Primary Source

Against the Revolt to a Foreign Jurisdiction

Richard Baxter 1691
Baxter's political treatise opposing English submission to foreign papal jurisdiction, defending national sovereignty and Protestant ecclesiastical independence.

EEBO-TCP A26858 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 12619551; STC/Wing Wing B1182; ESTC R22132

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.

p. 1An Historical Prologue, as a Key to understand our English Differences.

§ I. IT is a dreadful Instance of the sottish deceivableness of Mankind, that one of the most happy Kingdoms on Earth, should be almost consumed by their own hands, in Divisions infamous through the World, and that to this very day the Cause and Matter of them, is not known (except by the contrivers, among our selves) by such who madly continue the Divisions. Nor is it known who is in the fault, but they strive on, accusing one another. And it's one of the saddest notices in this World, that studious Learned Pastors that are grown old in Studies, and profess all to be devoted to Truth and Love, are so far from having skill and will to heal us, that they are the men that cause the wound, and keep ◊t open, and are greater hinderers of our Concord and Peace, than Princes, Lords, or any Seculars: And what one judgeth the certain Cause of the Worlds Divisions, another as confidently judgeth the only way to heal them: And both sides confess while they lay it on each other, that it is the Clergy that are the deadliest Enemies of Peace.

§ II. It is not the noise of Drums and Trumpets, which tells an Army the causes of the War: The Masters of the War can chuse their own Trumpeters, and talk loudest of that which they would have divert men from the true cause. Episcopacy, p. 2and Liturgy, and Ceremonies, and Conformity, are the things that make the greatest noise. But Jewel, Bilson, Hooker, &c. differed not about these, nor Sir Edwin Sandys, the Author of Europae Speculum: Nor the English Clergy and Parliaments in Bishop Abbots days, who were of their mind, when the Differences began to rise and threaten us.

§ III. It's certain that the fundamental, universal Quarrel through the World, is between the followers of Cain and Abel, the Serpents and the Womans Seed, or the Servants of Satan and of Christ: For the carnal mind is enmity to God, and neither is nor can be subject to his Law. Selfishness is the sum of wickedness; and Holiness of Moral good. Uniting in one God is possible and safe: But to the selfish there are as many Religions and Ways, as sandy self-interest requireth. Good men will do good, and bad men will do evil, under every Form of Government: Because Great-Good men are so rare, to keep Bad men from doing hurt, is not the smallest use of Laws. Good men of different Opinions can live in Love and Peace. I never knew any called Puritanes, who did not love and honour such Conformists, as Bishop Jewel, A. Bishop Grindal, A. Bishop Abbot, A. Bishop Vsher, Bishop Davenant, and many such; and such as Mr. Bolton, Dr. Sibbs, Dr. Preston, Mr. Whateley, and all such other; yea while they wrote against some of them (as Bishop Morton, Hall, Downame, &c.) But what are the particular Quarrels?

p. 2§ IV. Departing from the only Center and Test of Universal Concord, and devising an Vniversal Humane Soveraignty, hath set the World into p. 3mortal Discord, on pretence of being the only way to Concord. Christ only is the Head, the King, and Law-giver, and Judge of the whole World: The Law of Nature, and sacred inspired Apostolical Scriptures, are his only Universal Law. Pastors by the Word, and Princes by the Sword (conjoyned where it may be) rule under him only in their several Provinces. God made the largeness of the Roman Empire a Receptive Means of the happy propagation of Christianity. Mans nature is prone to selfishness and ambition: By degrees those humours, and the Wisdom of the World, conformed the Episcopal Government to the Civil, and made those Bishops highest, who dwelt in the Cities where the Secular Rulers were highest. The Churches had before used to serve God in Concord, and to Assemble for Consultation when Concord required it. The Emperors therefore exalted the great Bishops, not to Govern alone, but to preside in these Assemblies. The first General Council had been called as a rational means to cure the shameful threatning Discords of the Churches, without the formality of any President, save the Emperor and a temporary Moderator: But three Patriarchs were soon set up, and after made five, and other Bishops in different degrees of grandeur: The great and shaking dangers bred by Religious Factions, were ordered to be decided by Assemblies of Bishops, when changes were made in the Cities of the Empire, the Rule of conforming the Church to the Civil Government bred a competition between Rome and Constantinople, because of the translating of the Imperial Seat. They grew higher and higher; and whenever any Emperor p. 4of Constantinople fell out with his own Patriarch, he either put him out, or favoured the preheminence of the Bishop of Rome to curb him: But usually his own Bishop being at his command, he favoured his Interest against the Roman: And it being the Law of their Councils called General, that the five Patriarchs must be there, by themselves, or their Delegates, and the Emperors calling the Councils (upon great occasions) they called them in some Eastern City for the most part, and the main Body of the Councils were the Greek Bishops, very few of the Western being there, nor the Pope himself, nor at C. P. Conc. 1. so much as any Legate.

p. 4When the Patriarch of Alexandria, who was the third, fell out with him of Constantinople, he would extol the Roman Preheminence to strengthen himself: And when the East had Arian persecuting Emperors and Bishops, the Orthodox would fly for countenance to the Orthodox Emperor and Bishop in the West: But usually the other four Patriarchs in Councils concurred, and the Roman Clergy were a small part of their Councils.

But these Councils dolefully disagreeing, became a Church Militant, and on pretence of agreeing, the Churches tore them all to pieces, and all upon two occasions: 1. WHO SHOULD BE GREATEST, or please the greatest for worldly Interest? 2. WHO SHOULD PASS FOR ORTHODOX, when after the Arian and Macedonian Heresies, much of the strife was about ambiguous words: Till at last the Division of the Churches, the Degeneracy of the Clergy, the Badness of Emperors, and the Rebellion of Generals, p. 5and Mutinies of Souldiers, delivered up the Empire to the Infidels. And the Bishop of Rome became the Chief Rebel, and set up the French in the Western Empire, against his Lawful Prince, and furthered the Division of the Empire to its Ruine. But this Division occasioned an Universal Claim.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. To the Reverend and deservedly Honoured Dr. JOHN TILLOTSON Dean of St. Paul's Church.
  2. TO THE READER.
  3. An Historical Prologue, as a Key to understand our English Differences.p. 1
  4. Chap. I. The Protestant Church of England is against all Humane…p. 41
  5. Chap. II. The whole Kingdom and Church is sworn against all Forreign…p. 58
  6. Chap. III. What Endeavours have been used by the more Moderate…p. 64
  7. Chap. IV. Of the Papists Endeavours in the time of King Charles the…p. 75
  8. A Declaration of the Dutchess of York, translated out of Maimbourg's…p. 81
  9. Postscript.p. 86
  10. Chap. V. The foreign Leaders of the English Conciliaters, who are for…p. 87
  11. Chap. VI. Grotius's Judgment in his own Words.p. 93
  12. Chap. VII. Of the several sorts of Conciliators or Peace-makers about…p. 100
  13. Chap. VIII. The Doctrine of Archbishop Bromhall [in defence of…p. 103
  14. Chap. IX. The Judgment of Archbishop Laud, as delivered by Dr.…p. 106
  15. Archbishop Laud's own words as laid down in his Book defended by Dr.…p. 113
  16. Chap. X. Dr. Peter Heylin's own Judgment.p. 114
  17. Chap. XI. The Judgment of Mr. Herbert Thorndike, a late Eminent…p. 119
  18. Chap. XII. The Judgment of Dr. Sparrow Bishop of Norwich, and divers…p. 127
  19. Chap. XIII. Dr. Parker's Judgment (since Bishop of Oxford.)p. 130
  20. Chap. XIV. Dr. Saywell's Arguments for a Foreign Jurisdiction…p. 131
  21. The True Sum.p. 176
  22. Chap. XV. The first Letter to Bishop Peter Guning, upon his sending…p. 177
  23. Chap. XVI. The Second Letter to Bishop Guning, after our first…p. 185
  24. Chap. XVII. The Third Letter to Bishop Guning.p. 207
  25. Chap. XVIII. The Fourth Letter to Bishop Guning.p. 232
  26. Chap. XIX. Mr. Henry Dodwell's Leviathan further Anatomized.p. 233
  27. Chap. XX. Dr. Thomas Pierce now Dean of Salisbury's Judgment (and Dr.…p. 312
  28. Chap. XXI. That this New sort of Prelatists who were for a Coalition…p. 315
  29. Chap. XXII. How they have been stopt, and in • hat Danger we are yet…p. 332
  30. Chap. XXIII. Postscript to the Reverend Dr. Beveridge.p. 337
  31. The Second Part. The Stating of the Controversie, and full Confutation of the Pretences…
  32. Chap. I. The true State and just Resolutions of the Controversies…p. 339
  33. Chap. II. Why Parliaments and Archbishop Abbot and the Church of…p. 423
  34. Chap. III. They are deceived who are for the foresaid Papal or…p. 434
  35. Chap. 4. The Deceits that are Pleaded for an Vniversal Humane…p. 443
  36. Chap. V. What a Foreign Jurisdiction by Councils or the College of…p. 455
  37. Chap. VI. The Grand Consequential Case, Whether it be lawful for the…p. 462
  38. Chap. VII. Of the second Part of the Design; to bring the Papists…p. 472
  39. Chap. VIII Why the Papists abating their Innovations of the last Four…p. 478
  40. Chap. IX. Whether the Instance of the Apostles Church Government…p. 489
  41. Chap. X. Some Questions about General Councils, to be resolved before…p. 500
  42. Chap. XI. A Breviate of the Papists Faith and Church Doctrine, both…p. 515
  43. Chap. XII. A humble Expostulation to the zealous Antipapists…p. 520
  44. Chap. XIII. What is the Duty of all other Christians towards the…p. 532
  45. Postscript.p. 542

Other works by Richard Baxter

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.