Primary Source

Pharisaism and Christianity Compared

Joseph Hall 1608
A sermon contrasting Pharisaic hypocrisy with authentic Christian righteousness, delivered at St. Paul's Cross on Matthew 5:20.

EEBO-TCP A02571 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 99851811; STC/Wing STC 12699; ESTC S116595

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.

Except your righteousnesse exceed the righteousnesse of the Scribes and Phariseis, yee shall not enter into the kingdome of Heauen.

THE curious Doctors [Petr. Galatin. de arcan. fidei Cath. ad finem. Ex glos. Rab. Sh • lom • h.] of the Iews had reduced all Gods statute-law to sixe hundred and thirteene precepts; so many p. 2as there are daies in the yeere, and members in the body. It was an honest & (which were strange) a Christian conceit of one of their Rabbins, that Dauid abridges all these to eleuen in his Psal. 15. Esay to sixe, in his 33.15. Micha◊ yet lower to three, in his 6.8. Esay yet againe to two, in his 56 1. Habacue to one, The iust man shal liue by faith. [Lex est Euā gelium praedictum: Euangelium lex completa.] So yee see, the Law ends in the Gospell; and that Father said not a misse, The Law is the Gospell foretold▪ and the Gospell is the Law fulfilled. These two are the free-hold of a Christian; and what but they?

The Iewes of these times p. 3peruerted the Law, reiected the Gospell. Our Sauior therfore that great Prophet of the World (as it was high time) cleares the Law, deliuers and settles the Gospell: well approuing in both these, that hee came not to consume, but to consummate the Law. [1. Cor. 16.9] Wherein (as Paul to his Corinths) he had a great dore, but many aduersaries: [Ioh. 3. Art thou a Master in Israel?] amongst these were the great masters of Israel (so our Sauior termes the Phariseis) and their fellowes, and yet their riuals, the Scribes: both so much harder to oppose, by how much their authority was greater.

p. 4Truth hath no roome till falshood bee remooued; Our Sauior therefore (as behoued) first shewes the falshood of their Glosses, and the hollownesse of their profession; and if both their life and Doctrine be naught; what free part is there in them? And loe both of these so faulty, that Except your righteousnesse exceed the righteousnesse of the Scribes and Phariseis, yee shall not enter into the kingdome of Heauen.

p. 4What were the men? What was their righteousnes? What wanted it? Follow mee, I beseech you, in these three, and if my discourse shall seeme for p. 5a while, more thornie and perplexed, remedie it with your attention.

Those things which are out of the ken of sense or memory, must bee fetch't from Story. The Sect (or order whether) of the Phariseis ceassed with the Temple; since that, no man reads of a Pharisie; and now is growne so farre out of knowledge, that the moderne Iewes are more ready to learne of vs who they were: There is no point, wherein it is more difficult, to auoid variety, yea ostentation of reading; without any curious trauersing of opinions, I study for simple truth, p. 6as one that will not lead you out of the rode-way to shew you the turnings. Scribes were ancient; [Esr. 6.7.] Esra is called (Sopher mahir) a prompt Scribe. As long before him, soeuer since they continued till Christs time; but in two rankes; some were 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: others 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: Some popular, others legall: Some the peoples, others, Gods: The one Secretaries, Recorders, Notaries, as 2. Chron. 24.11. (Sopher hamelec) the Kings Scribe: The other Doctours of the Law of God: [Ier. 8.8.] The Law of the Lord is with vs, in vaine made hee it, the pen of the Scribe is in vaine.

As the Phariseis were (〈non-Latin alphabet〉 p. 7〈non-Latin alphabet〉;) Law-masters: so these are the same which Luc. 11.45. are called (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) interpreters of the Law. Tho to some not meane Critickes, it seems these should be a third sort; which consider not, that our Sauiour on purpose addressing his speech to the Phariseis, fell by the way vpon the Scribes, and being admonished by one of them, as of an ouer-sight, now auerres right downe of the Scribes, what before he had but indifferently glanced at. [Neh. 8.4. Matt. 23.2. Cleric: Iudaeorum: saith Ierome.] What they were, is plaine by Ezraes pulpit; and Moses his chaire. These and Phariseis differed not much; they agreed in some p. 8good, but in more euill. But the profession of Phariseis, because it is more obscure, you shall giue mee leaue to fetch somewhat further.

p. 8[Euseb. eccl. hist. l. 4 c. 22 Erāt in circūcisione diuersae sentē tiae qua maximè tribui Iudae aduersabantur, &c.] There were, saith old Egesippus (as Eusebius cites him) diuers opinions in the Circumcision; which all crossed the tribe of Iuda: Essens, Galileans, Emerobaptists, Masbutheans, Samaritans, Phariseis, Sadduces. It were easie to helpe him with more, [Vid Ios. Scalig resp. ad Serarium.] Sebuaeans, Cannaeans, Sampsaeans; and if need were, yet more. Where are those wauerers, that stagger in their trust to the Church, because of different opinions, receiuing that p. 9rotten argument of profane Celsus against the Christians? [Orig. lib. 5. aduers. Cels. Christian • s non habere veram Religionem, quòd in varias sectas diuisi essent.] Sayes the Papists, One saith I am Caluins, another, I am Luthers. We disclaime, we defie these titles, these diuisions: we are one in truth: would God we were yet more one: It is the lace and fringe of Christs garment, that is questioned amongst vs, the cloth is sound. But what? Was the Iewish Church before Christ, Gods true Church, or not? If it were not, which was it? If it were: lo that heere rent in more than eight parts, [Domus Sā mai & Hillel. Ar. Mont. in Euang.] and one of them differing from it selfe in eighteene opinions; and yet as Irenaeus p. 10well obserues, [Ante aduē tum Christi, non tot & tam blasphemae hareses▪ Irem. lib. 5.] before Christ, there were neither so many heresies, nor so blasphemous.

Shew me a Church on earth without these wrinkles of diuision, and I will neuer seeke for it in heauen: although to some Pharisaisme seemes rather a seuerall order, than a sect: but S. Luke that knew it better, hath (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) the Sect of the Phariseis. [Act. 15.5.] When the profession began, no history recordeth. …

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. TO THE RIGHT REVEREND FATHER in God, and my very good Lord, THOMAS Lord Bishop of LONDON…
  2. Prayer
  3. To the READER.

Other works by Joseph Hall

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.