Primary Source

A Discourse on Natural Religion

Andrew Eliot 1771
A discourse on natural religion and divine revelation delivered at Harvard, examining reason and faith in theological understanding.

TCP N09443. EEBO . STC/Wing Evans 12033. Source: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/uwgraphics/VEP2_TCP_SimpleText/main/N0/N09443.txt

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

Dr. Eliot's SERMON At the Annual DUDLEIAN-LECTURE. May 8. 1771. A DISCOURSE ON NATURAL RELIGION DELIVERED IN THE Chapel of HARVARD COLLEGE IN CAMBRIDGE, NEW ENGLAND May 8.1771. AT THE LECTURE FOUNDED By the Hon. PAUL DUDLEY, Esquire By ANDREW ELIOT, D.D. BOSTON: Printed by DANIEL KNEELAND, for NICHOLAS Bows in Cornhill. M,DCC,LXXI, ACTS XVII. 27. That they should seek the LORD, if happily they might feel after him, and find him. BEFORE we can undertake to determine the proper use and improvement of the principles of Natural Religion, we must know what Natural Religion is, and what those principles are, which we are to use and improve. It was justly observed by one Mr. GAY who has gone before me on this subject, that "the belief of God's existence is most essentially fundamental to all religion." -- If we could suppose an intelligent creature to do every thing that we call right, and to forbear what we call evil; yet, if he did not act from a sense of the Being and Perfections of God, we should not pronounce this religion, whatever else we might call it. It is the opinion of many great and good men, that there is an essential and immutable difference between moral good and evil; and that this difference arises from the very nature of things, so as to be entirely independent on the will of God. I shall not determine whether these sentiments are true or false but allowing that they are true, and that some superior minds are influenced by this abstract and unalterable fitness of things to act agreeable to it, without any other consideration; we may call them wise and virtuous; but if there is no regard to a Deity, they cannot be denominated religious, because a respect to a Deity is necessarily implied in the very notion of Religion -- If there is no God, there is, there can be no Religion -- The sacred writings lay this down as a fundamental principle, "He that comes to God must believe that He is" -This is the foundation of all Religion both Natural and Revealed. THE first thing therefore in discoursing on Natural Religion is to establish this great, this fundamental, this essential truth -- That there is a God.

ALLOWING the Being and Perfections of God, we are next to prove that there is such a thing as Religion. IN the last place we shall show in what respects this Religion may be called Natural or the Religion of Nature. THE first thing before us is, to prove the Being of a God, or that there is a Deity of infinite perfection -- I shall not take up much of your time upon this head, as I am not able to offer any arguments, but such as will easily occur to your minds without any help of mine. "The high priori road" is, I fear, too intricate for men of common understanding, either when they attempt to find it out themselves, or to travel in it when discovered by others -- These exalted reasonings become men of such prodigious reach of thought as the late Dr. Clark, but even with the help of this clear and consummate Reasoner, the most are rather puzzled and confounded, than enlightened and established by such abstract speculations -- "The argument a posteriori", says that very great man, "is indeed by far the most generally useful argument, most easy to be understood, and in some degree suited to all capacities". THAT every Effect must have some cause is as plain and undeniable a truth as any axiom in Euclid. That the whole sensible universe is an Effect, we have all the evidence that the nature of the thing will admit. If it is not the effect of some cause, it must exist from Eternity: Now, says Dr. Clark, "whatever exists from Eternity and without any external cause, is self-existent: Whatever is self-existent, must exist necessarily, by an absolute necessity in the nature of the thing itself. It follows evidently, that unless the material world exists necessarily, by an absolute necessity in its own nature, so as that it must be an express contradiction to suppose it not to exist; it cannot be independent, and of itself eternal. Now that the material world does not exist thus necessarily, is very evident. For absolute necessity of existing, and a possibility of not existing, being contradictory ideas; it is manifest the material world cannot exist necessarily, if without a contradiction we can conceive it either not to be, or to be in any respect, otherwise than it now is. Than which, nothing is more easy. Every thing in it, both the whole and every one of its parts, their situation and motion, the form and also the matter, are the most arbitrary and dependent things, and farthest removed from necessity, that can possibly be imagined". We rationally conclude therefore that the universe is the effect of some powerful cause.

THE structure and constitution of the world, the accurate adjustment of its various parts, and the uses and ends to which they are mutually adapted, prove this cause to be intelligent, wise and good. THE two first of these attributes, I conclude, will readily be allowed. Possibly some may dispute, whether the Goodness of God can be justly argued from the state of things in this world, where there is such a mixture of sorrow, distress and misery. But there is certainly a large share of good communicated, enough to preponderate the evil there is in the universe, so far as it is known to us, and even if we leave out all consideration of a future state. The most enjoy a great degree of comfort, and would enjoy much more, were it not for their own irregular passions, and the faults and follies which are the consequence of them. …

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Other works by Andrew Eliot

→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.