Primary Source

Baxter's Vindication of the Church of England

Richard Baxter 1682
Baxter vindicates the Church of England's rites, ceremonies, and discipline through faithful extracts from his writings without alteration or misrepresentation.

EEBO-TCP A27066 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 12885390; STC/Wing Wing B1449; ESTC R1229

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

Mr. BAXTER's EPISTLE TO THE Non-Conformists, Being a just and true Abstract of his Defence of the Principles of Love.

BRETHREN,

IT grieves me to the heart that neither Party, [Pag. 18.] Conformable or Non-conformable, is more sensible of the sin and danger of our distance (though I know that in both Parties there are many wise and holy persons, who, I suppose, lament it more than I do.) It layeth my soul in daily lamentations to see how we run further from each other, to the apparent danger of the Protestant Cause, and of the Kingdoms welfare, and of all the hopes of our Posterity.

p. 2[Part 1. pag. 49.] Our narrow Judgment draws many to think that it is the Interest of Religion now in England to have the Parish-Churches brought low in reputation, and deserted, and God's publick worship which they would have all religious People use, to be onely that of tolerated, or more private Churches, by which they little know what they wish against the Interest of the Christian and Protestant Religion in this Land, and what hurt they would do, if in this they had their wills.

[Par. 1. pag. 36.] The Interest of the Christian Protestant Religion must be kept up, by keeping up as much Truth, Piety, and Reputation, as may be, in the Parish-Churches.

[Part. 1. pag. 56. The publick to be preferred before the private: and come to the beginning of Common-Prayer.] I am very glad that the pious Lectures of Mr. Hildersham, Mr. Rogers, and such other old Non-conformists, are in so good esteem among good people, where they will read them urgeing the people, not onely against Separation, but to come to the very beginning of the publick Worship, and preferring it before their private duties. And I need not tell those that have read the Writings of the good old Non-conformists, [Part. 2. p. 176. Common-prayer preferred before all private duties.] Ames, Parker, Bains, Fox, Dearing, Greenham, &c. that these did some of them read the Common Prayer, and most of them judged it lawful to join in it, or else Mr. Hildersham, p. 3Rogers, &c. would not write so earnestly to men to come to the beginning, and prefer it before all private duties.

p. 3When I think what learned, holy, [part. 1. p. 97. The heinousness of Separation, in consideration of those excellent persons that they separated from 1. the old Conformists▪ 2. the present Conformists.] incomparable men, abundance of the old Conformists were, my heart riseth against the thoughts of separating from them; If I had come to their Churches when they read the Common-prayer and administred the Sacrament, could I have departed and said, It is not lawful for a Christian here to communicate with you. What! Such men as Mr. Bolton, Mr. Whateley, Mr. Fenner, Mr. Crook, Mr. Dent, Mr. Dike, Mr. Stock, Mr. Smith, Dr. Preston, Dr. Sibbs, Dr. Taylor, and abundance other such; yea, such as Bishop Jewell, Bishop Grindall Bishop Hall, Bishop Potter, Bishop Davenant, Bishop Carleton, &c. yea, and the Martyrs too, as Cranmer, Ridley, Hooper, Farrar, Bradford, Philpot, Sanders, [Part. 1. p. 12.13.] &c. I think not my self worthy to be compared with Mr. Bolton, Whateley, Fenner, Preston, Sibbs, White, Field, Usher, Jewell, and abundance other old Conformists; and you might forgive me, if I tell you again, that if they were all alive, and used now the same Liturgy and Ceremonies as they did then, I could not find in my heart to think their communion in Prayer and Sacrament unlawful, nor to censure that man p. 4as injurious to the Church, who should write to persuade others not to separate from them on that supposition, I am sure the Assembly of Divines that sate heretofore at Westminster, were so conformable when they went thither, that I never heard of five Non-conformists among them, except the five dissenting Brethren; their Judgment was (as Mr. Sprints) that Conformity was lawful in case of necessity, rather than to be deprived of Liberty to preach the Gospel.

[Part. 1. p. 10, 11, 12.] And as for the present Conformists, I know those of them, whom I think as godly and humble Ministers [N.B.] as most of the Non-conformists, whom I know— and as my acquaintance increaseth I know more and more; — And I tell you again, that I believe there are many hundred godly Ministers in the Parish Churches of England, and that their Churches are true Churches. [Part. 1. p. 40. Mr. Baxter dares not go against his Conscience in not taking the Sacrament at his Parish Church.] And for my part I forbore communion with the Parish Churches in the Sacrament a long time, yet at last I saw that the reasons seemed to me to cease, and I durst not go against my Conscience, for I knew not what.

p. 4[Part. 1. p. 16, 68, 69.] But O that you would yet consider how much defect of love and patience there is in you as well as others, How easily can we aggravate p. 5the faults of others, and how hardly can we aggravate or see our own! The defects of the Liturgy, and the faults of those by whom we suffer, are easily heightned even beyond desert, but when many of us vend untruths and slanders against our Brethren about the Land, who aggravates this, or repents of it? But above all I entreat the dividing Brethren, if they can so long lay by their partiality, to judge by this of the reasons of their separation from those Churches private or parochial, that they differ from in tolerable things. You think it a sin to communicate in a Church where the Liturgy is used, and where Discipline is not so strictly exercised against some Offenders, as you and I desire. But publick multiplied untruths in mens mouths, do never make you scruple their communion. I intreat you do but study an answer to one that would separate from you all upon such grounds as these. First for the Sin, [The Separatists that are so scrupulous about Church communion, make no conscience of greater sins.] consider of these Texts, Exod. 23.1. Thou shalt not raise a false report, &c. Eph. 4.31. Let evil speaking be put away from you. J◊mes 4.11. Speak not evil one of another, &c. Tit. 3.1, 2. Prov. 25.23. Pet. 1.2, 1. &c. Have you more or plainer Texts of Scripture against the Common-prayer than these are against Slandering, &c. p. 6Now suppose one should say that a People of such sin as this, should not be communicated with, what answer will you give to this, which will not confute your own objections against communion with many Parish-Churches in this Land. God hates every disorder in extemporate Prayer, [Part 1. p. 84.] and yet he more hates that censoriousness and curiosity which would draw men to forsake the substantials of Worship or Christian love and communion on that pretence. If Christians should plead Gods jealousie about his Worship, as censoriously against their own prayers, as they do against other mens, and Churches in this case, they would turn prayer into the fuel of despair and torment.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. TO THE READER.
  2. Mr. BAXTER's EPISTLE TO THE Non-Conformists, Being a just and true Abstract of his…p. 3
  3. Mr. Baxters Prayer.p. 16
  4. Mr. BAXTER's VINDICATION OF THE CHURCH of ENGLAND In her Rites, and Ceremonies…p. 19
  5. 1. Standing up at the Creed and the Antiphones.p. 19
  6. 2. Episcopal Confirmation.p. 20
  7. 3. Church-Musick by Organs, or such like Instruments.p. 21
  8. 4. Godfathers and Godmothers.p. 22
  9. 5. The Antiphones, or the Peoples bearing a Part with the Minister in…p. 23
  10. 6. Bowing at the Name of JESUS.p. 24
  11. 7. It is certain from God's Word, that the Child so Baptized, dying…p. 24
  12. 8. Kneeling at the Sacrament.p. 26
  13. 9. Episcopacy is Apostolical, and of Divine Institution.p. 26
  14. 10. The Oath of Priests and Deacons for Canonical Obedience to their…p. 28
  15. 11. The Surplice.p. 29
  16. 12. The Cross at Baptism.p. 30
  17. 13. Reordination.p. 31
  18. 14. Renouncing the Covenant.p. 31
  19. 15. The defects and faults of the Liturgy.p. 32
  20. 16. The Errour of demanding a Scripture-text, or rule, for Ceremonies…p. 32
  21. 17. The Church of England not guilty of any kind of False-worship.p. 35
  22. 18. A general Vindication of the Liturgy and Ceremonies.p. 35
  23. 19. The soundness of the Doctrine of the Church of England.p. 36

Other works by Richard Baxter

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.