Primary Source

A Reply to Dr. Morton's General Defence of Three Innocent Ceremonies

William Ames 1622
Ames's 1622 defense of Reformed worship practices against Bishop Morton's justification of ceremonial elements in Anglican ecclesiastical tradition.

EEBO-TCP A19178 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 99835978; STC/Wing STC 559; ESTC S100126

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.

VVHATSOEVER is objected in this Section for the All-sufficiencie or perfect fulnesse of the Scripture, I will take for granted, because nothing is denyed by the Defendant. It is granted therefore at the first entrance, that the Scripture condemneth whatsoever is done, not onely against the vvarrant and direction of the Word, but also that vvhich is done beside it.

BVT that which before the Defendant durst not denie, now he commeth to oppose in the proofes of it: Which is a strange course, in him especially that professeth a distinct logicall proceeding.

In the propounding of our confirmation, I note two things once here in the beginning for all following occasions to be marked, 1 this Defendant doth us wrong in distributing our confirmations into those vvhich are taken from Scriptures, and those that are from the Fathers, and those that are from Protestant Divines: as if these were in our estimation of the same kinde. Wheras we professe that vvee ascribe no force unto any testimony of man, as if it vvere a proofe, but onely bring such allegations in as illustrations in regard of our adversaries perverse prejudice. 2 He vvrongeth us likewise in that difference vvhich he insinuateth betwixt the Fathers and our Divines, calling their testimonies Iudgements, and the other onely Confessions: we acknowledge no such imparitie. If this vvere nothing but idle rhetorick in the Defendant, it may be passed by.

In the answer brought to Heb. 3 2, vve haue this distinction given us: some points concerning religion are doctrinall, and some meerly ceremoniall. The former are sufficiently revealed in Scripture: but the latter are left to the libertie of the Church. But 1 vvhy is that denyed here by a distinction, which passed vvithout deniall or distinction in the former section? 2 vvhat kind of distinction is this, vvhich doth not distinguish of any terme vvhich is in the objection? 3 the Defendant should haue done vvell to haue explained and confirmed his distinction. For doctrinall opposed to ceremoniall in the formall signification of these vvords, I never heard of before that I remember: and sure I am no sound reason vvill allow. Ceremoniall is opposed to Morall, and sometime to substantiall; but to doctrinall it cannot properly, because there is ceremoniall doctrine as vvell as morall or substantiall. 4 To vvhich of these points vvill the Def referre the Hierarchie of Bishops? or are they no points of Religion? For the negatiue part of this answer, that ceremoniall points of Religion are not revealed in the Scripture, but left to the libertie of the Church: it is too too nakedly set down for to beare any colour of truth vvith it. For 1 vvas this true before the comming of Christ? then all the ceremoniall law is Apocriphall. 2 is this true universally (as it is heere set down) in the new Testament? then vvater in baptisme, and bread and wine in the Lords Supper, are no ceremoniall points of Religion. 3 the caution that is given Deut. 4. 2 and such like, did they not conteyne in them ceremoniall points of Religion? then it vvas lawfull for the Iewes, to adde, detract, and alter the ceremonies according to their pleasure; and doth not that law binde us as vvell as the Iewes? then vve doe the Papists wrong, in putting them to so much trouble as vve doe in finding out shifts to avoide the dint vvhich such places giue them.

But to leaue this mishapen distinction: An answer is given at length to the place alledged out of Heb. 3. 2 concerning the comparison betwixt Christ and Moses: sect. 4 5.

IN this Section comparison is made betwixt Christ and Moses in reall faithfulnes, as he calleth it. But this sufficeth not to loose the knot. For Moses vvas faithfull in all the house of God, and Christ vvas not inferiour, but in all parts of his office Propheticall concerning all points of Religion, vvas no doubt as faithfull as Moses.

HEre the Defendant can find nothing to bring out of Scripure for Christs faithfulnesse in rituall ordinances, but as Moses appointed ceremonies, so Christ removed them. Is not this a proper explication of Scripture, to interpret a similitude by a dissimilitude? The Scripture maketh Christ like unto Moses: this Defendant expoundeth the likenesse to be in this, that Christ pulled down that which Moses had set up.

Out of M. Calvin, Instit. lib. 4. c. 10. S. 30. he taketh upon him to decide this question. But he should haue dealt more plainly, and according to the scope of his author, if he had cited Bellarmine de pont. l. 4. c. 17. where the same words are according to his meaning. For in that place of Calvin there is nothing at all which vvithout grosse aequivocation will serve the Defendants purpose: For Calvins meaning was nothing lesse then to teach that Christ had given libertie unto men for to prescribe at their discretion mysticall signes in the Church: but onely to dispose of such circumstances as in their kind are necessarie, but in particular determination doe varie. He instanceth in the next section in the circumstance of time, vvhat houre the congregation should meet: in the place, how large, or in what fashion the Church should bee built: in meere order, what Psalmes should be sung at one time, and what another time. These and such like circumstances of order and comelinesse, equally necessary in civill and religious actions are understood by Calvin: not significant ceremonies, proper unto religious worship, such as ours are now in controversie. This allegation therefore borroweth all the shew it hath from the ambiguous meaning of the word ceremonies.

The same deceit is in the known case which the Defendant adjoyneth to Calvins words. For if by Rites he meaneth such circumstances of order and decencie, as were before mentioned, then I grant all he saith: but if by Rites he meaneth ceremonies properly of religious nature, use, and signification, such as the crosse in baptisme, and surplice are knowne to be, then there is no reason in his speech. For 1. there is no necessitie that in any nation the Churches should haue any religious ceremonie of spirituall signification, beside those which Christ hath appointed to all: and if the Defendant can shew any such necessitie, then I would desire him also to shew by what rules, and for vvhat cause these religious ceremonies imposed upon us in England, are fitter for us, or tend more to our edification, then other ceremonies would, or then they would in any other nation under heaven. Except both these positions be proved, the words of this section are all but wind: and proved I am sure they never were nor will be.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. THE PREFACE.
  2. SECT. II.p. 1
  3. SECT. III.p. 1
  4. SECT. IIII.p. 18
  5. SECT. V.p. 3
  6. SECT. VI. VII.p. 4
  7. SECT. VIII. IX. X. XI.p. 5
  8. SECT. XII.p. 28
  9. SECT. XIII.p. 29
  10. SECT. XIIII.p. 30
  11. SECT. XV.p. 87
  12. SECT. XVI.p. 9
  13. SECT. XVII.p. 12
  14. SECT. XVIII.p. 12
  15. SECT. XIX.p. 13
  16. SECT. XX.p. 14
  17. SECT. XXI.p. 15
  18. SECT. XXII.p. 15
  19. SECT. I.p. 58
  20. SECT. VI.p. 18
  21. SECT. VII.p. 21
  22. SECT. IX.p. 22
  23. SECT. X.p. 24
  24. SECT. XI.p. 26
  25. SECT. I. II.p. 33
  26. SECT. VIII.p. 42
  27. SECT. XIII. XIIII.p. 45
  28. SECT. XV. XVI.p. 46
  29. SECT. XVII. XVIII. XIX. XX. XXI.p. 52
  30. SECT. XXIII. XXIIII. XXV. XXVI.p. 50
  31. SECT. XXVII.p. 51
  32. SECT. XXVIII.p. 48
  33. SECT. XXIX.p. 54
  34. SECT. XXX.p. 55
  35. SECT. XXXI.p. 56
  36. SECT. XXXII.p. 57
  37. SECT. XXXIIII.p. 57
  38. SECT. XXIII.
  39. SECT. XXIIII.
  40. SECT. XXV.p. 72
  41. SECT. XXVI. XXVII.p. 72
  42. SECT. I. ad X.p. 75
  43. I thought good, overseeing the Presse, to confirme the Authors…p. 86
  44. SECT. XIX. XX.p. 89
  45. SECT. IIII. V.
  46. SECT. VII. VIII. IX. X.p. 95
  47. I haue added to the Authors Reply, but without his knowledge, the…p. 113

Other works by William Ames

→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.