Primary Source

A Search for the English Schismatic

Richard Baxter 1681
Baxter defends nonconformists against accusations of schism by distinguishing diocesan canons from persecuted nonconformists through careful case analysis.

EEBO-TCP A27030 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 11894721; STC/Wing Wing B1399; ESTC R6862

From the text

The opening of the work as printed, in the spelling of this edition.

THE strivings of Parliaments since Archbishop Laud's Government, against Innovations, Popery and Arbitrary overtopping Law, and their jealousies of the designs and progress, while they themselves were of the Old Church of England, do call us to think what the difference was between the Old and New.

HE that would know what the Old Church of England is, let him read,

I. The 39 Articles.

II. The Homilies.

III. The Apology, with Jewels defence.

IV. Nowell's Catechism.

V. Deus & Rex (all owned by the Church).

VI. Hookers Ecclesiastical Polity, in 8 Books.

VII. Bishop Bilson of Christian Subjection.

VIII. Bishop Downham de Antichristo.

IX. The great Writers against Popery, as Dr. Whitaker, Dr. Reynolds, Dr. Willet, Dr. Sutliff, Dr. White, Dr. Airy, Dr. Humphrey, Dr. Fulk, Dr. Prideaux, Dr. R. Abbot, Dr. Crakenthorp, Dr. Challoner, Dr. Hall, Bishop Usher, Dr. Davenant, Bishop Carlton, Chillingworth, Bishop Morton, &c.

X. The Writings against Bishop Laud, viz. Bishop Hall's Epistle to D. L. Archbishop G. Abbots, and Bishop R. Abbot's judgment of him, and his Tryal, with what was there charged against him.

XI. The Harmony of Confessions, and the Synod of Dort.

XII. King James's Works.

HE that would know what is the New Church of England, since Bishop Laud differs from the Old, let him read,

I. Dr. Heylin's Writings, Dr. Pocklingtons, Mr. Dows, Sybthorps and Mainwarings.

II. Heylin's Life of B. Laud, particularly his description of the designed reconciliation with the Papists.

III. Mr. Thorndike's Just weights and measures, and forbearance of Penalties.

IV. Archbishop Bramhall's book against me, explaining the new way in these particulars, 1. To abhor Popery. 2. That we all come under a Foreign Jurisdiction, obeying the Pope as the Western Patriarch, and also as the Principium unitatis to the universal Church, Governing by the Canons. 3. That Dissenters from this be accounted Schismaticks. 4. That we yield to what the Greeks have yielded, and be of their Religion. 5. That Grotius was a Protestant for the Church of England.

V. Dr. Parkers Preface to that book, and Dr. Pierce's defence of Grotius.

VI. Grotius his Volume and Notes on Cassander, specially his Discussio Apologetici Riveliani; in which he professeth, 1. That Rome is the Mistris-Church. 2. Sound in faith. 3. That he finds Protestants can never unite, but by uniting with Rome. 4. He owns the Doctrine of the Councils, even that of Trent. 5. The Pope to govern by the Canons of the Councils, and not arbitrarily. 6. Nor must invade the rights of Kings or Bishops. 7. That if the curiosities of the School-men, and the ill lives of the Clergy be disowned and amended, this much is enough to sober men. 8. And he saith that the English Bishops were many of his mind, tho' the Separatists were not.

VII. The Earl of Clarendon's Defence of Dr. Stillingfleet, laying the nature of Popery in their injury to Princes.

VIII. Guil. Forbes, Bishop of Edenborough his Irenicon.

IX. Mr. Dodwell's book against Schism, and the same doctrine maintained by others who nullifie Ministry and Churches, whose Episcopal Ordination hath not come down from the Apostles uninterrupted.

X. The Bishops endeavours since 1660, to silence, fine, imprison, banish, and drive five miles from all Corporations, &c. all such as receive not the Impositions. Together with the rest of the true History of these last Twenty years.

The particulars are not now to be recited.

p. 1A SEARCH FOR THE ENGLISH SCHISMATICK: OR, The True Characters of the several Accused Parties, by which they may be discerned.

p. 1CHAP. I. The Parties Accused.

The Parties questioned are, I. The Papists. II. The Diocesan-Militants, or Canoneers. III. The Passive peaceable Conformists. IV. The Meer Nonconformists. V. The Sectarian Church-Appropriators, and Causeless Separatists and Dividers.

I. THERE is no Sect of Christians which maketh so great use of their pretence to Unity, and crying down Heresie, Schism and Separation, as the Papists do; and yet are the greatest Schismaticks and Dividers, as thus appeareth.

1. They have a self-made humane universal Church, p. 2feigning the Pope to be the rightful Head of all the Christian World.

2. They exclude all from Christs Chuch, who are not the Popes Subjects, though at the Antipodes, where he never came nor sent.

3. They presume to make universal Laws for all the World.

4. They Curse men from Christ by Excommunications, who refuse such subjection and obedience to these Laws.

5. They have introduced many new Articles of Faith, on pretence of declaring and expounding Faith.

6. They have multiplied corrupting additions in the Christian Worship.

7. Their regular objective Religion now consisteth in so great a number of the Decrees of Councils, as no Christians can well understand, while they accuse Gods Laws as unintelligible.

8. They can give us no certainty which of these Councils are obligatory to us, while they contradict each other.

9. They agree not of the Essence of Christianity, or necessary truths; but resolve all into the uncertainty of [sufficient Proposals].

10. They damn men as Hereticks that deny not all humane sense, believing there is no Bread and Wine, when they see and taste them.

11. They burn such as Hereticks, and are for tormenting Inquisitions to destroy them.

12. They bind Temporal Lords to exterminate all such, and to swear to do it; and this on pain of Excommunication, Deposition and Damnation: So that a Protestant Kingdom under a true Papist King, hath a King that is p. 3thus bound to exterminate his Subjects, if he be able; and professeth to do it on these three penalties, his Salvation lying on it.

p. 313. They decree the giving of his Dominions to another, and absolving his Subjects from their Oaths of Fidelity, if he obey not.

14. They decree, that it's Heresie to hold that a King hath the power of Investing Bishops, and that he is not thus subject to the Pope.

15. They tolerate their chief Doctors to write, that a Heretick is no King, at least if Excommunicate, and may lawfully be killed.

Keep reading

Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.

Create a Free Account to Read

Contents

  1. POSTSCRIPT.
  2. CHAP. I. The Parties Accused.p. 1
  3. CHAP. II. The Case of the Diocesan-Canoneers, or Zealots for Imposition of Conformity.p. 7
  4. CHAP. III. The Meer Nonconformist.p. 29

Other works by Richard Baxter

→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→
→

Related works

→
→
→
→
→

Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.