Primary Source

An Examination of and Some Answer to a Pamphlet Intitled a Narrative and Defence of the Proceedings of the Ministers of Hampshire

William Cooper 1736
Cooper's 1736 defense of ministerial approval for Breck's settlement at Springfield against Hampshire ministers' disapproval and procedural objections.

EEBO-TCP N03282 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 3996

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

An Examination of AND some Answer to THE Hampshire Narrative & Defence.

THE Case of the first Church and Parish in Springfield, with Respect to the Settlement of the Rev. Mr. Robert Breck in the pastoral Office among them, has indeed made a great Noise through the Country; and the Conduct of those who have been immediately concern'd, approv'd or blam'd, according to the Information Persons have received, or as they have stood affected to one or other of the acting Parties. But the extraordinary Noise has been occasioned by the extraordinary Methods taken to hinder the said Settlement, in direct Opposition to those Liberties of the Churches, which are confirm'd to them by Law, and they have been in the constant Use and Exercise of. If the Reverend Gentlemen in the County of Hampshire, who disapprov'd of Mr. Breck s Settlement at Springfield, could but have thought they kept themselves pure, by forbearing to act in it themselves, and sending their formal p. 2Protest against it, and then left those call'd by the Church to judge in the Affair, (of which Number were the Eldest Ministers in their own County) to have acted according to their Light & Consciences, without employing the secular Arm upon the Occasion, much of the Noise had, to be sure, been prevented. Or if after the strange Interposition of some in civil Authority, to which we have very good Grounds to think the disapproving Gentlemen of the sacred Order were accessary, they could have been contented to have let the Matter remaind the Subject of Conversation only, without runing it into the public Prints, the Noise had been still much less, and the Censures bestow'd on either Party fewer and milder. But not thinking enough was done to blacken Mr. Breck, and bring an odious Imputation on the Council, by the two Letters publish'd in the Boston Journal, [Here it may be remark'd, That these Letters were publish'd the Day before the Complaint of the Church in Springfield was to be heard in the Honourable House of Representatives, and were industriously put into the Hands of the Members, no doubt to prepossess them, that nothing might be done in Favour of the Church or Mr. Breck. A Specimen of their fair way of managing!] by these Gentlemen themselves, or some Body that undertook their Vindication, before any Thing had been publish'd on the other Side of the Question, they have now thrust into the World a remarkable Piece, containing about seven Sheets; intitled, A Narrative and Defence of the Proceedings of the Ministers of Hampshire, who disapprov'd of Mr. Breck's Settlement at Springfield. And because Vis unita fortior, it is said in the Title Page to be Written by themselves. The Text of sacred Scripture with which this Page is grac'd, is certainly very pertinent and well chosen, viz. that Passage of the wise Solomon, "He that p. 3unswereth a Matter before be heareth it, it is Folly and Shame unto him". It may therefore well be suppos'd those into whose Hands their Narrative has been put, have suspended their Judgment, till they hear the other Side, and will not think themselves Masters of the Merits of the Cause, by hearing it only ex Parte. Especially since the same royal Author tells us presently after, He that is first in his own Cause, seemeth just; but his Neighbour cometh and searcheth him. i. e.

p. 3He that speaks first will be sure to tell a straight Story, and relate that only which makes for him, and put the best Colour he can upon it, so that his Cause shall appear good, whether it be really so or no. But the Plaintiff having done his Evidence, 'tis fit the Defendant should be heard, and have Leave to shew the Falsehood & Fallacy of what has been alledg'd, which perhaps may make the Matter appear quite otherwise than it did.

In the Introduction to their Performance, lest the World should think they had medled with what did not belong to them, they let us know that the Ministers of the County of Hampshire were obliged both by their Situation and Office to act in this Affair. As to their Situation, it is indeed in the same County; but the Churches in this same County are at a large Distance from one another. And some of these very Gentlemen live twenty, thirty, or near forty Miles from Springfield: So that some Ministers in another County, and indeed in another Province, were as conveniently situated to have acted in the Affair as themselves. Boston is in the County of Suffolk; yet the Ministers there have not tho't themselves oblig'd by their Situation to act in the Affairs of every Church in the County. These Gentlemen seem to lay a p. 4great Stress in the present Controversy upon their Limits as a County; tho' we are perfectly at a Loss by what Law or Rule they make the Churches to follow the Civil Districts. The Towns in the Province we know are by the Legislative Power laid out into Countys; but we did not know the Churches were. If they are, should there not be a Shire-Church too in every County, for the holding ecclesiastical Courts in? These would be a new Kind of Churches indeed, such as we have not yet heard of. We have heard of National Churches, and of Provincial and Classical, but we do not know a Name for these, unless that of Comitatic may be allowed. — But it may be their Obligation is stronger from their Office. As to this, we suppose them by their Office to be Pastors of particular Churches, which were committed to their Care at their Ordination; and that they are obliged to act in the Affairs of other Churches only as their Assistance, by Advice, or otherwise, may be desir'd & sought, by those Churches in Communion with them that think they need it. Or if they consider themselves as Ministers in the Catholic Church, and therefore obliged to take Care of all the Churches; so are other Pastors:

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Other works by William Cooper

→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.