A Letter to the Author of the Pamphlet Called An Answer to the Hampshire Narrative
EEBO-TCP N03404 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 4152
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.
Reverend Sir,
WE your Brethren, in the calling of Jesus Christ; and Ministry of his Gospel, of the County of Hampshire, who from the Beginning of your acting in the Springfield Affair, have been looked upon, and treated by you, as especially, and above all others obnoxious. And in all your Proceedings, from first to last, have been the Butt of your Resentment and Obloquy, and especially in your Book called An Answer to the Hampshire Narrative, have been treated with Indignity and Contempt, and represented with a great Manifestation of Disdain and Insult as a Set of wicked, contemptible Men, looking upon it that you have gone out of the Way of your Duty, and acted much against the Honour of Christ, and the Interest of Christianity, and to the Prejudice of the ministerial Character, do think ourselves obliged, as we are your fellow Christians and Brethren in the Ministry, not only to vindicate ourselves, but to labour to lead you to a Sense of your Error, which p. 2tho' we have reason to fear, from the Temper and Prejudice you have discovered in your Answer, is not very likely to be successful; yet leaving the Event with GOD, we think ourselves bound to endeavour. And would observe in general, That you have almost wholly overlooked the Merits of the Cause in Dispute between us, and instead of that, have been pleased to divert your Readers with such ludicrous and unfriendly Reflections on our Narrative and Conduct, as you have tho't fit, for Reasons best known to yourself. And therefore, for our own Vindication and your Conviction, we have tho't it necessary to remark and reply to some of the exceptional Passages in it.
In Page 1 and 2, where you distinguish those who disapproved of Mr. Breck's Settlement at Springfield, and sent their Protest against it, from those that were called to judge in the Affair, speaking of the Letter, you say, of which Number were the eldest Ministers in their own County, whereby 'tis insinuated, that the eldest Ministers in the County acted, when you know that the true State of the Case was thus, That the eldest Minister of all in the County, and the eldest in the Province but one, was one that disapproved and protested; the two next acted: the four next disapproved; and the next acted: Which three were all in the County that acted. Now, Sir, the Case being thus, was not this that you gave an unfair Representation: We appeal to all your Readers that had their Information only from your Book, whether they han't been led by it, to apprehend the Case quite different from what we have now represented. In the same Place you blame us that we did not leave those eldest Ministers that acted with others, to act according to their own Light. And why, Reverend Sir, could not you, the Ministers that come from Boston, leave them to act according to their own Light, without taking such abundant Pains in urging them to act against what they of themselves were inclined to, as you know you did the Reverend Mr. Chauncey, the eldest that acted, who has often declared, in the hearing of some of us, that had he not been exceedingly importuned, he would not have acted, p. 3and that he long resisted and opposed, but that you overcame him, at both times of the Council's meeting. And the Reverend Mr. Devotion, before the Council came up, did sufficiently declare in our hearing, his Disinclination to act in the Case: And there are many other concurring Evidences, that he would not have acted had not you sent to him, urging him to it.
p. 3In Page 2, you boldly charge us with running this Controversy into the publick Prints. Certainly you ought not thus to have declared this to the World before you knew it; and yet afterwards, before you get to the Bottom of the Page, you implicitly confess, that you don't know it; for you speak of the two Letters in the Boston Journal, as published by us, or somebody that undertook our Vindication: If it was only somebody that undertook our Vindication, how does it thence follow, as you say, that we not being content that the Matter should remain the Subject of Conversation only, run it into the publick Prints: And yet afterwards again, in the Margin, you charge the publishing these Letters at such a Time, on us, as an Instance of our unfair Way of managing. Indeed, we none of us had any hand in publishing either of those Letters, and knew not that any such Letters were published, or like to be published, or were in Being, 'till we saw them in the publick Prints: And if they had been published by us, it would have been very injuriously said, that it was before any thing was published on the other side: Whereas you very well know, the Complaint of Springfield Church to the General Assembly, was published in the Boston Gazette, and the Letters refer'd to in your Answer, we suppose, were occasioned by that Publication, and a stolen Letter that was written on this Affair, was before this exposed in the publick Prints, with ludicrous Reflections, to render the Author, and the Cause he appeared in, ridiculous in the Eyes of the World.
Thus, Sir, instead of our running our own Writings first into Print, those of your Party stole 'em, and expos'd 'em, and ridicul'd 'em in the publick Prints. And then you write again▪ crying down both the Ministers p. 4and Magistrates of the County, before ever we publish'd any thing at all: And this after you had, in a great Measure filled the Country with Reproaches of us, and raised a general Cry against us, as a set of ambitious, arbitrary, and unjust Usurpers, in the principal Part of the Country, where we, by ◊◊ason of our Distance, have no other Way to speak for ourselves but by the Press: And then after all cry out of us for running the Matter into the publick Prints.
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadOther works by Jonathan Edwards
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.