A Vindication of the Power, Obligation and Encouragement of the Unregenerate to Attend the Means of Grace
EEBO-TCP N09758 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 12416
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.
SECT. I. The State of the question.
THEY who have been conversant with controversial writings need not be informed what vexatious wrangles are often carried on about the true state and meaning of the question in dispute; each party confidently charging the other with maintaining propositions which they utterly disown. One great cause of which we have reason to think is because men aim rather to display their own talent at reasoning, than to instruct those in meekness who are in opposition to them. They who have this in ◊iew, to run down and triumph over an antagonist at all events, if they find themselves unable to confute what he has really asserted, must pretend that he ho◊ds to something which they imagine themselves able to confute. But though the due exercise of charity and a candid fair spirit towards those with whom they may have to do in a way of disputation, would no doubt much shorten p. 2their work, and disincumber their discourses of abundance of vain jangling; yet so imperfect are our conceptions, and such is the ambiguity of language, the best medium we have of communicating our ideas, that even intelligent persons, and those mutually well affected, will many times strangely mistake the designed purport of each others expressions.
Had it not been for our distant situation from each other, I would, before I entred the lists of public debate with the Rev. Mr. Hopkins, have tried whether by private conference, or letters, the difference of opinion that appears to be between us might not have been somewhat narrowed and reduced.—But at present I have no other way of entring into his views than by what he has published; which while I examine with freedom, I hope I shall not transgress the law of charity towards a fellow labourer in the Gospel, or the rules of modesty towards one, who, on other accounts besides superiority of age, is intitled to respectful treatment from the author of the ensuing essay.
The subject now to be discussed having never (that I know of) been controverted among professed Christians till very lately, it will be the more necessary for us to take care that we conceive aright of the question proposed to consideration—And that the state of the question may be truly and plainly represented, it will be necessary for us in the first place to distinguish it from some other questions with which it may inadvertently be confounded.—Let it then be carefully observed.
p. 2The question is not whether it be the duty of the unregenerate to obey all and each of the commands of God. The obligation of all mankind to obey the divine law, is on both sides equally acknowledged.
p. 3Nor is it disputed whether there be ordinarily a work of the holy Spirit upon the soul preparatory to regeneration. This we both plead for.
It is also mutually allowed that this preparatory work is ordinarily carried on by means of the outward dispensation of the word, and other divine ordinances.
And that the Endeavours of the unregenerate in attending on God's word and ordinances are, by his appointment and blessing, subservient to this preparatory work.
And further, that God has some way given encouragement to the endeavours of the unregenerate in a way of attendance on the means of grace.— This, though perhaps denied by some, with whom at present we concern not ourselves, is expresly granted by Mr. H. I shall now propose that state of the question which Mr. H. has given in the second part of his reply to the Rev. Mr. Mills, p. 116.
'The question' says he
is, whether there are any commands given to the unregenerate which do not require any thing holy, but only require such exercises and doings which they may and do comply with while they are perfect enemies to true holiness?
If Mr. H. had only maintained the negative of the question as above proposed, the difference which seems to be between him and those who maintain that something is enjoined upon and required of sinners in a way of duty previous and preparatory to regeneration, might I conceive be accommodated without much trouble.—For we conceive that there is no inconsistency in supposing that a divine command which requires holiness, and nothing but what is some way included in holiness, does yet require and oblige to the performance of some actions, which taken nakedly in themselves, separate from such circumstances, qualifications and adjuncts as ought to p. 4accompany them, have not the complete essence of holiness.—We conceive that the holiness of an action consists in its entire conformity to the divine law, in itself, its principles, end a◊d manner.—That the law which requires the whole of what is necessary to constitute an action holy, does also require each of those things in particular which are involved and conjoined in every act of holy obedience, although the complete essence of holiness is not found in any of those particulars detached from the rest. There is a great breadth in the divine law, to which every act of t◊ue holiness must be some way answerable. Whatever particular is comprehended in the duty required by any divine precept, is therefore matter of duty because contained in the command; and yet it will not follow, either that whatever is contained in the duty required has (taken by itself) the whole of what is essential to true holiness, or that there is any command which does not require any thing holy, but only requires unholy acts. In a word, we conceive that it may very consistently be maintained, that though no actions of the unregenerate are so fully conformable to the divine command as that they can be denominated holy in the least degree, being essentially defective in divers respects; yet some actions are conformable to the divine command in some respects, and are therefore comprehended in the requirement of it.
p. 4Whether such conceptions of the commands of God and of the actions of the unregenerate are agreable to scripture and reason will afterwards be examined. Our present design is not to argue points, but to open the subject of the ensuing enquiry. But it is very manifest that Mr. H—'s aim and design is not so much to prove that there is no command which requires only such actions as may be done in p. 5a state of unregeneracy, but that no actions of the unregenerate are required at all. If he would admit that they were required at all in any divine precept, and that consequently we had any divine warrant to inculcate upon sinners an attendance on the means of grace, as preparatory to regeneration, I would never contend with him, though he should at the same time hold that this is not the whole duty contained in and injoined upon them by such precept. The question then is not, as he has represented,
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadContents
- The power, obligation and encouragement of the unregenerate to attend the means of grace…
- SECT. I. The State of the question.p. 2
- SECT. II. An enquiry into the character of the unregenerate, their…p. 6
- SECT. III. Arguments proving that something is required of Men in a…p. 100
- SECT. IV. A Reply to Mr. Hopkins's Arguments.p. 203
- Conclusion.p. 226
Other works by Moses Hemmenway
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.