The Reconciler
EEBO-TCP A02584 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 99839454; STC/Wing STC 12709A; ESTC S103708
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, from p. 78, in the spelling of this edition.
p. 78MY Lord; you desire my opinion concerning an assertion of yours, wherat some haue taken offence. The proposition was this. [That the Romane Church remaynes yet a True Visible Church.] The occasion which makes this an ill sounding proposition in the eares of Protestants (especially such as are not throughly acquainted with Schoole Distinctions) is the vsuall acception of the Word, True, in our English tongue. For though p. 79men skilled in Metaphysickes hold it for a maxime, Ens, Verum, Bonum conuertuntur: yet with vs, he which shall affirme, Such an one is a True Christian, a True Gentleman, a True Scholler, a True Souldier, or the like; hee is conceiued not only to adscribe Truenesse of Beeing vnto all these, but those Due Qualities, or Requisite Actions wherby they are made commendable or Praise-worthy in their seuerall kinds. In this sense the Roman Church is no more a True Church in respect of Christ, or those due Qualities, and proper Actions which Christ requires; then an arrant whore is a True and loyall Wife vnto her Husband I p. 80durst vpon mine oath be one of your Compurgators, that you neuer intended to adorne that Strumpet with the Title of a True Church in this meaning. But your owne Writings haue so fully cleered you herein; that Suspition it selfe, cannot reaosnably suspect you in this point. I therefore can say no more concerning your mistaken proposition then this. If in that treatise wherein it was deliuered; the Antecedents, or Consequents were such, as serued fitly to leade the Reader into that Sense, which vnder the word True, comprehendeth only Truth of Beeing or Existencie, and not the Due Qualities of the thing or subiect; p. 81you haue beene causelesly traduced. But on the other side, if that Proposition comes in ex abrupto, or stands solitarie in your discourse, you cannot maruell though by taking the word True according to the more ordinarie acception, your true meaning was mistaken. In briefe, your Proposition admits a True sense; & in that sense, is by the best learned in our Reformed Church, not disallowed.
p. 81For The Beeing of a Church does principally stand vpon the Gratious Action of God, calling men out of Darknesse and Death, vnto the Participation of sight and life in Christ Iesus. So long as God continues this Calling p. 82vnto any people, though they (as much as in them lies) Darken this light, and corrupt the meanes which should bring them to life and saluation in Christ; yet where God Calls men vnto the Participation of life in Christ, by the word & by the Sacraments, there is the true Being of a Christian Church; let men bee neuer so false in their Expositions of GODS Word, or neuer so vntrustie in mingling their owne Traditions with Gods Ordinances. Thus the Church of the Iewes lost not her Being of a Church, when shee became an Idolatrous Church. And thus vnder the gouernment of the Scribes and Pharisees, who voided the p. 83Commandements of God by their owne Traditions; there was yet standing a true Church in which Zacharias, Elizabeth, the Virgin Mary, and our Sauiour himselfe was borne, who were mēbers of that Church, and yet participated not in the corruptions thereof. Thus to grant that the Roman was, and is a True Visible Christian Church, (though in doctrine a false, and in practice an Idolatrous Church) is a true assertion, and of greater vse and necessitie in our Controuersie with Papists about the Perpetuitie of the Christian Church, then is vnderstood by those who gainsay it. This in your Reconciler is so wel explicated, p. 84as if any shall continue in traducing you, in regard of that Proposition, so explained, I thinke it wil be only those who are better acquainted with wrangling, then reasoning, and deeper in loue with strife, then truth: As for the aspersion of Arminianisme, I can testifie that in our Ioint imployment at the Synod of Dort, you were as farre from it, as my selfe. And I know that no man can imbrace it in the Doctrine of Predestination, and Grace, but he must first desert the Articles agreed vpon by the Church of England, nor in the point of perseuerance, but he must vary from the common Tenet, and receiued opinion of our best p. 85approued Doctors in the English Church. I am assured that you neither haue deserted the one, nor will vary from the other. And therefore be no more troubled with other mens groundlesse suspitions, then you would be in like case, with their idle Dreames. Thus I haue inlarged my selfe beyond my first intent. But my loue to your selfe, and the assurance of your constant loue vnto the Truth, inforced me thereunto. I rest alwayes
p. 86¶To the Reuerend and learned, Master Doctor PREDEAVX, professor of Diuinitie in Oxford, and Rector of EXCETER Colledge.
WOrthy Master Doctor Predeaux: All our litle world here, takes notice of your worth, and eminencie; who haue long furnished the Diuinitie Chaire in that famous Vniuersitie, with mutuall grace and honour. p. 87Let me intreate you, vpon the perusall of this sorie sheete of Paper, to impart your selfe freely to me, in your censure; and to expresse to mee your cleare iudgement, concerning the true being, and visibilitie of the Romane Church; you see in what sence I professe to hold it; neither was any other euer in my thoughts; Say, I beseech you, whether you thinke any learned Orthodoxe Diuine can, with any colour of reason, maintaine a contradiction herevnto; p. 88And if you find (as I doubt not) much necessitie and vse of this true, and safe Tenet; helpe me to adde (if you please) a further supplie of Antidotes to those Popish spiders, that would faine sucke poyson out of this herbe. It was my earnest desire that this satisfactorie reconcilement might haue stilled all tongues, and pens, concerning this ill-raysed brabble: but I see to my griefe, how much men care for themselues more, then peace; I suffer, and the p. 89Church is disquieted; your learning and grauitie will be ready to contribute to a seasonable pacification; In desire, and exspectation of your speedie answere, I take my leaue, and am
Your very louing friend, and fellow-labourer, IOS. EXON.
p. 90Right Reuerend Father in GOD;
VPon the receite of your Reconciler, which it pleased you to send me, I tooke occasion (as my manifolde distractions would permit) to peruse what had beene said on both sides, concerning the now-being of the Romane Church. VVherin I must professe, that I p. 91could not but wonder at the needlesse exceptions against your Tenet; you affirming no new thing in that passage misliked in your Old Religion. And this your Aduertisement (afterward) so fully and punctually cleareth, and your Reconciler so acquitteth, with such satisfying ingenuitie, that I cannot imagin they haue considered it well, or meane wel, that shal persist to oppose it. For who perceiues not, that your p. 93Lordship leaues no more to Rome, then our best Diuines euer since the Reformation haue granted? If their speeches haue beene sometimes seemingly different, their meaning hath beene alwayes the same; that in respect of the common Truths yet professed among the Papists they may, and ought to bee tearmed, a True visible. Church, in opposition to Iewes, Turkes, and Pagans, who directly denie p. 93the Foundation, howsoeuer their Antichristian aditions make them no better then the Synagogue of Sathan. This being agreed vpon by those, whose Iudgement wee haue good reason to follow (cited in your Aduertisement, and by others) they doe an ill office to our Church (in my opinion) who set them at ods in this point, that are so excellently reconciled; and giue more aduantage to the Aduersarie p. 94by quarrelling with our worthies, then the Aduersarie is like to get by our acknowledgment, that they are such a miserable Church, as we discouer them to be. VVhat I haue thought long since in this behalfe, it appeareth in my Lecture De Visibilitate Ecclesiae; and as often as this hath come in question in our publicke Disputes, we determine here no otherwise, then your Lordship hath stated it. And yet wee p. 95trust to giue as little vantage to Poperie, as those that doe detest it; and are as circumspect to maintaine our receiued Doctrine and Discipline without the least scandall to the weakest, as those that would seeme most forward. That distinction of Romes case before, and since, the Councell of Trent, holds not to dis-Church it; but shewes it rather to be more incureable now, then heretofore Neither find I any particulars p. 96obiected, which those worthy men haue not sufficiently cleared, that haue iustifyed your Assertion. Not to trouble therefore your weightier affairs with my needlesse interposition; As that controuersie about the Altar (Iosuah 22.) had presently a faire end vpon the ful vnderstanding of the good meaning on both sides; so I trust in God this shall haue: In which I am so perswaded that if it were to bee discussed p. 97there after our Scholasticall manner, it might well bee defended either pro, or con, with out preiudice to the Truth, according to the full stating, which your Aduertisement, and Reconciler haue afforded. And thus, with tender of my due obseruance, and Prayers for your happinesse, I rest p. 97Your Lordships in Christ to be commanded, IO. PRIDEAVX
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadContents
- TO THE RIGHT HONOVRABLE, AND truly religious, my singular good Lord, Edward Earle of…p. 1
- TO THE CHRISTIAN READER Wisedome and Charitie.p. 37
- To the Right Reuerend Father in God, THOMAS, Lord Bishop of Couentree and Lichfield.p. 61
- To the Right Reuerend Father in God, my verie good Lord and Brother IOSEPH Lord Bishop of…p. 66
- To the Right Reuerend Father in God, IOHN, Lord Bishop of Salisburie.p. 71
- Letterp. 78
- ¶To the Reuerend and learned, Master Doctor PREDEAVX, professor of Diuinitie in Oxford…p. 86
- Right Reuerend Father in GOD;p. 90
- ¶To my Reuerend and learned friend M. Doctor PRIMEROSE, Preacher to the French Church in…p. 98
- To the Right Reuerend Father in God, and my very good Lord, IOSEPH Bishop of Exceter.p. 101
- ¶To my VVorthy and much respected Friend Mr. H. CHOMLEY.p. 137
Other works by Joseph Hall
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.