An Appeal to the Public Answered
EEBO-TCP N08486 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 10853
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.
INTRODUCTION.
IT has, for some time, been known, that the Episcopal Clergy, in the Colonies, in consequence of consultations, in convened bodies, have transmitted a number of addresses to England; one, to his present Majesty, importunately requesting an AMERICAN EPISCOPATE; others, to the Arch-Bishops of Canterbury and York, to the Bishop of London, and to the Universities of Oxford, and Cambridge, solliciting their influence in an affair of such importance to the well-being, if not the very being, of the Church of England in these parts of the world. If this was "never intended to be kept a secret", it was certainly made one, at least in regard of the arguments made use of in support of the thing requested; for though an authentic knowledge of them was desired, it could not be obtained at first, and I know not that it ever has been since. The affair seems to have been carried on, as it were, under ground, until "the discovery of a favorable disposition in many," at home, towards the support of the thing in view. And now, the way being prepared, it is "thought proper, in a public manner, to give information of the REASONS, why an American-Episcopate is so earnestly desired by the Clergy, and other friends and members of the church". It might have been as proper, and certainly would have been more candid and generous, not to say fair, if they had given these reasons, when they sent their addresses supported by them. We might then have been heard at home as well, and p. 6as soon, as they; and judgment might have been made upon an impartial hearing of the case, and not by hearing one side only. We are, after such previous care to ripen matters at home in their favor, without all controversie, under disadvantage in offering what we have to say upon this affair, which may far more nearly concern the civil as well as religious interests of the Continent, than some may be ready, at first view, to imagine.
IT must not be esteemed strange, if "some persons", I may rather say many, are "alarmed at this conduct of the clergy". For now "the case has been explained", and is well "understood", there still "remains uneasiness"; nor is the exhibited PLAN "so reasonable", even in regard of the Episcopal churches; or so "harmless to other denominations", as the Dr. would represent. He hopes, "every objection", or even "suspicion", will be "intirely obviated" by what he has to say. But "should any objections continue, which shall be thought worthy of notice, objectors are invited to propose them in such a manner, that they may be fairly and candidly debated before the tribunal of the public". It is in compliance with this invitation, that the following sheets are wrote; as also, that it might not be "taken for granted, that all parties acquiesce and are satisfied". We join with the Episcopalians in bringing the case to open tryal. We desire nothing more than an impartial hearing. Let the public judge between us.
p. 6I SHALL proceed in the method the Dr. has chalked out; taking into consideration his several sections one by one, and saying what may be thought proper, in a way of answer, to each of them distinctly.
Answer to Section I. which contains "a Sketch of the Arguments in favor of Episcopacy."
THE Dr. begins the subject before him with premising, "that the Church of England is Episcopal; and consequently holds the necessity of Bishops to govern the Church, and to confer ecclesiastical powers". If he means, that the constitution of the Church of England, as established by law, is Episcopal, making Bishops, under the King, and within certain prescribed limits, the governors of the Church, and conveyers of ecclesiastical powers, and that this is the doctrine of the Church, it is readily acknowledged: But, if he intended to lead us into this thought, that the Church of England holds, or is obliged to hold, the DIVINE RIGHT of Bishops to govern the Church, or confer ecclesiastical powers, in virtue of their being officers distinct from, and superior to Presbyters; we differ from him in opinion. p. 8None of her public offices, no part of the system of her conduct towards the clergy is founded on this principle. The passage he has here quoted, from the preface to the book of ordination, may seem to have an aspect this way; but it is, as the late learned and excellent professor Wigglesworth, observes, [Sober Remarks, pag. 11.] "too slender a foundation to build upon in the present case; especially, if it be remembered, who were the compilers of that book, and what reason we have to conclude they were of the judgment, that Priests and Bishops are by God's law one and the same". This was certainly the doctrine of the Church of England in the beginning of the reformation, and of the generality of its pious and learned divines for a very considerable time afterwards [See the many quotations from their writings to this purpose, by the celebrated Dr. Stilling fleet, in his Jrenicum, pag. 394. and onwards.] .
IN Henry the eight's time, the Arch-Bishops, Bishops, Arch-Deacons, and Clergy of England, in their book intituled, "the instruction of a christian-man," subscribed with all their hands, and dedicated to the King, Anno. 1537; and King Henry himself, in his book stiled, "a necessary erudition for any christian-man," set out by the authority of the statute of 32. Henry VIII. chap. 26. approved by both houses of Parliament, prefaced with the King's own epistle, and published by his command Anno. 1543, expresly resolve, "that Priests and Bishops BY GOD'S LAW, are one and the same; and that the power of ORDINATION and excommunication belongs EQUALLY to them both. [Calamy's defence of mod, non-conformity, pag. 91.]
p. 9EDWARD the sixth no sooner came to the throne, than he took proper methods to go on with the reformation, begun in the former reign. …
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadContents
- ADVERTISEMENT.
- INTRODUCTION.p. 6
- Answer to Section I. which contains "a Sketch of the Arguments in…p. 9
- ANSWER to SECTION II. which says, "The Powers peculiar to the…p. 34
- ANSWER to SECTION III. which declares, the Church in AMERICA, without…p. 56
- ANSWER to SECTION IV. in which the unparalleled Hardship of this Case…p. 91
- ANSWER to SECTION V. assigning Reasons why the Church in America has…p. 103
- ANSWER to SECTION VI. which says the present Juncture is apprehended…p. 110
- ANSWER to SECTION VII. in which the Case of the American Heathens is…p. 125
- ANSWER to SECTION VIII. in which the Plan, on which alone American…p. 136
- ANSWER to SECTION IX. which pretends that the Episcopate proposed…p. 185
- ANSWER to SECTION XI. entitled, farther Suspicions and Objections…p. 193
Other works by Charles Chauncy
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.