Primary Source

The Doctrine of Unsanctified Communicants Examined and Confuted

Increase Mather 1708
Mather examines and refutes the doctrine permitting unsanctified persons to receive communion, while appending scriptural evidence for anticipated church reformation within years.

EEBO-TCP N01147 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. STC/Wing Evans 1366

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

SAcramenta non Largiuntur aliquid Gratioe sed renunciant et ostendunt quoe divina Largitate nobis data sunt.

Sacramenta tantum Conversis sunt instituta.

Pareus in Cat. Explicat. Q. 84.

THERE are in Mr. Stoddards Preface to his Sermon, several Passages very Exceptionable. One is, his Complaining, That those Holy men who first Planted this Land, did not acknowledge a Publick Government in the Church. Which is a mistake. For they did declare in the most Publick manner that can be, That there is a Form of ChurchGovernment, which is of Divine Institution, and also what that Form is. Not only has Mr. Cotton done it, in his Book of the Keys of the Kingdom, and of the Way of the Churches in New-England; And Mr. Hooker, in his Survey. And my Father, in his Answer to Thirty Two Questions; which goeth under the Name of the Elders of New-England. And Mr. Norton, in his Answer to the Queries, Proposed by Apollonij, (a Famous Dutch Minister of the Presbyterian perswasion) a very Learned Book, and the First that ever was Written in New-England, or I suppose in America, in the Latin Tongue. But moreover, a Synod of the Elders and Messengers of the Churches, Meeting at Cambridge, 1648. has Published a Platform of Church Discipline, Gathered out of the Word of God. Blessed Mr. Norton, in his Dying Sermon, Expressed himself thus,

Remember that we have the Pattern in the Mount, I mean we have the Scripture as a Rule, & you have the Platform of Church-Discipline, given to you in way of Counsel, as the Confession of our Faith, in this way of Church-Government; that which for the Substance of it owns the Cause Congregational, if any are departed from it, let them look to it; I know none of the Elders that are receded from it. It was given many Years ago as the Confession of our Faith to this Countrey, and to the World. It is distinct from the Episcopacy, & from the Presbyterian Way; from the Morellian Way, and from that of Separatism; and is for the Substance of it, precisely the Way Congregational: We have the Pattern: only this is complained of, that it is not practised, tho' we had it many Years ago. Now Practice is the end of Doctrine;—Let the Churches look to it, we are all concerned herein. Our Fidelity in this cause is our Crown. See that it be not taken from us.

Thus spoke that Learned & Holy man, who was in his time the Glory of Boston, in the Last Sermon that ever he Preached; and therefore his Words ought to have the more Weight with us. Were the Platform of Discipline, together with what was Unanimously agreed unto concerning the Conscociation of Churches, in the Synod which met in Boston, 1662, duely attended, we need no other, nor better Church-Government, than what our Blessed Predecessors have commended to us. It is true, That they never did acknowlege such a Scheme of Church-Government as Mr. S. and perhaps no man besides himself, would have. But there is no reason that therefore they should be Charged with Failure in not acknowledging a Publick Government in the Church.

Another Particular in his Preface, which has given Offence, is, The Conclusion of it, desiring the Reader, Not to act like those, who told the Prophet, As for the Word which thou hast spoken to us in the Name of the Lord, we will not hearken to thee. But is he a Prophet Divinely Inspired? Is the not hearkening to his New, and Singular Notions, which are Contradictory not only to the Doctrine taught by the Former Ministers in New-England, (Prophets if ever there were any among us) but also by the whole Body of Protestant Divines in the most Reformed Churches, a Sin like that of the Jew, who regarded not what the Inspired Prophet delivered to them in the Name of the Lord. When we are satisfyed that his New Doctrine is according to the Word of the Lord, we will readily hearken to it, and say as a great Man among the Reformers did, Veniat, Veniat verbum Dei, et si nobis Essent Sexcenta colla, Subijceremus. In the mean time, we shall endeavour to Examine all things, and hold fast that which is good. There have been some who by reading the Books of their Antagonists, have been brought over to their Perswasion. Vergerius took Calvins Institutions into his hands purposing a Confutation of it, but was himself confuted by it. Dr. Owen designed an Answer to Mr. Cottons Book of the Keys, but upon a serious consideration of it, declared himself to be of the same judgment. Mr. Robinson (a Worthy Divine) by a Book which Dr. Ames Wrote against some of his Opinions, was brought off from his Rigidity in divers Points, Lately in Holland, a Learned man whose Name was Christopher Christopher, Published a Book in which he ascribes to Angels things Peculiar to the Holy and Eternal Spirit. Dr. Witsius, now Professor of Divinity in the University of London, Wrote against him, and he was thereby Reduced from his Errors. I Expect no such thing from Mr. S. He that has slighted Mr. Gillespies Arguments, will doubtless do so by mine. Yet would it be no Dishonour for him to change his Opinion, Nullus pudor ad mepiora transire. However, I hope that by this Collision the Truth will gain, and the Churches be more Established, in an adherence to the Doctrine which they have according to the Word of the Lord, been Taught by those Blessed men, who now rest from their Labours. And it is a rejoycing to me, in that I know I shall by what is here done, obtain the Blessing of the Prayers of many Godly Souls in these Churches, which I value above all the Gold in America.

Notwithstanding his Errors (for so I must account them) in the Controverted Questions, I esteem him a Pious Brother, and an Able Minister of the New Testament, a Serious Practical Preacher, in his Ministry designing the Conversion and Edification of the Souls of men; and as such, I do, & shall Love and Honour him: and hope that we shall in the Lords time, meet where Luther and Zwinglius differ not in their Opinions.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. The Preface.
  2. CHAP. II.p. 19
  3. CHAP. III.p. 27
  4. CHAP. IV.p. 30
  5. CHAP. VI.p. 36
  6. CHAP. VII.p. 62
  7. CHAP. VIII.p. 64
  8. CHAP. IX.p. 73
  9. An Appendix, TO THE Preceding Dissertation:p. 91
  10. A SERMONp. 111

Other works by Increase Mather

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.