Primary Source

The Examiner, or Gilbert Against Tennent

John Hancock 1743
John Hancock's polemical critique of Gilbert Tennent's religious views, defending orthodox theology against what he perceived as erroneous principles.

EEBO-TCP N04219 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 5200

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

THE EXAMINER, OR, Gilbert against Tennent.

WHEN I had read over Mr. G. Tennent's three first Sermons on Rev. 3▪3. representing the Necessity of holding fast the Truth, with the Appendix, relating to the Moravian Errors, &c. I immediately reviewed and compared therewith his famous Sermon preach'd at Nottingham upon the Danger of an Unconverted Ministry, on Mark 1◊ 44. And must confess it is as impossible to reconcile them upon the Principles of Common Sense, as to unite the two Poles.

But then putting on that Charity which is not easily provoked, and hopeth all Things, I endeavoured to consider the three Sermons as a Retractation of the Nottingham Sermon; That altho' he did not expresly retract it, yet I would charitably cast it in this Light, for the sake of Catholick Unity, and because it seems hard for an High Priest to confess his Errors even once a Year, tho' he may love to be Father Confessor himself, and bring others to the Stool.

p. 4But upon Enquiry, it is to be suspected that Mr. Tennent never design'd that these three Sermons should superceed the other; but that they should consist and travel together like good Companions. For it is plain that after Mr. T—had preached these Sermons at N. York, in April 1742, his Sermon at Nottingham receives a new Edition at Boston, from the second Edition printed at Philadelphia; by which it appears that Mr. T. or his Friends, instead of suppressing it, have been careful to propagate it, as his Master-Piece; and indeed it is a Master-Piece of it's kind: And not only so, but I'm credibly inform'd, that he has lately justified it, as containing the genuine Sentiments of his Soul; and I'm apt to think he has spoken the Truth. And no wonder Mr. T. won't abate one Jot or Tittle of it, since Mr. W—d has judg'd it an unanswerable Piece: for his Counsel it seems with many in these Days is, as if a Man had enquired at the Oracle of GOD. [The Querists, Part III, Page 5, take Notice, that it hath been observed that when it is Mr. Whitefield's turn to speak, then Mr. G. Tennent is proclaimed the most able, most eminent Servant of Christ, and all his Associates or Party, spiritual Men, and faithful Ministers of Christ, &c. &c. And in the Examiner, Pag. 149, it is affirmed, that when Mr. Whitefield preached a Sermon at Philadelphia, he told a numerous Audience, that there were but few faithful Ministers of Christ in these Parts; and if he must be plain and name them, it was the Tennents and their Adherents: The like he did at Fog's Mannor. On the other Hand, If their Turn comes to speak or write, then Mr. Whitefield is proclaimed the most able, and most eminent Servant of Christ.—When there is such an Hue and Cry after Pharisees, we would be glad to know, whether it would be safe for the other side to trumpet one anothers Praises so loudly and highly as this side doth, without being in Danger of being taken up for Pharisees, and having the Crows Eggs cast in their Teeth? because Christ saith to those Pharisees that were offended at him for healing a Man on the Sabbath, John 5, 44. How can ye believe, that receive Honour one of another?]

p. 5It is plain also, That Mr. T—t's zealous Advocates here and elsewhere, have by way of Charity, dispers'd about the Country great Numbers of the last Edition, tending to corrupt the Minds of People from the Simplicity which is in Christ, and to promote that Confusion and separating Spirit which he himself has been instrumental of raising in many of our Places; Which the Lord rebuke in his Time. For many are fully perswaded that Mr. T—t's Sermon and Practice upon it, have sown the Seeds of all that Discord, Intrusion, Confusion, Separation, Hatred, Variance, Emulations, Wrath, Strife, Seditions, Heresies, &c. that have been springing up in so many of the Towns and Churches thro' the Province for two Years past. Who hath been so instrumental to hatch the Cockatrice as himself, tho' at the same Time he could gravely advise others to crush it in the Egg [See his printed Letter to Mr. Dickinson.] . His Principiis obsta is given out too late in the Day: That is to say, After Vows make Enquiry, instead of letting alone Contention before it be medled with.

Whoever will take the Pains to consider the main Scope of Mr. Tennent's Sermon at Nottingham, will find the Principles of it to be subversive of Gospel Order, the publick Ministry and publick Means of Education; and what have we more? What could touch the Apple of our Eye like this fatal Blow. It is a Blow at the Root.

Take here by the Way, the Sentiments of the Synod in the Examination, &c. Page 81, viz

We look upon Mr. T—'s printed Sermon preach'd at Nottingham to be a notable Instance of their sowing Seeds of Division, and we charge him with perverting Scripture, uncharitable rash Judging of the Body of the Clergy of this Generation in the Lump, and encouraging Factions and Disorders therein; and say we, This, This, This, and the like Speeches thereunto, filled the Minds of many People against their stated Pastors, &c.

p. 6Furthermore, I can't find any Room for rational Christian Charity to think that Mr. T—ever intended that his last Discourses should be interpreted as a Retractation of his Sermon at Nottingham; and therefore as long as he holds two Sett of Principles as opposite to one another, as the heathenish Principles of a good and an evil god, and until he makes a publick and solemn Retractation of that Sermon, it is but just and equal to set Gilbert against Tennent, and judge him out of his own Mouth.

p. 6Moreover, Having reviewed the florid Preface to Mr. Tennent's late Discourses, subscribed by Six Reverend Divines,

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. To the reader
  2. THE EXAMINER, OR, Gilbert against Tennent.p. 5
  3. GILBERT.p. 12
  4. TENNENT.p. 12
  5. The Conversion and after Experiences of the Moravians, compared with…p. 22
  6. Mr. T—'s Reflections on the Conversions, &c. of the Moravians.p. 22
  7. Applied to his own Party, &c.p. 22
  8. Mr. T—'s Reflections on the Spirit of the Moravians compared with his…p. 24
  9. Mr. T—'s Reflections on the Practice of the Moravians, compared with…p. 27

Other works by John Hancock

→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.