocrites than to keep out one sincere Child of God. It is obvious then that Hypocrites may be admitted, and yet the Minister incur neither the rebukes of Conscience, or of this Scripture: nay, he may be approved of God, as doing his Duty, though Hypocrisie may too well consist with sufficient Knowledge found belief, a blameless Life, a credible Profession, &c. To conclude, Its very observeable, the Reverend Author closes this first Enquiry, by saying, That the Churches here are free to admit those into their communion, who are thus qualified. We marvel then his Zeal is not stirred to rebuke them afresh.

p. 2But what will the Reader think if we should make an Apology after all for the Reverend Author, and assure him he means no more, than that Ministers ought not to admit known Infidels or Prophane; for, for his part, he pretends not to know mens hearts. We only can intreat the Reader not to rebuke the Author too severely for his inconsistency, for he may mean well, and all parties are agreed. Unless he should imagine himself attacqued by the Reverend Author of the Doctrine of instituted Churches.

p. 2Q 2. Whether there ought not to be a Tryal of Persons concerning their qualifications and fitness for Church communion, before they are admitted thereunto?

We shall not here examine the force of the Authors arguments, whether they unresistably conclude, or not; and whether the consequence is good from the tryal of the Apostles, the Porters at the Temple, or the 12 Angels at the Gates of the Mystical Jerusalem, to the tryal of Church Members. It suffices that the Reverend Author has modestly stated this Truth, and cited us to a merciful Bar, the judgment seat of a rational Charity, where the Judge avoids severity, and the tryal is managed with abundant tenderness: the p. 3bruised Reed is not broken, nor the smoaking flax quenched: the tender Lambs find the kind Shepherds Arms to fold them, and a gentle carriage in his bosom. This is indeed the part of the good shepherd, and we could now gladly commit our selves to the Reverend Authors Pastoral care. So many good words remove all jealousie of a rigid Tryal. But alas! the Clouds return upon us, and a black doubt is started, as follows.

p. 3Q 3 Whether are not the Brethren, and not the Elders of the Church only, to judge concerning the qualifications and fitness of those who art admitted into their Communion?

The Reverend Author allows there may be a difference of apprehension, as to this point, and yet no breach of Union. We think so too, and therefore as we continue to honour the Person, though we expose his opinion; so we ◊o◊◊ the negative will not dele◊ve the popular cry, Oh Apostacy! Apostacy! The difference, as the Reverend Author tells us, is between the Brethren of the Presbyterian and the Congregational way, the former giving this power only to the Eldership, the latter joyning the fraternity with them. He takes up for the latter; but whether he proves it, the world may see when we have considered his Arguments.

In the fore-going Chapter, when he would prove there ought to be a tryal of Persons, he tells us of the Porters that were set ut the gates of the Temple, 2 Chron. 23. 19 but those Porters were Officers 1 Coron. ◊6. 1. so he Instances in the Twelve Angels at the Gates of the Mystic〈…〉 Jerusalem, which tho' it may imply that the G◊◊es were kept, yet not that the fraternity were the keepers. He instances also in Phillip and John the Baptist, which if it argues any thing, is applicable only to the Officers, and not in the Brother-hood.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. Advertisement.
  2. The Epistle Dedicatory, To the Churches of Christ in N. England.
  3. Gospel Order Revived, &c.p. 1
  4. Quest. 1. Whether particular Churches ought to consist of Saints and…p. 1
  5. Q 2. Whether there ought not to be a Tryal of Persons concerning…p. 2
  6. Q 3 Whether are not the Brethren, and not the Elders of the Church…p. 3
  7. Q. 4. Whether is it necessary t • at Persons at their admission into…p. 6
  8. Q • . 5. Hath t •• Church Covenant, as commonly practised in the…p. 9
  9. Q. 6. Is publick Reading of the Scriptures, without explication or…p. 13
  10. Qu. 7. Is Baptism to be administred to all Children, whom any…p. 16
  11. Qu. 8. Is Baptism in a private House, where there is no Church…p. 17
  12. Q. 9 O • ght all that contribute towards the maintenance to have the…p. 18
  13. Qu. 10. Is it expedient that Churches should enter into a Cons •…p. 20
  14. Qu. 11. May the Brethren in Churches, and not the Pastors only, be…p. 21
  15. Qu. 12. Doth the Essence of a Ministers Call consist in his being…p. 22
  16. Q. 14. Is the Practice of the Churches of New-England in granting…p. 28
  17. Qu. 15 Is not the asserting that a Pastor may administer the…p. 29
  18. Qu. 16. Is it a Duty for Christians in their Prayers, to make use of…p. 31
  19. Qu. 17. May the Churches under the Presbyterian and Congregational…p. 34
  20. Postscript.p. 37

Other works by Benjamin Colman

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.