Primary Source

The Successive Visibility of the Church

Richard Baxter 1660
Baxter's defense of Protestant church visibility and succession, arguing Protestants represent the true church against Catholic and sectarian objections.

EEBO-TCP A27045 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 12395122; STC/Wing Wing B1418; ESTC R17445

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 14, in the spelling of this edition.

p. 14Readers,

WEre not the Iudgements of God so dreadfull, and infatuation so lamentable in matters of everlasting consequence, and sin so odious, and the calamities of the Church, the dishonour of God, and the Damnation of Souls such deplorable things, as tolerate not a laughter in the standers by, it would seem one of the most ridiculous things in the World, that a man of seeming wisdom should be a Papist; and that so many Princes, and learned men, with the vulgar multitude, should be able so far to renounce or intoxicate their Reason while they are awake: And a Papist would be described, to be one that sets up his understanding to be the laughingstock of the sober rational World. There are abundance of Controversies among Physitians that concern mens lives; and yet I have heard of none so vain, as to step forth and challenge the Authority of being the universal Decider of them, or to charge God with solly or oversight, if he have not appointed some such universal Iudge in the World, to end all Controversies in matters of such weight. But if in Physick's, Law, or any p. 15of the Sciences, the Controversies should be never so many or so great, if yet you could resolve them into sense it self, and bring all to the judgement of mens eyes, and ears, and taste, and feeling, who would not laugh or hiss at him that would still make them the matters of serious doubts?

The Papists finding that man is 〈…〉perfect, and knoweth but in part, and 〈…〉 the Scripture there are some things are hard to be understood, and that Earth hath not so much Light as Heaven, imagine that hereby they have a fair advantage to plead for an universal terrestrial Iudge, and to reproach God, if he have appointed none such, and next to plead that their Pope or his approved Councils must needs have this Authority. And when they come to the Decision, they are not ashamed to see after so many hundred years pretentions, that the World is but basfled with the empty name of a Judge of Controversies, and that Difficulties are no less Difficulties still, and Controversies are nowhere so voluminous as with them. But this is a small matter with them. Their Iudge s◊◊ms much wiser when he is silent, then when he speaks. When he comes to a Decision, and formeth up thereby the Hodge-podge of Popery, they seem not to smile at, nor be ashamed p. 16of the Picture which they have drawn, which is, of an Harlot shewing her nakedness, and committing her lewdness in the open Assemblies, in the sight of the Sún. They openly proclaim their shame against the light of all the acknowledged Principles in the World, their own or others, and in opposition to all, or almost all that is commendable among men. The charge seems high, but (in a few words) take the proof.

p. 161. They confess the Scripture to be the Word of God: and yet when we would appeal to that as the Rule of Faith and Life, or as a divine Revelation, in our Disputes, they fly off, and tell us of its obscurity, and the necessity of a Iudge. If they meet with a Hoc est corpus meum, they seem for a while to be zealous for the Scripture: But tell them that Paul in 1 Cor. 11.26, 27, 28. doth call it Bread after the Consecration, no less than three times in the three next Verses, and then Scripture is non-sense to them till the Pope make sense of it. It is one of their principal labours against us, to argue against the Scriptures sufficiency to this use. By no means can we prevail with them to stand to the Decision of the Scripture.

2. They excessively cry up the Church, and appeal to its Decision: and therefore we might p. 17hope, that here if anywhere, we might have some hold of them. But when it comes to the Point, they not only disown the judgement of the Church, but impudently call Christ's Spouse a Strumpet, and cut off (in their uncharitable imagination) two or three parts of the universal Church as Hereticks or Schismaticks. The judgement of the Churches in Armenia, Ethiopia, Egypt, Syria, the Greeks, and many more besides the Reformed Churches in the West, is against their Popes universal Vicarship or Soveraignty, and many of their Errours that depend thereon: And yet their judgement is not regarded by this Faction. And if a third or fourth part (such as it is) of the Universal Church, may cry up themselves as the Church to be appealed to, and condemn the far greater part, why may not a tenth or a twentieth part do the like? Why may not the Donatists, the Novatians, or the Greeks (much more) do so as well as Papists?

3. They cry up Tradition. And when we ask them, How we shall know it, and where it is to be found, they tell us, principally in the profession and practice of the present Church. And yet when two or three parts of the universal Church profess that Tradition is against the Papal▪ Monarchy, and other Points p. 18depending on it, they cast Tradition behind their backs.

p. 184. They cry up the Fathers: and when we bring their judgements against the substance of Popery, they sometime vilifie or accuse them as erroneous, and sometime tell us, that Fathers as well as Scripture must be no otherwise understood, than their Church expoundeth them.

5. They plead for an appeal to Councils; and (though we easily prove that none of them were universal, yet such as they were) they call them all Reprobate, which were not approved by their Pope, let the number of Bishops there be never so great. And those that were approved, if they speak against them, they reject also, either with lying shifts denying the approbation, or saying, the acts are not de fide, or not conciliariter facta, or the sense must be given by their present Church, or one such contemptible shift or other.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. The Preface.p. 1
  2. Letterp. 14
  3. Postscript.p. 25
  4. Mr. Iohnsons first PAPER.p. 1
  5. The Answer to the first PAPER.p. 7
  6. Letterp. 27
  7. To your first Exception.p. 27
  8. To your second Exception.p. 27
  9. To your third Exception.p. 28
  10. To your fourth Exception.p. 28
  11. To the Proof of my Major. Syll. 2.p. 31
  12. To my Minor.p. 31
  13. To my third Syllogism.p. 33
  14. To Mr. T. L. (who called me to this work.)p. 68
  15. The Reply to Mr. Johnsons second PAPER.p. 77
  16. Qu. Whether the Church, of which the Protestants are Members, have been Visible ever…p. 197
  17. Addenda Miscellanea.p. 288
  18. Whether Hereticks are in the Church.p. 292
  19. The Answer.p. 293
  20. Introductionp. 310
  21. Queries of R. B. on these definitions, with Mr. Iohnsons Answer, and my Reply.p. 311
  22. Appendix.p. 355

Other works by Richard Baxter

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.