Quo Warranto
EEBO-TCP A55393 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 13621122; STC/Wing Wing P2850; ESTC R33938
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.
p. 1Touching the Relation of the MINISTRY.
COncerning the Epistle prefixed by our Brethren to their Book, I shall say nothing, because they run out into impertinent Controversies concerning the Catholick visible Church, the matter of a Church, Church Covenant, &c. And indeed it is needlesse I should say any thing about them, they having been so fully ventilated by so many Learned Authours, as Hudson, Rutherford, Wood, Cawdrey, and many others; and Dr Collings in particular hath Answered this Epistle, whither I referre the Reader: and therefore I come 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, to the Answer of the Book.
Wherein I shall crave no more liberty then our Brethren took, and I shall use their own words, Pag. 1. Though I intend not to Reply to every particular, yet I shall give such Animadversions upon the most considerable things, as will leave it unnecessary to speak to the rest. This I shall solemnly promise, that I will not willingly decline any thing, which is either strong, or plausible, or considerable, but only such passages, as, the foundations being shaken, do fall of themselves: And under this promise I hope I may be excused from following our Brethren 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 ▪ (which commonly occasions personal reflections, and p. 2heterogeneous excursions.) And, although it were easie to cast the work into a more convenient mold, yet, that the Reader may with greater ease compare their Book and the Answer, I thought fit to observe their order, and to distinguish it according to their Chapters.
1. THey Question, What is meant by the Ministry? And here (to passe by impertinencies) because a Minister is called so from ministration, they infer, That gifted men, whose ordinary work or calling is to Preach, may properly be called Ministers of the Gospel; pag. 3. For my part I shall never blot paper with contending about words: Our Question is not about Names, but Things; And if the word Minister may be applied to twenty persons, we are not concerned in it; for the Question is not, Whether a Gifted brother, whose work or calling is to preach, may be called a Minister? (for even he who never preaches, if he any other way minister to the Gospel, may be called a Minister of the Gospel, according to their own arguments) but Whether such a Gifted brother may preach? and Whether the title Minister, in its special and distinct acception may be applied to him? And in both these we hold the Negative.
2. Their second Question is not much more important, viz. Whether the Office of the Ministry be a relation to the Work of the Ministry, or to the Church? And here they tax the Assembly, for saying that the Office of the Ministry is better defined by relation to the Work, than to a particular people. Where I desire it may be observed, that the Assembly did not say, The Office of the Ministry is better defined by relation to the Work, than to the Church in generall, p. 3but than to a particular Church: It was not the design of the Assembly to deny the Ministry to be a relation to the Church, nor yet was it their businesse accurately to insist upon the notions of relate and correlate; they never called the Work of the Ministry, the correlate, but only obiter and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, they asserted the Office of the Ministry to be better defined by relation to the Work, than to a particular Church, which our Brethren have not here disproved; but only endeavoured to prove that the Office of the Ministry rather consisteth in relation to the Church in general, than to the Work; so that all their labour, as to that particular, might have been spared. To which may be added, that we must distinguish between the abstract Ministry, and the concrete a Minister.
p. 3And although the Minister in the concrete have the Church for his Correlatum, yet that the Ministry in the abstract should have relation to the Work, is no more absurd, then that the Office of a King should have relation to ruling, which, I think, no sober man will deny; and especially when such a thing is brought in occasionally by a person not minding, nor obliged to minde the 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 of words; it were a vanity in any man to batter down such an expression by a quaternion of Arguments, which our Brethren have attempted to do.
To which may be added, that that rule upon which their first Argument hangs, viz. Relata sunt simul, & do mutuo se ponere & tollere, is true only of Predicamentall, but not of Transcendentall relations, such as this is; whose being is not wholly respective, [Suarez Metap.] as the Masters of the Metaphysicks inform us.
And the same answer also may serve for the second Argument (which indeed is but the same) viz. That relations must be together, but the Office is a means to the Work as an end, and so the Office must needs be first, and therefore p. 4they are not relatives. To which I answer, 1. As before, The rule holds not of Transcendentall relations. 2. A potentiall being is sufficient in relations: My knowledge of a Rose to be in the spring is related to that Rose even in winter; and yet the Rose doth not actually, but only potentially exist in winter.
The other two Arguments are trivial, and therefore I shall dilate no further about them, because this is a Logical and no Theological Controversie.
Qu. Whether Ministers are only Ministers to their particular Flocks?
IN handling of this I shall 1. State the Question plainly and faithfully. 2. I shall offer some Arguments for the Negative. 3. I shall enquire what our Brethren have to say for the Affirmative.
For the state of this Question we must take notice of another Question, whence it hath its rise and being, to wit, Whether besides particular Congregational Churches, there be any other visible Political Churches mentioned in Scripture? It hath till these last times been universally received in the Church of God, that, Besides that union and communion, whereby the members of a particular Church meet together in a Congregation for the Word and Sacraments, there is another union and communion, whereby particular Churches do by their Delegates (because in their persons they all cannot) meet together, combine, consult and conclude in common, as they judge most expedient for the good of their particular Churches.
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadContents
- The EPISTLE to the READER.
- Touching the Relation of the MINISTRY.p. 1
- CHAP. I.p. 2
- CHAP. II. & III.p. 4
- CHAP. IV.p. 39
- State of the Question.p. 39
- CHAP. V.p. 43
- CHAP. VI.p. 60
- CHAP. VII.p. 82
- CHAP. VIII.p. 91
- CHAP. IX.p. 95
- The Arguments alledged by them to prove that unordained men may…p. 116
- The Arguments alledged by us, to prove that unordained men may not…p. 117
- CHAP. XI.p. 119
- CHAP. XII.p. 130
- CHAP. XIII.p. 136
- CHAP. XIIII.p. 146
- CHAP. XV.p. 152
- Only that the Reader may see the fruit of our Brethrens opinion (as indeed posito uno…p. 160
Other works by Matthew Poole
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.