A Third Defence of the Cause of Peace
EEBO-TCP A27046 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 12625933; STC/Wing Wing B1419; ESTC R647
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.
p. 1AN ANSVVER TO MR. HINCKLEY.
SIR,
I Have perused yours, (I think Impartially) and to tell you my Judgment of it, I perceive, is like to offend you more. I find it is natural to men to desire to be thought to be in the right, and to have said well, and done well, be it never so ill. It is some Honour to Truth and Goodness, that the Names and Reputation of them seem desirable to those that cannot endure the things; yea, that the Things are never loathed or opposed formally as such, but for their opposition to somewhat, that is more loved. And it is some help to the depression of Falshood and Sin, that it is ashamed of its own Name, and cannot endure to see its own Face, which hath ever inclined it to break the Glass; though to its greater shame, when every piece will shew that ugliness which was shewed but by the whole before. If nothing else had notified it to us, one might have strongly suspected that you are of that p. 2Tribe, who take themselves to be persecuted when they may not domineer, and when others may but Preach and live without their Consent; by your excessive tenderness and impatience, calling it Poyson, Hornets, and abundance of such smarting angry Names, if a man that is cast out of God's Vineyard as well as his Maintenance among many hundreds more, do but plainly in a private Letter speak for himself, and shew the injustice of your Printed Accusations. O! that you were all but the thousandth part as tender, (I will not say of your Brethrens sufferings) but of the danger of many thousand perishing starved Souls? I shall only tell you this much in general, that I now perceive you are used but for a Temptation to me, to lose my time, by the neglect of better Work. And that you do so notoriously bawk the Truth, and hide Untruth in a heap of Confident Rhetorical Flourishes; that while you are of this temperament, I will not undertake to prove to you that Two and Two are Four.
1. My Beginning was taken from your Ending; where you wrote [You will satisfie your self, as little as you will do others] And what others Mind know you better than your own? And sure that which satisfieth not you, doth you no good as to its proper end, what ever it may do by accident some other way. Yet it seems you forgot that you had written this, and that was warrant enough for all your confident Impertinencies on that occasion. Sandy foundations, light and darkness, Hornets Nests, rushing into the midst of the Pikes, waking Dragons, the golden Fleece, &c. come all in upon this your oversight: And you seem to think that you have acquit your self well.
p. 32. You tell me of bringing the Controversie to an issue by dint of Scripture, whether you sin in Conforming. Is this fairly done, to pretend that to be the Controversie which I never undertook to meddle with? Could you possibly forget, 1. That You were the Plaintiff and Accuser in Print, not content that your Brethren were forbidden to Preach Christ, and that many of them live in great poverty and want? You wrote a Book of reproachful Oratory, with no strength of Argument worthy an Answer, to make them seem the flagitious Causes of their own silence and sufferings: Against which, they (that meddled not with you) had nothing to do but to justifie themselves. 2. That in this Book you vehemently importune me, who never knew you, nor meddled with you, to give the World the Reasons of my Non-conformity. 3. That hereupon the Question that I treated about with you, was, How I may have leave to do it. And whether it be ingenious thus publickly to urge me to that which you know I cannot do. This was all the Controversie I had with you. I tell you again, I would go on my knees to any Bishop in England, to procure but License for my self alone, (much more my Brethren) to Write and Print the Reasons of our Non-conformity, after Nine years Silence, Suffering, and Accusation; that the World and Posterity may but once hear us speak for our selves: And I would be engaged to leave out all such plain expressions as now offend you. But to begin such a Work, when I know I cannot Print it; or to enter a Dispute with you in this rambling way, (whose Books and Letters tell me that you will Syllogize in Aristophanes, or Lucian's p. 4Moods and Figures; and whose Logick will take up no greater room among your Oratorical Diversions, Evasions, Subterfuges, and Flosculi, than a spoonful of Wine in a Gallon of Water, which will leave it Water still. I shall not easily be drawn to this, having lost so much time upon you already, as I have done: Therefore you here bring in your Serpents Head and Tail and Fable, upon a false Supposition of the Subject of our Debates.
p. 4§. 1. Here first, you would have your Book go for Innocent; no wonder: Impenitence is no rarity, among those whose office is to Preach Repentance: And therefore so many of them go without the Fruits of it, Matth. 7. 22, 23. And he that can write against Truth, can defend it by Untruth. 2. You untruly suppose me to undertake the Confutation of your Book. But who hath so little to do, as to shew particularly of each Page and Line of a Bundle of impotent Oratorian Revilings, how little Logick or Truth is in them. 3. You untruly suppose me not to have opened the faultiness of any Page of your Book: Let the Impartial judge. 4. In all, you shew the strange unacquaintedness with your Self, and your Own, which you cannot endure to be told of. …
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadContents
- Preface
- AN ANSVVER TO MR. HINCKLEY.p. 1
- RICHARD BAXTERS second Account to Mr. John Cheney of his Judgment, accused by him of…p. 1
- CHAP. I. PREFATORY.p. 1
- CHAP. II. What the Doctrine is which he accuseth of Atheism, Impiety…p. 4
- CHAP. III. What Mr. Cheyney saith against these things: And 1. Of…p. 18
- CHAP. IV. A Defence against the foresaid Accusations.p. 26
- CHAP. IV. Mr. Chenies Accusations of me about Church-Covenants, and…p. 45
- CHAP. V.p. 74
- There is a Law against Lying, To which we must Conform: OR Truth pleaded for Peace…p. 77
- CHAP. I. PREFATORY. Our Accuser's Advantages.p. 77
- CHAP. II. The Impleaders Truth examined.p. 88
- CHAP. III. His Answer to the first Plea for Peace Examined.p. 116
- CHAP. IV. Of his dealing with the Second Plea for Peace.p. 145
- A REFLECTION on the REFLECTER on a Book against Sacrilegious Desertion of the Sacred…p. 147
- A Note on J. Varney's Book against the Dissenters from the Church of England.p. 150
- Notes on Mr. Le Strange's Casuist uncased.p. 150
- Notes on a Dialogue between the Pope and a Phanatick.p. 152
Other works by Richard Baxter
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.