Primary Source

The Certainty of Christianity Without Popery

Richard Baxter 1672
Baxter defends Catholic-Protestant faith as more certain than papal Catholicism, equipping believers against papist challenges and demonic temptations to their salvation.

EEBO-TCP A26887 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 11892559; STC/Wing Wing B1213; ESTC R5291

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

This following Paper was sent me from an unknown person in a Letter, which had these words.

SIR,

THe business of this Paper is to beg a favour of you, of a publick nature—an Answer to the inclosed Paper, which was sent me from a friend of mine who is a Papist, with an earnest desire that I would procure it to be answered. The resolution of which would be of use to us both in the things in Controversie between us—I cannot but wonder at the confidence of this deluded people, who though they are so often again and again Learnedly and Religiously writ against, yet they can with as great confidence and boasting challenge and dare the Ministers of Truth to encounter and answer them, in such kind of Papers, as if their tenets had never been refuted at all: And though I have referred my friend to your Books, that will not satisfie; but he doth as it were Goliah-like bid defiance to our Ministers, telling me that if any be so hardy, let them answer his Papers.

The Paper followeth.

ALL who call themselves Christians are agreed in this principle.

That every Revelation of God, or whatsoever God says is most certainly true in the sense wherein he intends it.

And this is a matter of right on Gods part, to have this granted.

But all Christians do not agree; and it is the sole point wherein Christians differ:

Whether God hath Revealed or said what is proposed to us as his Revelation: Or as the sense intended by him by that which they all agree to be his Revelation.

And this is purely matter of Fact, (viz.) 1. Whether several Books affirmed and proposed to us as the Revelations of God be truly so. For Instance, the Old Testament affirmed by some to be, and proposed as the Revelations of God, are denied by the Valentinians and the Manichees. The Gospels of St. Mark, St. Luke, St. Iohn, and all St. Pauls Epistles, proposed by some Christians as the Revelations of God, are denied by others, namely by the Ebionites. So likewise several parties agreeing several Books to be Scripture and the Revelation of God, do notwithstanding differ touching the Copies, and touching the Translations; Some affirming one Copie to be true, and one Translation to be true, whilst others expresly say, that Copy is false, and that Translation false. And Lastly, several parties agreeing the Books to be Scripture, the Copies true, and the Translations true, and to be the Revelation of God, do nevertheless differ touching the sense, each party delivering a particular sense of such a Text, and proposing such sense, as the sense, and the only sense Revealed by God, to be intended by God by that Text, and each proposed sense being contrary to the other.

It is clear in any difference arising touching matter of Fact, there can only be one party which can have the true Faith touching that matter, for it is impossible one thing can be a Revelation of God and no Revelation of God: That one Copy, or one Translation, or one Sense can be true and not true.

It is now enquired whether Christ hath setled any principle or medium in the world: And what principle or medium it is which Christ hath setled in the world, for the determining of matters of Fact of this nature. By which Unity in Faith may be conserved, and Christians may with certainty know what is a true Revelation of God, which a true Copy of such true Revelation, which a true Translation of such true Copy, and what the true sense thereof, that Christians may not be carried about with every wind of Doctrine.

The solution of this is desired to be by fixed and solid principles, and not by tedious discourses; for the Nature of the thing requires that there be a firm Principle setled among Men, for the final determining of matters of Fact.

Of the Quality of this Question.

SIR,

§. 1. YOU may see by this Paper, with the ordinary disputing of this sort of men, that it is not without cause that we have suspected the hand of the Papists in many of the defences of the Infidel cause, and questionings of the foundations of the Christian faith, which this age is troubled with. They have so long plaid the Infidels in jeast, till they have made such a swarm of serious Infidels, as will prove neither the honour nor comfort of such seducers in the end. I know that this Paper it self hath a more modest aspect, but the p. 2tendencie of it is the same as of the rest. But I hope God will turn all their endeavours to our advantage, and teach Christians bet-better to consider the foundations of their faith; that they may not only be able to defend it against an Infidel or Papist; but, which is of more universal and frequent necessity, to defend it against the inward suggestions of Satan, the enemy of Christ and us.

§. 2. Therefore I think it most profitable to answer this Question in such a manner as shall tend not only to silence the Caviller, but as may best satisfie such as doubt, and stablish men about the cause it self; and therefore to be larger, than this Imposer desireth, that I may be plain.

§. 3. The fraud which this Quaerist is guilty of is manifold, and manifest to any discerning Reader. 1. In the choice of his subject: For he knoweth (for it's easily known,) that it hath not pleased God to make the mysteries of our faith so evident, as things sensible are; and that the difficulties which are in and about the Christian cause, are such, as give advantage to carnal unbelievers, to find many words to say against it; and that maketh it the hardest work of Preachers, to convince unbelievers: or else the Gospel had been received by more than the sixth p. 3part of the world, before this day. Now these juglers would lay all the difficulties which are in the Christian cause as such, upon the Reformers cause alone, as if all this were nothing to them, but the cause of Popery were wholly free from them; or at least, they could answer such questions better than we can do. And so when such a fellow as Hobbs, or Benedictus Spinosa in his Tractatus Theologico-politicus, shall stretch their wits to disgrace the Scripture and the Christian cause, all this shall seem only to fall upon the Protestants; whereas if we could not better defend Christianity than the present principles of Popery enable them to do, we must confess that the Infidel were far hardlier answered than any Sectary that we have to deal with.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. TO THE Protestant Reader.
  2. This following Paper was sent me from an unknown person in a Letter, which had these…
  3. The Paper followeth.
  4. CHAP. II.p. 5
  5. CHAP. III.p. 13
  6. CHAP. IV.p. 22
  7. CHAP. VI.p. 30
  8. CHAP. VII.p. 43
  9. CHAP. VIII.p. 45
  10. CHAP. IX.p. 48
  11. CHAP. XI.p. 54
  12. CHAP. XII.p. 57
  13. CHAP. XIII.p. 60
  14. CHAP. I.p. 97
  15. CHAP. II.p. 100
  16. CHAP. III.p. 103
  17. CHAP. IV.p. 108

Other works by Richard Baxter

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.