Primary Source

Baxter's Apology

Richard Baxter 1654
Baxter responds to theological objections from Blake, Kendall, and others, defending his positions on doctrine and ecclesiastical matters with detailed refutations.

EEBO-TCP A26864 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 12169815; STC/Wing Wing B1188; ESTC R31573

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.

MY Reverend and dearly beloved Brother, I remember that when I met you last at Shrewsbury, you told me that you had sent to the Presse a Treatise of the Covenants, and desired me not to be offended, if you published in it some things against my Judgement: Your Treatise is since come to my hands, and upon a brief perusall of some part of it, I am bold to let you know this much of my thoughts, 1. That I very much value and honour your Learned Labours, and had I been Mr Vines or Mr Fisher, I might rather have given (in some respects) a higher commendations of your Book: And especially I love it for its sound discoveries of the Vanity of the Antinomians. 2. So farre am I from being offended at your Writing against my Writings, that (as I have oft said concerning Mr Owen, since I saw his Book against me, even so do I by you) I never honoured you so much (though much) nor loved you so dearly (though dearly) before as since; for I see more of your worth then I saw before. For where I erre, why should I be offended with any brother for loving Gods Truth and mens souls, above my Errours, or any seeming Reputation of mine that may be ingaged in them, and for seeking to cure the hurt that I have done? God forbid that I should seek to maintain a Reputation obtained by, or held in an opposition to the Truth. I take all my Errors in Theology (even in the highest revealed points, participaliter) to be my sinnes; but especially my divulged Errors: And I take him for my best friend, that is the greatest enemy to my sins. And where I erre not, I have little cause for my own sake to be offended at your opposition. For as you are pleased to honour me too highly both in your Epithetes and tender dealing, yea in being at so much pains with any thing of mine, and in stooping to a publick opposition of that which you might have thought more worthy of your contempt, so I know you did it in a zeal for God and Truth, and you thought all was Error that you opposed; so that in the general we fight under one Master, and for one Cause, and against one Enemy: You are for Christ, 1. For Truth and against Errors, so farre as you know it, and so am I. I know you wrote not against Me, but against my Errors, reall or supposed. And truly, though I would not be shamelesse or impenitent, nor go so far as Seneca, to say we should not object a common fault to singular persons (Vid. Cor. de Irâ, l. 3. c. 26. p. (mihi) 452. no more then to reproach a Blackmore with his colour; yet I p. 2see so much by the most Learned and Judicious, to assure me that humanum est errare, and that we know but in part, that I take it for no more dishonour, to have the world know that I erre, then for them to know that I am one of their Brethren, a son of Adam, and not yet arrived at that blessed state where that which is childish shall cease, and all that is imperfect shall be done away. Only if my Errors be greater then ordinary, I must be humbled more then ordinary, as knowing that my sin is the cause that I have no greater illumination of the Spirit. I have truly published to the world my indignation against the proud indignation of those men, that account him their enemy that shall publiquely contradict them.

p. 22. Yet must I needs tell you, that in the points which you contradict, I finde no great alteration upon my understanding by your Writings; whether it be from the want of evidence of truth in your Confutation, or through the dulnesse of my Apprehension, I hope I shall better be able to judge, when I have heard from you next. I think I may safely say, It is not from an unwillingness to know the Truth. And one further difference there is in our Judgements: For my Judgement is, that it is not so convenient nor safe a way to publish suddenly a reply to your opposition, as to tell you my thoughts privately (seeing we live so near) and to bring the Points in difference by friendly collations to as narrow a compass as we can, and make as clear a discovery of each others meanings as may be; and then by joynt consent to tell the world our several Judgements, and our Reasons, as lovers of the Truth and of each other; that so others may have the benefit of our friendly Collations and Enquiries; and may be thereby advantaged for the more facile discovery of the Truth. Truly I would have all such Controversies so handled, that all the vain altercations might lye in the dust in our studies, and that which is published might be in one Volume friendly subscribed by both parties. In this I perceive by your practise, your Judgement differs from mine; and that you rather judge it fittest to speak first by the Presse, that the world may hear us. I crave your acceptance of these Papers, rather in this private way, and that you will signifie to me in what way I shall expect your return, wherein I think it fitter you please your self then me. I shall faithfully give you an account of the effect of your Arguments on my weak understanding; but not in the order as they lye in your Book, but I will begin with those Points which I judge to be of greatest moment.

IT is also true that faith accepts Christ as a Lord, as well as a Saviour: But it is the Acceptation of him as a Saviour, not as a Lord, that Justifies: Christ Rules his People as a King, Teacheth them as a Prophet, but makes Atonement for them only as a Priest, by giving himself in Sacrifice, his blood for Remission of sins: These must be distinguished, but not divided: Faith hath an eye at all, the blood of Christ, the command of Christ, the doctrine of Christ, but as it lies and fastens on his blood, so it Justifies. He is set out a propitiation through faith in his blood, Rom. 3.24. not through faith in his command. It is the blood of Christ that cleanseth all sin, and not the Soveraignty of Christ. These confusions of the distinct parts of Christs Mediatorship, and the speciall offices of faith may not be suffered. Scripture assignes each its particular place and work; Soveraignty doth not cleanse us; nor doth blood command us: Faith in his blood, not faith yielding to his Soveraignty doth Justifie us.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. The Preface Apologetical.
  2. The Prologue.p. 1
  3. § 28. Of Evangelical Personal Righteousness. Mr Bl. Pag. 110, &c.p. 41
  4. §. 38. How farre unbelief and impenitency in professed Christians are Violations of the…p. 57
  5. §. 39. Mr Bl. Ch. 32. A Dogmatical faith entitles to Baptism.p. 58
  6. §. 55. Whether Faith and Repentance be Gods Works.p. 108
  7. §. 56. Of the Life Promised, and Death threatned to Adam in the first Law.p. 110
  8. §. 59. Of the Law as made to Christ.p. 115
  9. §. 60. Whether the Sacraments seal the conditional Promise absolutely? or the conclusion…p. 115
  10. Whether the Covenant of Grace require perfection, and accept sincerity.p. 144
  11. Georgius Calixtus, Epitom. Theolog. Moral. pag. 463.p. 155
  12. POSTSCRIPT.

Other works by Richard Baxter

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.