Primary Source

A Disquisition Concerning Ecclesiastical Councils

Increase Mather 1716
Mather argues that both pastors and delegated church members possess equal voting rights in ecclesiastical councils, advancing Congregational polity and church consociation proposals.

EEBO-TCP N01544 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 1836

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.

p. 1A DISQUISITION Concerning Ecclesiastical Councils.

AN Ecclesiastical Council, or Synod, is a Convention of duly qualified Persons, called to Consult, and judge about Affairs, in which Churches, one or more are concerned. There have been great Disputes on that Question, Who has Power to Convoke a Synod? Whether it belongs to Magistrates, or to Pastors. I shall not insist upon that Enquiry, only say, that if we keep to Scripture, Churches have this Power Belonging to them. There have likewise been some who have decried all Ecclesiastical Councils as useless, p. 2nay, pernicious; and as having always done hurt to the Interest of Religion. Nazianzen's [in Epist. ad Procopium.] Expressions Concerning this, are famously known. Bellarmine Charges Luther with being of that Opinion, but he wrongs him. If Luther was against all Councils, why does Bellarmine complain of his being President of a Council, Convened at Wittenberg, in the Year 1536. in which there were (as he says) Three Hundred Pastors. I know not of one Protestant Writer of any Fame, that dislikes all Synods, Grotius only Excepted: It cannot be denied, but that the greatest part of Ecclesiastical Convocations, have done more against the Truth then for it, as any man that Consults Alsted's Chronology of Councils, will easily perceive. But this has proceeded not from the nature of Councils, but from the faultiness of the Persons, of whom they were Co◊stituted. The greatest part of Magistrates, and of Miniisters, and of Professed Christians have been Erroneous and Vicious. This p. 3ought not to prejudice Men against Magistracy, and Ministry, and Christianity. The same is to be affirmed of Synods, of which also there have been more than a few that have been blessed for the Suppression of Errors, and Establishment of the Churches in the Truth. Several Particular and Provincial Synods have given a faithful Testimony against Errors, both in Judgment and Practice. Writers inform us, that [Eachard. Eccles. History, p. 343.] The first Ecclesiastical Council, after that held at Jerusalem, was in the year 180.

p. 3in which the Heresy of Montan◊s, and his Followers was Condemn'd. There was a Synod in Arabia. A. D. 240. In which Origen was the President. This Synod Condemned Soul-sleepers. Th◊t in Arabia, A. D. 260. did good S◊◊ vice for the Churches, in Refuti◊◊ and Condemning the Haere◊ies of Paul of Samosata, and the Paulinites, as they were Called. And the four Oecuminical Councils (altho' as Calvin, and many others have observed( we cannot say that any one of them was p. 4altogether free from Error in some lesser points, were blessed for the Suppressing of the Haere◊ies, which did infest the Church in those Ages. The Nicene Synod, in which there were 318 Bishops, or Pastors, besides a numerous Company of Elders, and others whom the Emperour himself, the great Constantine honoured with his Presence, Condemned the Heresy of Arius. This has been Esteemed the most Celebrious Synod that ever was in the World. 2. The first General Council at Constantinople, in which there were an hundred and fifty Pastors, Condemned the Heresy of Macedonius. 3. In the great Ephesine Synod, there were two hundred Pastors, in which the Heresy of Nestorius, who maintained that Christ is two Persons, was Condemned. This Synod Convened, A. D. 431. In this very City of Ephesus, there was another Synod, though not a general one) held but nineteen years after the first; in which an Heretica◊ Error on the other Extream was Established, and several Members of the Synod Compelled by Tortures to Subscribe the Decrees of the Majority. In p. 5so short a time have Synods in the same place, greatly varied from one another. 4. In the General Synod at Chalcedon, A. D. 451. there was 630 Pastors, besides Presbyters and Laymen, as they are called: This Synod was of great use in Confuting and Condemning the Heresy of Entyches, who held that there was but one Nature belonging to our Saviour Christ; it appears by these mentioned, that notwithstanding Councils are not infallible, nevertheless, they have been very helpful to discover the Truth, and settle the Churches in the profession of it. They are necessary, tho' not absolutely to the Being, yet to the Well-being of Churches. I have said nothing of the Synods which have been among the Reformed, in these latter Ages, in France and Holland, and in other Countries, by some of which the Interest of the true Religion has been a great gainer. It has been Objected by some, Where have we an Institution for Synods? We answer, that the Light of Nature directs unto it: Plus vident Oculi, quam Oculus. Many Eyes see more than one. The Scripture says, Where no Counsel is the p. 6People fall, but in the multitude of Counsellors there is safety. Prov. 11. 14. And therefore they that are wise, will in their difficulties ask for Counsel. 2 Sam. 20. 18. They were w◊nt to speak in old time, saying, they shall surely ask Counsel at Abel; and so they ended the Matter. Moreover, we have Scripture Example for a Synod. The Church in Antioch, and that at Jerusalem, under the Conduct of the Apostles, Convened in order to Consulting on a Question, which was of common Concernment to them. Dr. Owen [Of Gospel Churches. p. 252.] therefore rightly observes, That Synods are Consecrated to the use of the Church in all Ages, by the Example of the Apostles, in their guidance of the first Churches of Je◊s and Gentiles, which had the force of a Divine Institution, as being by them under the Conduct of the Holy Spirit.

p. 6These things being premised, I proceed to what I have principally designed in this Disquisition. There are two Problems relating to Ecclesiastical Council◊, which I▪ have been desired to Exdress my Thoughts and Judgment concerning p. 7them. One of the Questions is,

Whether no Acts of Councils are to be received as Concluding and Decisive, for which there is not the Concurrence of the Major part of the Pastors therein Concerned?

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Other works by Increase Mather

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.