The Validity of Presbyterian Ordination Asserted and Maintained
EEBO-TCP N07133 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 9089
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.
Dr. CHAUNCY'S DISCOURSE AT THE DUDLEIAN-LECTURE, AT HARVARD-COLLEGE IN CAMBRIDGE, MAY 12. 1762.
THE words I would prefix to the following discourse, as a proper MOTTO, are those inspired ones of the apostle PAUL,
NEGLECT not the gift that is in thee, which was given thee by prophecy, with the laying on the hands of the presbytery.
THE honorable judge DUDLEY
esteem'd the method of ordination, as practised in Scotland, at Geneva, among the dissenters in England, and in the churches in this country, to be safe, scriptural and valid.
And he firmly believed,
that the great head of the church, by his blessed spirit, had own'd, sanctified and blest the administration of gospel ordinances by persons ordained in this way; and that he would continue so to do to the end of the world.
It p. 6was accordingly his intention, that the discourse at this lecture should be adapted to the purpose of "explaining and maintaining" this kind of ordination. Not that he questioned "the validity of what is commonly called episcopal ordination, as performed in the church of England," or had it in his heart to encourage the saying any thing that would insinuate as tho' God had not blest, and would not go on to bless, the ministry of those who were thus ordained. Had none of the friends to ecclesiastical superiorities, according to the present episcopal form, been less wanting in candor and charity towards those who differ from them, we should never have heard of this lecture. It took rise, in the honorable founder's mind, from the narrow principles of those anathamatising zealots, who would confine salvation to their own church, by confining the validity of gospel ordinances to the administration of them by persons, upon whom the hands of a bishop, in their sense of the word, have been imposed. And he wisely ordered the preaching of it in this place, that our sons, who are sent here, from all parts of the land, to be trained up for public service, might be under advantage to hear and know the reasons, upon which they may, with all good conscience, join in communion with these churches, p. 7and officiate as pastors in them, should they, when fitted for it, be called thereto in the providence of God.
p. 7YOU are, by this time, at no loss to know the design of the present discourse; that it is to vindicate the New-England churches in their method of ordination by presbyters: or, in other words, to assert and maintain the safety and validity of what is commonly called presbyterian ordination, to the purposes of the gospel ministry.
ONLY, before I come to the argument upon this head, it may not be amiss to mention a few things, in which we agree with our opponents.
WE agree with them, it is the will of Christ there should be officers in his church to preach the word, to administer the sacraments, to exercise discipline, and to commit these powers to other faithful men; and that this will of his extends to all ages, till time shall be no more. "Lo, I am with you always, even to the end of the world." Whether it be his will, made known in the new-testament-revelation, or else-where, that this work of the sacred ministry should be divided, and differently lodged in the hands of two distinct orders of men, the p. 8one superior, the other inferior, we shall hear afterwards.
WE agree with them, that none should take upon them the ministerial office, unless they are qualified for it conformably to the apostolic directions in the epistles to Timothy and Titus; and, if they are thus qualified, that they have no right to officiate as pastors in the church of Christ, till they are called hereto. "No man taketh this honor to himself, but he that is called of God as was Aaron." This call, in the opinion of the church of England, includes not only an ability given by God for the work of the ministry, but the excitement of an actual readiness in the persons who have it freely to devote themselves to the gospel service. We go farther, and add hereto, the voice of the church. And herein the advantage lies undeniably on our side, whether an appeal be made to scripture, or primitive antiquity. Even after the distinction between bishops and presbyters took place, it was by the suffrage of the people that this or that person was selected for this or the other cure. In this way, Alexander was chosen bishop of Jerusalem [Euseb. Lib. 6. • . • 1] ; in the same way Fabianus was advanced to the see of Rome, upon the death of Anterus [Euseb. Lib. 6. • . 28.] , p. 9as was also his successor Cornelius [Cyprian. Epis. 67.] ; and it was by the same favor and suffrage of the people, "plebis favore," [Pontius in vita Cypriani.] "populi suffragio," [Cyprian. Epis. 55.40.] that Cyprian was elected bishop of Carthage. — But instead of mispending the time to prove that which is so well known to all, in any measure acquainted with antiquity, it may rather be lamented, that the churches of Christ have so generally had wrested from them, in one way or another, this invaluable privilege. The people, constituting the episcopal church at home, scarce know what it is to have pastors of their own chusing. And the case is much the same with most of the protestant churches in Europe. The right of nomination is almost universally lodged, not with the people, but with princes or patrons, either clerical or secular, in consequence whereof their ministers are not of their own chusing, but such as others chuse for them. The New-England churches, blessed be God, possess and exercise the right of electing their pastors in the most ample manner of any in the whole christian world. May they ever "stand fast in this liberty" wherewith he who is "head over all things," has "made them free"! And may their glory, in this respect, be never taken from them!
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadOther works by Charles Chauncy
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.