Primary Source

The Old Religion

Joseph Hall 1628
Hall's defense of Reformed Christianity against Roman Catholicism, clarifying doctrinal differences and addressing the causes of ecclesiastical division.

EEBO-TCP A02563 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 99852822; STC/Wing STC 12690; ESTC S117610

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

An Aduertisement.

COurteous Reader; I shall entreat you where you finde some few, either ◊iterall, or verball faults, to haue recourse to this following Errata committed by the Printer, which will bee verie vnpleasing to the Reuerend Authour (who is many miles distant from the Presse) which errors if you shall vouchsafe to pardon in this Impression, they shall be more carefully amended in the next.

p. 1CHAP. I. The extent of the differences betwixt the Churches.

THe first blessing that I dayly begge of my God, for his Church, is, [Ioh. 14.27.] our Sauiours Legacie, Peace: that sweete Peace; which in the verie name of it comprehends all happinesse both of estate and disposition. [Adrichoni descr. Hiero fol. fig. 19 • .] As that mountaine whereon Christ ascended, though it abounded with Palmes, and Pines, and Mirtles, yet it caried onely the name of Oliues, which haue beene an ancient Embleme of Peace: Other graces are p. 2for the beautie of the Church; this for the health and life of it; For how so euer, [Faciunt fau • ; & v • s • e faciunt Ecclesias & Marcionitae. Ter tull. aduer. Marcion. l. 4. c 5.] euen Waspes haue their Combes, and heretickes their assemblies (as Tertullian,) so as all are not of the Church that haue Peace; yet so essentiall is it to the Church, in Saint Chrysostomes opinion, [Ecclesiae nomen consensus, concordiae que est Chrysost. com. in Ep. ad Gal.] that the very name of the Church implyes a consent, and concord; No maruel then if the Church labouring here below, make it her dayly suite to her glorious Bride-grome in heauen, Da pacem, giue Peace in our time, O Lord: The meanes of which happinesse are soone seene, not so soone attained; euen that which Hierome hath to his Ruffinus, [Sit inter nes vna fides & illico pax sequetur Hier. aduers. Ruff.] Vna fides; Let our beleefe be but one, and our hearts will be one.

But since, as Erasmus hath too truely obserued, [Erasm. Epist. l. 20. Paulo Decimario.] there is nothing so happie in these humane things, wherein there is not some intermixtures of distemper; [1. Cor. 11.] and S. Paul hath told vs, there must be heresies, and p. 3the Spouse, in Salomons Song, [Cantic. 2. vlt.] compares her blessed husband to a yong Hart vpon the mountaine of Bether; that is, Diuision; Yea, rather, [Victor. Perser. Afric. l. 5.] as vnder Gensericus, and his Vandals, the Christian Temples flamed higher then the Townes; so for the space of these last hundred yeeres, there hath beene more combustion in the Church, then in the ciuill state; My next wish is, that if differences in Religion cannot bee avoided, yet that they might bee rightly iudged off, and be but taken as they are. Neither can I but mourne, and bleede, to see how miserably the World is abused on all hands with preiudice in this kinde: whiles the aduerse part brands vs with vniust censures, and with loude clamours cries vs downe for heretickes: On the other side, some of ours, doe so sleight the errours of the Romane Church, as if they were not worth our contention; [Spalat. de hist. Eccles. tom. vlt. lib. 7.] as if our Martyrs had beene rash, and our quarrels trifling; Others p. 4againe doe so aggrauate them, as if we could neuer bee at enough defiance with their opinions, nor at enough distance from their communion. All these three are dangerous extremities; The two former whereof shall (if my hopes faile me not) in this whole discourse be sufficiently conuinced; wherein as wee shal fully cleare our selues from that hateful slander of heresie, or schisme, So we shall leaue vpon the Church of Rome, an vnauoydable imputation of many no lesse foule, and enormious, then nouell errours; to the stopping of the mouthes of those Adiaphorists, [Melanct. Postill. de Baptismo Chri.] whereof Melancthon seemes to haue long agoe prophesied; Metuendum est, &c. It is to be feared (saith he) that in the last age of the world this errour will raigne amongst men, that either Religions are nothing, or differ onely in words.

p. 4[Diog Laert.] The third comes now in our way; That which Laertius speakes of Menedemus that in Disputing his p. 5very eyes would sparkle, is true of many of ours, whose zeale transports them to such a detestation of the Romane Church, [Hooker. Eccles. Pol. l 4. §. 3. Comment. in Euang. saepe. Patres nostri & saluberrimam consuetudinem tenuerunt vt quicquid diuinum ac legitimum, &c. Aug-Ne que propter paleam relinquimus aream Domini, ne que propter pisees malos rumpimus retia domini Aug, Epist. 48 Sic Anabaptistae accusant Paedobaptismum. Papismi Cliston, contr. Smith. Sic Neariani Trinitatem arguunt & articulum Papae. Probant· Fascic· c. 1.] as if it were all errour, no Church; affecting nothing more, then an vtter opposition to their doctrine and ceremonie, because theirs; Like as Maldonate professeth to mislike and auoide many faire interpretations, not as false, but as Caluins: These men haue not learned this in Saint Austens Schoole, who tels vs, that it was the rule of the Fathers well before Cyprian and Agrippinus, as since, that whatsoeuer they found in any schime or heresie, warrantable and holy, that they allowed for its owne worth, and did not refuse it for the abettors; Neither for the chaffe doe we leaue the floore of God, neither for the bad fishes doe we breake his nets. Rather, as the Priests of Mercurie had wont to say, when they eate their Figs and Honie, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, &c. All truth is sweet; it is indeed Gods, not ours, wheresoeuer it is found, p. 6the Kings coyne is currant, though it be found in any impure channell.

[Nos fatemur sub papatu plurimum esse boni Christiani, imo omne bonum Christianum; dico insuper & imo vero verum nucleum Christianitatis. Luther. in Epist. ad 2. pleb. de Anabapt. cit • a Cromero de falsa relig. Lutheran.] For this particular …

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. TO MY NEWE, AND DEARELY Affected charge, the Diocesse of EXCETER, All Grace and…
  2. An Aduertisement.
  3. CHAP. I. The extent of the differences betwixt the Churches.p. 1
  4. CHAP. II. The Originall of the differences.p. 7
  5. CHAP. III. The reformed vniustly charged with noueltie, heresie…p. 14
  6. CHAP. IIII. The Church of Rome guiltie of this Schisme.p. 22
  7. CHAP. V. The newnesse of the Article of Iustification by inherent…p. 27
  8. SECT. II. The errour hereof against Scripture.p. 36
  9. SECT. III. Against Reason.p. 42
  10. CHAP. VI. The newnesse of the doctrine of Merit.p. 45
  11. SECT. II. Against Scripture.p. 48
  12. CHAP. VII. The newnesse of the Doctrine of Transsubstantiation.p. 52
  13. Transsubstantiation. SECT. II. Against Scripture.p. 62
  14. SECT. III. Transsubstantiation against Reason.p. 67
  15. CHAP. VIII. The newnesse of the Halfe-Communion.p. 71
  16. SECT. II. Halfe Communion against Scripture.p. 75
  17. SECT. III. Halfe Communion against reason.p. 77
  18. CHAP. IX. The newnesse of the Missall Sacrifice.p. 79
  19. SECT. II. Sacrifice of the Masse against Scripture.p. 81
  20. SECT. III. Missall Sacrifice against reason.p. 84
  21. CHAP. X. Newnesse of Image-worship.p. 87
  22. SECT. II. Image Worship against Scripture.p. 94
  23. SECT. III.p. 98
  24. CHAP. XI. The newnesse of Indulgences and Purgatorie.p. 100
  25. SECT. II. Indulgences and Purgatorie against Scripture.p. 108
  26. SECT. III. Indulgences against Reason.p. 112
  27. CHAP. XII. The newnesse of Diuine Seruice in an vnknowne tongue.p. 114
  28. SECT. III. Against reason.p. 122
  29. CHAP. XIII. The newnesse of forced Sacramentall Confession.p. 124
  30. SECT. II. Romish Confession not warranted by Scripture.p. 129
  31. SECT. IV. The noueltie of Absolution before Satisfaction.p. 134
  32. CHAP. XIV. The newnesse of the Romish Inuocation of Saints.p. 136
  33. SECT. II. Inuocation of Saints against Scripture.p. 140
  34. CHAP. XV. The newnesse of seuen Sacraments.p. 148
  35. SECT. II. Seuen Sacraments beside Scripture.p. 152
  36. CHAP. XVI. The newnesse of the Doctrine of Traditions.p. 156
  37. SECT. II. Traditions against Scripture.p. 162
  38. SECT. III. Traditions against reason.p. 166
  39. CHAP. XVII. The newnesse of the vniuersall Head-ship of the Bishop of…p. 169
  40. SECT. II. The newnesse of challenged Infallibilitie.p. 177
  41. SECT. III. The newnesse of the Popes Superioritie to Generall…p. 179
  42. SECT. IV. The new presumption of Papall Dispensations.p. 182
  43. SECT. V. The new challenge of Popes dominering ouer Kings and…p. 185
  44. CHAP. XVIII. The Epilogue both of Exhortation and Apologie.p. 190

Other works by Joseph Hall

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.