Primary Source

An Answer to Mr. Dodwell and Dr. Sherlock

Richard Baxter 1682
Baxter refutes universal church supremacy as tyranny and popery, defending Isaac Barrow's treatise against Dodwell and Sherlock's ecclesiastical authority claims.

EEBO-TCP A26860 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 11733763; STC/Wing Wing B1184; ESTC R16768

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

A late Letter from Mr. Dodwell, calling for more Answer, with the Answer to it, written since the rest was Printed, though it be here placed.

Reverend Sir,

I Am now in the Country, and as yet in so unsetled a condition, as obliges me to be a Stranger to new Works. However, by the short view I have when I come into Shops, I find you put me off for a Reply to Mr. Clarksons little Pamphlet concerning Diocesan Jurisdiction: I have got it and perused it, and the design of my writing at present is, to acquaint you with the reason why I think my self unconcerned in it, if that be all I must expect from you in Answer to my yet unanswered Letters. You must excuse me, if I cannot think that Book an Answer, which as it was written before them by your own confession, so neither doth it foresee the accounts given in those Letters, nor provide against them: Whether it do so, let the Reader judge.

But to return to the account intended, why I cannot think my self concerned in this new Pamphlet of Mr. Clarkson's, be pleased to understand, that the excellent Dean of St. Pauls being engaged against you on the same Argument of my Letters, was pleased to put himself to the trouble of perusing my Papers, as they came from the Press, purposely that he might avoid repeating what had been said by me. This being so, you may easily understand how far I am concerned in what is said to him, when it was indeed wholly distinct from mine. Not that I should have been unwilling to serve that great Person, but that I know he is in much better hands already. Mr. Clarkson in this Pamphlet, as he has only mentioned Dr. Stillingfleets name, so he hath confined himself to his Arguments, and hath taken notice of nothing in my Letters not considered by the Doctor. If he will be pleased to engage further, I confess I like his temper better than any I have seen of your late Brethren, except Dr. Owen. Such an Adversary I should desire, as would confine himself to the Cause, without digressing to personal Slanders. There is one mistake in him, which you may be pleased to acquaint him with, and that is his translating 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 thousands more than once, and sometimes where his Argument is grounded on it, that it may appear to be his mistake rather than the Printers. The mistake is small and separable from the main Cause, but withal is very evident. But according to his candour in acknowledging it, so I shall see what candour I may expect from him in the main Cause, if he think fit to engage with me in it.

As to your Answers to my Objections against your Ministry in our Oral Debates, had they been unproved Assertions, I should then have thought them sufficiently answered with Denials. But you know the Assertions are proved in the body of my Book; and till I see my Principles unravelled, and Answers more distinctly applied to the junctures, where the proof may seem to fail, I am not likely to see any reason to change my minde. Till you attempt this, I am content the Reader judg, whether what you have done, or shall hereafter do in the like way, deserve the name of a Confutation. If I must never expect any further satisfaction from you for the Slanders you have raised against me, all the return I intend, is my hearty Prayer to God, to qualifie you for your forgiveness, not only of that sin, but of the many others of your late writings, by your re-union to the Church from which you are fallen, on which account alone I have proved that you can expect forgiveness. I am obliged not only on my own account, but to the Publick, to which you have shewn your self an Enemy on this occasion, to reflect on you; but I desire to leave no monuments against you to Posterity. God may yet have mercy on you, and let you see the mischief you are doing, before it be too late. That he will do so, is the most unfeigned request of him, who, notwithstanding your many and great provocations, will still endeavour to approve himself

Yours, as far as is consistent with his Duty to the Publick, Henry Dodwell.

When you have occasion to write to me, send your Lettrs to be left with Mr. Took

Sir,

I Received not yours of Septemb. 19, 1681. till Octob. 21. through the miscarriage of one that should have delivered it. What you have to say to Mr. Clarkson, write to himself and not to me: As to your call for more Answer to your Books, you shall have more. I had wrote one long ago, and cast it by: Men are weary of our Controversies, and had rather all of us gave over. But if I should shew the errour and impertinency of every such word in your great Book, it might be a years work; when I look not to live so long; and it might make so great a Volume in Folio, that few I think would buy or read! And what great good will it do the world, to tell them how grossly you abuse the Chuch, and how confidently and voluminously you err?

As to your charge of Slandering you, and wronging the Church, and being unqualified for forgiveness, I have the same Accusations from Quakers, Anabaptists, Antinomians and Papists, almost in the same words: Within these two hours an ancient Doctor sent me as hard words [As being a self condemned person, to be forsaken, as opposing the Commands of God, and the Faith of Iesus,] for not yielding to his [asserting of the Seventh-day-Sabbath, and condemning the Lords-days observation.] I have these thirty six years lived under such Accusations: It is no new thing for Seducers to use affrighting words instead of proof, and to say, [Except ye be circumcised and keep the Law of Moses, you cannot be saved. It's the cry of most Sects, [You cannot be saved but in our way]

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. To the reader
  2. A late Letter from Mr. Dodwell, calling for more Answer, with the Answer to it, written…
  3. Mr. DODWEL's LEVIATHAN, or Absolute Destructive Prelacy, the Son of ABADDON APOLLYON, and…p. 1
  4. CHAP. II. His Schiswatical Church destroying Scheme Confuted.p. 7
  5. CHAP. III. The consequence of Mr. Dodwell's foresaid doctrine.p. 21
  6. CHAP. IV. My words of Gods Collation of Ministerial Authority, Vindicated from the…p. 27
  7. CHAP. V. Wherein Mr. Dodwell's deceits, and the danger of them do consist.p. 63

Other works by Richard Baxter

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.