Schism Detected in Both Extremes
EEBO-TCP A27028 (TEI), original spelling, printed page numbers. EEBO 12393808; STC/Wing Wing B1396; ESTC R16323
From the text
The opening of the work as printed, from p. 1, in the spelling of this edition.
SAITH THE RESOLVER,
§. 1. THE Church is a Body or society of men separated from the rest of the World, and united to God and to themselves by a Divine Covenant.
A. He saith this is the plainest description he can give: That is not the fault of his Auditors or Readers. 1. As to the Genus, a Community of equals without Rulers is a body: but I suppose he meaneth not such. 2. Is it enough that it be of Men? sure now they should be Christians? 3. Many are separated from the rest of the World, secundum quid, that are no Christians; some in one respect and some in another, and none in all respects. 4. Vnited to God, is an ambiguous word, no Creature is Vnited to him perfectly so as to be thereby what he is, God, in the created Nature. Only Christ is united to him Hypostatically in his created Nature. All are so far united to him in natural being, as that in him they live and move and have their being: And the Nature of man is one sort of his Image: All things are united to him as effects to their constant efficient. The Church should not be defined without any mention of Christ: The Churches Union with God is by Christ. 5. Christ himself as Head is an essential part of the Church, and should not be left out of a Definition, thô the meer Body may in common speech be called the Church, as the People may be called a Kingdom. 6. Will any Divine Covenant serve? or must it not be only the Baptismal Covenant? 7. Is it called Divine only as made by God, or as commanded by God and made by Man, or as mutual? Certainly Gods Law and offered or Conditional Promise is most frequently called His Covenant in Scripture; and this uniteth not men to God, till they consent and Covenant with him. Their own Covenant Act is necessary hereto: And that is a Divine Covenant, only as commanded, and accepted and done by Gods assisting Grace. 8. The form of a Church is Relative, and the Terminus is essential to a Relation. It is no definition that hath not the End p. 2of the Association: Therefore this is none at all; and so the beginning tells us what to expect.
p. 2This description hath nothing in it▪ but what may agree to divers forms of Society, and so hath not the form of a Church: And if he intended not a Definition, but a loose description, I would a defining Doctor had had the Chair, during this controversie.
Let us try this description upon a Mahometan Kingdom, Army, or Navy, or suppose them meer Deists.
1. Such a Kingdom, Army, or Navy may be a Society. 2. Of Men. 3. Separated from the rest of the World secundum quid & ad hoc (and none are separated from it simpliciter & ad omnia: e. g. No man is Separated from the common humanity, No Deist from any but Atheists, and no Christian in believing a God and the Law of Nature and Nations.) 4. They are Vnited to God so far as owning a God and Worshipping him amounts to, besides the Union of the Creature with the Creator in whom he liveth, &c. And no unregenerate ungodly Christian is united to him savingly. 5. They are united among themselves. 6. This is by a Covenant: 7. And by a Covenant Divine, as to command, approbation and object. It is God that they Covenant to own and obey: The common Profession of the Mahometans, is, There is one God, and Mahomet is his Prophet. It is Divine in tantum as commanded. For God Commandeth all men to Own him; to believe that God is, and that he is the Rewarder of them that diligently seek him: And God so far approveth it: St. James saith, (Thou dost well) to him that believeth there is a God, much more that is professedly devoted to him.
Let us by this examine the Jewish Church: Jews now may be 1. A Body, 2. Of Men, 3. Separated from the rest of the World, even in Religion and Church pretensions. 4. United to God as Creatures, as Men, as the corporal seed of Abraham, and as professing Belief, Love and Obedience to God, as their God. 5. Strictly united among themselves: 6. By a Covenant, 7. Which God once commanded, and still approveth so far as they own God.
Let us consider whether this description take not in, those in every Nation that fear God and work Righteousness, that never heard of Christ, (being thus combined.) And whether the Kingdom of God, be not larger than his Church: Joyn the Head and Tail of this mans book together, and by the Head (the description) for ought I see, Jews, Mahometans, if not almost; all Heathens, are the Church: But at the End, I think none on Earth is the Church: At least none that separate from a pair of Organs, or an ignorant Curate; Nor can any man know who.
p. 2Page 2. §. 2. He explaineth his Word [Body] as opposed to a confused Multitude.
A. But a Community of Equals, that have no Governours, may have order, and be no confused Multitude. And he himself after pleads over much for ◊◊◊◊necessity of Rulers.
p. 3P. 3. §. 3. And in many places, his Confusion and grand errour is repeated, that the Christian Church is but one: p. 7. We know no Church but what all Christians are members of by Baptsme, which is the Vniversal Church; p. 8. There is but one Church, of which all Christians are members, as there is but one Covenant; p. 19. If there be but one Church and one Communion, of which all true Christians are members, &c. p. 23. I am no otherwise a member of any particular Church, than I am of the Vniversal: p. 40. It's a schismatical Notion of membership that divides the Christian Church into distinct memberships, and therefore into the distinct Bodyes: And. p. 19. and often he saith, those Churches which are not members of each other, are separate Churches and Schismaticks.
Keep reading
Full text search, AI synthesis across 1,277 Reformed primary sources, and seamless reading — all in one place.
Create a Free Account to ReadContents
- The English Schismatick, detected and confuted: Occasioned by a Resolver of Cases about…p. 1
- CHAP. I.p. 1
- CHAP. II.p. 18
- CHAP. III.p. 19
- CHAP. IV.p. 20
- TO THE READER.
- THE SECOND PART AGAINST SCHISM, &c. The Reasons of Mr. Raphson, and such others, against…p. 1
Other works by Richard Baxter
Related works
Browse the full Reformed theology catalog — 1,277 primary sources.