Which Is the True Church?
EEBO-TCP A27069 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 12626085; STC/Wing Wing B1453; ESTC R1003
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.
Question 1. WHAT mean you by the Catholick Church? [Sect. 1.]
W. J. The Catholick Church is all those Visible Assemblies, Congregations or Communities of Christians, who live in unity of true faith, and external Communion with one another, and in dependance of their lawful Pastors.
R. B. Qu. 1. Whether you exclude not all those converted among Infidels, that never had external communion, nor were members of any particular visible Church, of which you make the Catholick to to be constituted.
W. J. It is sufficient that such be subject to the supreme Pastors in voto, or quantum in se est, resolved to be of that particular Church actually, which shall or may be designed for them by that Pastor, to be included in my definition.
R. B. You see then that your definitions signifie nothing: No man knoweth your meaning by them.
W. J. You shall presently see that your Exceptions signifie less than nothing.
R. B. 1. You make the Catholick Church to consist only of visible Assemblies; and after you allow such to be members of the Church, that are no visible Assemblies.
W. J. I make those converted Infidels visible Assemblies, as my definition speaks, though not actual members of any particular visible Church. For though every particular visible Church be an assembly of Christians, yet every assembly of Christians is not a particular visible Church. I do not therefore allow such to be of the Church, who are no visible assemblies, as you misconceive.
R. B. 1. Would any man have understood that by [Visible Assemblies] the man had not meant only [Churches] but also Families, Schools, Cities, &c? 2. Doth he not here expresly deny all those persons to be of the Church, who are not members of some other visible assemblies. And if a man be a Pilgrim, a Hermite, or if one or many be cast upon an uninhabited coast, and if any are members of no visible assembly, as Merchants, Embassadors to Infidels, &c. when will he prove that this unchristeneth or unchurcheth them?
R. B. 2. You now mention subjection to the supreme Pastor, as sufficient, which in your description or definition you did not.
p. 1W. J. Am I obliged to mention all things in my definition, which I express after in answering your Exceptions.
Ans. All that belongs to a notifying definition.
p. 2R. B. 3. If to be only in Voto resolved to be of a particular Church, will serve; then inexistence is not necessary: To be only in Voto of the Catholick Church, proveth no man a member of it, because it is terminus diminuens, but the contrary. Seeing then by your own confession, inexistence in a particular Church, is not of necessity to inexistence in the Catholick Church, why do you not only mention it in your definition, but confine the Church to it?
W. J. I make them actually inexistent in some visible assembly, according to my definition, and in Voto only in a particular Church: Now every particular family or neighbourhood, nay two or three gathered in prayer, is an actual assembly.
R. B. Strange Doctrine! so it is of necessity to our Christianity and Salvation, that we be members of a Christian City or Village, or Fair or Market, or some Meeting! And so all Christians that live solitarily in Wildernesses, or among Turks or Heathens, are all unchristened and damned.
W. J. St. Hierome saith, Ecclesia est plebs unita Episcopo.—In this consists your fallacy, that you esteem none to be actually members of the Universal Church, unless they be actual members of some particular Church, which I deny.
R. B. I thought verily it had been I that was denying it, all this while. This is dispu◊ing in the dark. Will you say that you meant in Voto? who can understand you then, when you say, They must be of visible assemblies, and mean that they need not be of any, but wish they were, or purpose to be so.
W. J. It is sufficient if they be actually of some assembly or congregation of Christians, though it be no particular Church.
R. B. 1. Here is a new Exposition of Solomon's Vae soli, Wo to him that is alone; for he is unchristened by it, or unchurched. O poor Anchorites, Hermites, that are alone, and shipwrackt Christians, &c. 2. Here is a new found priviledg of having company, if in a Tavern or Alehouse; and of being married and in a family; such may be Christians, when the solitary cannot. Who would have thought that the Papists had held this!
p. 2But you say nothing to the case of them that are converted to Christ by a solitary Preacher, that never tells him of a supreme Pastor, as the English and Dutch convert many Indians: Can they be subject to him that they hear not of?
W. J. Whether he be named or no, the Church must be supposed to be sufficiently explicated to them, as having some prudent manner of Government; so that they must be instructed to render obedience to such Governours as Christ instituted in his Church, which is virtually to a chief Pastor.
R. B. 1. So they that take the Pope for Antichrist, may virtually be Papists: Be content with that virtue. 2. But I think that even that general belief of Pastoral Government is necessary ad bene esse, rather than ad esse of a Christian.
R. B. 1. I note by the way to be hereafter remembred, his description of a particular Church as given by Hierome, that it is Plebs unita Episcopo; and Cyprian saith, Ubi [Sect. 2:] Episcopus ibi Ecclesia. And Ignatius, To every church there is one Altar, and one Bishop, with the Prosbyters and Deacons. But by this Rule they make those that are now called Parish-Churches, to be no Churches, but only parts of a particular Church.
2. Note, that in his Definition he maketh living in external communion essential to those Congregations or Communities of Christians who make up the Catholick Church; but tells us not whether it must be a Civil or only a Religious Communion; or what Religious Communions besides unity of faith and dependance on Pastors it must be: If by those words, pag. 3. every particular family or neighbourhood, he express that external communion, then if their Pastors never give them Gods Word, Sacraments, or Prayer, it may serve.
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadContents
- The Preface to the Lovers of Truth.
- Mr. Iohnson's (alias Terret's) Explication of seven Terms of our Questions examined, and…p. 1
- CHAP. I.p. 1
- CHAP. II. Of their sense of the Word HERESIE.p. 22
- CHAP. III. What mean you by the Word POPE?p. 30
- CHAP. IV. What mean you by the word Bishop?p. 35
- CHAP. V. Q. What mean you by TRADITION?p. 41
- CHAP. VI. What mean you by a GENERAL COUNCIL?p. 45
- CHAP. VII. What mean you by [SCHISME.]p. 57
- PART II.p. 62
- THE PREFACE.p. 62
- CHAP. I. The Confutation of W. J's Reply.p. 66
- The Answer to W. J's second-Chapter.p. 75
- The Answer to W. J's third Chapter.p. 83
- W. J's Fourth Chapter answered.p. 95
- An Answer to W. J's fifth Chapter.p. 99
- An Answer to W. J's. Sixth CHAPTER.p. 121
- An Answer to W. J's Seventh CHAPTER.p. 125
- An Answer to W. J's second Part of his Reply.p. 135
- The Third Part:p. 143
Other works by Richard Baxter
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.