Primary Source

Ignis Fatuus

William Guild 1625
Guild refutes Bellarmine's doctrine of purgatory using Old and New Testament arguments and the theologian's own scriptural proofs.

EEBO-TCP A02352 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 99854180; STC/Wing STC 12481; ESTC S118973

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.

p. 1OF PVRGATORY. The Romish Assertion.

THe Papistes describe their Purgatorie to bee a prison next to hell, [Bell. lib. 1. de Purg. c. 1. Et lib 2. c. 6.9. & 10.] where the soules of the faithfull that are defiled with veniall sinnes, and haue not satisfied heere the diuine. Iustice fully for mortall sinnes, are purged by a temporarie fire, as hote as that in hell, and very long; [Bell. lib. 1. de Indul. c. 9.] witnesse Bellarmines expresse words, saying; Constat plurimas annas in Purgatorio, 〈…〉 Iudicij, id est, per multas annorum centiuias esse cruciandas. [Ibidem.] Yea, Non videtur negandum (saith hee) posse aliquos nos p. 2fidei penitentiae agendae per spatium aliquot millium annorum.

p. 2Our Assertion.

WEe denie any such Purgatorie, affirming that Christ is our onely and perfect purger by his Blood. And that the word (Purging) is metaphorically taken from the washing of corporall vncleannesse, to signifie the cleansing of the Soule from sinne, which is called the vncleannesse thereof. Zech. 13.1. So that, as an vncleane spot is said to bee purged when it is taken away; euen so are sinnes when they are remitted. Iohn 1.29. 1 Iohn 1.7.9.

Also, because Christ calleth our sinnes Metaphorically (Debts;) therefore such also is the word (Satisfaction,) God the Father being the Creditor, wee the Debtors, and Christ the Cautioner; p. 3who hauing fully satisfied our debt for vs, hath thereby freely freed vs at his Fathers hands from it; and therefore is called our payment and ransome. 1 Tim. 2.6. Math. 20.28.

p. 3In these foure poynts then consisteth all our difference.

1. Wee say, that Christ (by himselfe) hath fully satisfied for vs. Heb. 1.3.

They ioyne mans owne satisfaction for himselfe in Purgatorie also.

2. Wee say, that it is Christ (onely) that purgeth vs by his blood, 1 Ioh. 1.9.

They ioyne a fire that doth so also.

3. Wee say, that his blood purgeth vs from (all our sinnes) 1 Ioh. 1.7.

They say, from mortall onely.

4. Wee say, that hee perfectly purgeth vs (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) Heb. 7.25.

They say, That hee purgeth the guilt only, and taketh away the eternall punishment; p. 4but as for the temporall, we must satisfie for it our selues.

p. 4Arguments against Purgatorie, and to prooue our Assertion.

1. Out of the Old Testament.

Ezek. 18.22. If the wicked returne, I will not remember all his iniquities: that is, I shall forget them all; as not to hold guiltlesse, is to hold guiltie. Hence we argue:

That which God forgets, as if it had neuer been; for that hee punisheth no wayes by any satisfactory punishment, which is cleare, 1 King. 17.18. where punishment is made onely the sequell of remembrance.

But hee forgets all the sinnes of the conuerted sinner, Ezek 18.22.

Ergo, for them he punisheth him no wise by any satisfactory punishment.

[Bell. lib. 1. de Purg. c. 12. Bell. lib 4. de Pan. c. 13.] And whereas Bellarmine by not (to remember) would meane, not to punish eternally onely: wee answere him with his owne rule; non nostrum est restringere, quod Deus amplum esse voluit: It is not lawfull to man to make a restriction of that by a circumstance of time, which is so comfortably promised, and freely by God.

Isai. 57.1. The righteous is taken away from the euill to come; hee shall enter into peace. Whence wee reason:

p. 5If the righteous be taken away from a lesse euill on earth in mercie, that they may neither see nor feele the common calamitie, then they are not particularly themselues put to suffer a greater in Purgatory; and there to enter, not into peace, but torment, to satisfie Iustice.

But they are taken away from a lesse euill, that they see it not, in mercy.

Ergo, much more from the feeling of a greater themselues, in Iustice.

Ecclesiastes 12.7. Then shall dust returne to the earth, but the Spirit to God that gaue it. Hence wee argue:

The soule that returnes or ascends to God that gaue it, after bodily departure, descends not to the fire of Purgatorie except they would make to goe to, [Bell. lib. 2. de Purg. c. 13.] and goe from Go◊ and Satan, (whom they say torments the Soule in Purgatorie) heauen and hell to be all one.

But the soules of the godly returne to God that gaue them, and are receiued by him; as Act. 7.59.

p. 5Ergo, they goe not to the fire of Purgatory.

Psal. 32.1, 2. Blessed is the man whose transgression is forgiuen, whose sinne is couered, and to whom the Lord imputeth not iniquitie. Hence we reason:

He whose sinne is forgiuen, the same is couered (saith Dauid;) and what is couered, is not seene; and what is not seene, is not imputed; and what is not imputed, cannot by any satisfactory punishment bee punished. [Lomb. l. 4. Sent. dist. 18.] Therefore saith Lombard (as Bellarmine grants) Deum tunc tegere peccata, quando ad poenam non reseruat. And to take away the evasion of meaning onely the eternall punishment, p. 6Therefore (saith Chrysostome) where there is grace, [Chrys. in 4. ad Rom. Hom. 8.] there is forgiuenes; and where there is forgiuenes, there is no punishment at all. And Augustine on this Psalme saith, Si texit peccata, noluit aduertere; si noluit aduertere, noluit punire; noluit ne vel agnoscere, maluit ignoscere.

Now to subsume. But so it is, that the sinnes of the godly are forgiuen, couered, vnseene, and not imputed, as saith the Psalmist.

Ergo, they are not by any satisfactorie worke or suffering punished. Punishment being euer the worke of Iustice, and making the partie punished, wretched; and pardon being euer the worke of mercy, and making the partie pardoned, blessed: and so being incompatible.

Psal. 51.7. Purge mee, and I shall be whiter then snow. Whence we argue:

If to purge away sinne, and to remit, be all one, as is euident, 1 Iohn 1.19. and that none can remit sinne but God onely, Mark. 2.7. therefore it followeth, that God onely purgeth sinne; and consequently no other thing can doe so.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. TO THE TRVELY Noble, Right Honourable, and Religious, IOHN, Earle of Laderdail, Lord…
  2. To the READER.
  3. OF PVRGATORY. The Romish Assertion.p. 1
  4. Our Assertion.p. 2
  5. In these foure poynts then consisteth all our difference.p. 3
  6. Arguments against Purgatorie, and to prooue our Assertion.p. 4
  7. Arguments against Purgatorie, and to prooue our Assertion out of the…p. 8
  8. Arguments against Purgatory, and for our Assertion out of Bellarmin…p. 21
  9. 1. Their Confession, and arguments of their owne Doctors for vs.p. 21
  10. 2. Scriptures adduced by Bellarmine, to proue, that the Saints…p. 23
  11. 3. Fathers adduced by Bellarmine himselfe, to proue that the Saints…p. 25
  12. 4. Reasons adduced by Bellarmine, to proue the Saints present…p. 27
  13. Bellarmines Arguments for Purgatory answered.p. 28
  14. AN ANNEXE TO this Treatise of Purgatorie, concerning the Distinction of Sinne into…p. 49

Other works by William Guild

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.