A Letter of Reproof to Mr. John Cleaveland of Ipswich
EEBO-TCP N07632 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 9737
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.
Mr. Cleaveland,
BY the great vanity which you discover, and the self-important airs which you assume thro'out your slanderous Essay, I conclude you supposed that I would either enter the lists with 〈…〉 as a shrewd polemical writer, or else be wholly silent, from a conviction of my inability to defend the sermons which you have attack'd in so heroic a manner. But if you imagined either of these things, you was under a mistake. If ever I enter into a formal controversy with any person upon such points, it shall be with One, who appears to me to have both a better head, and honester heart than you have discovered in this specimen of your abilities, and zeal for what you call orthodoxy. And yet I do not think it convenient to be quite silent upon this occasion. Tho' my sermons need no elaborate, argumentative defence against your ratiotinations, and impertinent criticisms; yet so much rudeness and insolence, so much misrepresentation and slander, falsehood and forgery as your libel contains, should not, methinks, be passed over without some animadversions: Especially since it is probable that this will be read chiefly by those who have never seen the sermons aforesaid; and who may be so ignorant of you, as to imagine you had too much integrity and honor to misrepresent and falsify them. It is partly upon this consideration, that I give you and myself the present trouble; my principal aim being, not to dispute with, but to chastize and admonish you, for your real good; and to make you an example and warning to others. If in doing this, I should transiently touch upon the merits of p. 4the cause, theologically considered, you are not to flatter yourself, that I mean to controvert such points with you; whom I consider as a person wholly unworthy to be reasoned with about them, any farther than is requisite to shew your dishonesty and wickedness with reference to them.
If I had really published any material errors in point of doctrine, let me tell you, Mr. Cleaveland, that you was one of the most unsutable persons in the world, to undertake a confutation of them, or to set yourself up for an author, tho' you say, p. 4, that you have 'an undoubted right' to do it. I am sensible that British subjects have a legal right to expose themselves in print, on politics, divinity, or any other subject: And if this is what you insist on as an invaluable privilege, I would by no means have your liberty, or that of the press restrained. But you speak, p. 3. of 'Divines of indisputable ability for such an undertaking', as that of vindicating the truth against me. Can you then possibly think it became you, an obscure person from another province, and one so unletter'd as you are; an out-cast from the college to which you was a disgrace; for some time a rambling itinerant, and promoter of disorders and confusion among us; so raw and unstudied in divinity; one hardly ever heard of among us, but in the frequent reports of your follies and extravagances, and at length set up as a minister to an assembly of separatists;—Can you possibly think it became you to turn author upon this occasion; and to take this supposed necessary work of defending the most important principles of the protestant religion against me, out of the hands of our Divines of indisputable ability? What unaccountable vanity and infatuation was this! And you have presumed to pass an implicit censure on those Divines also, by saying, p. 3.
p. 4I marvel that none of our divines of indisputable ability for such an undertaking, have attempted to vindicate the truth against him
—Is not this a proof, that none of our able Divines thought there was any occasion for opposition to me? And do not you shew the utmost assurance, in thus setting up your little self in opposition to their opinion, as well as p. 5to my sermons? Poor, unhappy man! You doubtless thought to emerge from your obscurity, and to appear as a person of some consequence, by this vain attempt. But you have great reason to wish, you had continued as unnoticed as ever: For it were much better to remain as unknown as heretofore, than to be only more infamous; as you are at least in a fair way now to be, by means of your libel.
If it were my intention to write to you as a scholar, logician or divine, I would take some notice of the confusion and want of method, so apparent thro'out your Essay; the needless and numberless repetitions therein; and your running the proposed heads of it into each other: So that one had almost as good look for what you propose under any particular one, under any of the other, as that. This is particularly observable with respect to the three latter of them, which are the principal. And even under your first, the design of which, you say, is, to mention several things in which you "agree" with me [Thus it is expressed p 4. I. Mention several things, WE agree with the Dr. in. So p 7. 'Yea, WE stick not to say'.—p 95. 'OUR system of doctrine'—97. 'Another principle of OUR system' —After this manner he speaks in numerous other places: WE, OUR, US. &c. As if all this wrong headed creature's whimsies were the common cause of protestants, and himself a distinguished champion therefor. Who can help smiling at the folly and impertinence of this, that is not too much provok'd at the insolence & arrogance of it?] , you mention near as many, I think, in which, you say, we disagree. But it is as much beneath me to play the critic on such a performance as yours, as it would be particularly to expose the vanity of your criticisms on my sermons. Let me here only just observe by the way, that if I agree with you in so many things as you say I do, this is a better presumptive evidence, that I am under some mistakes, than any which you have produced. For I can hardly suppose it possible for any one to be of your opinion in many points of doctrine, without being in the wrong with respect to some.
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadOther works by Jonathan Mayhew
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.